Side Baskets$5.50Baskets of our chips, fries, curly fries, tots, broasted potatoes, or sweet potato fries. G
Stache Wings
6 Wings8.00 12 Wings…14.00 6
(Each Additional Sauce$0.50
Tower of Tortillas$11.75Hand cut tortillas loaded with our Cheddar and Jack cheeses, pico de gallo, & black olives. Served with a side of salsa & loaded sour cream. GV
Ultimate Tower$15.50Our hand cut tortillas loaded with our house smoked pulled pork, caramelized onions, bleu cheese & coleslaw.
Garlic Bread$8.50Classic garlic bread loaded with seasoned butter and parmesan cheese. Served with marinara.
Top with mozzarella cheese for$2.00
Cheese Curds$10.50Our famous Wisconsin cheese curd trio of cheddar, bacon, & jalapeño curds served with a side of Southwest, marinara, or ranch sauce.
Spin Dip$10.75House made spinach & artichoke dip, baked golden brown & served with house made tortilla chips.
Quesadillas$11.75Large grilled tortilla filled with shredded cheddar & Jack cheese, pico de gallo, & served with salsa & sour cream. V
Giant Pretzel$15.00Try one of Papa’s favorites! A traditional giant soft pretzel brought to us by the Milwaukee Pretzel Company. Served with our house made beer cheese, nacho cheese dip, or spicy honey mustard.
Guac & Chips$10.50Freshly made guacamole served with a basket of our hand cut tortillas.
Salsa Trio$8.50This trio includes a bright salsa verde, a sweet pineapple pico de gallo, & a spicy salsa roja. Served with a basket of our seasoned hand cut tortilla chips.
Bacon Wrapped Water Chestnuts$12.50Sticky & sweet sauce baked into smoky bacon, wrapped around crunchy water chestnuts. Yum!
Bacon Chicken Bites$13.00Tender bites of chicken wrapped in crispy applewood smoked bacon, coated in our bourbon glaze! Served with a side of our house made ranch.
Adult Chicken Tenders$15.006-piece chicken tenders fried golden brown and served with your choice of chips, fries or curly fries.
Jalapeño Poppers$12.00Crispy breaded cream cheese & jalapeño bites. Served with a side of our house made ranch to dip.
Fried Eggplant$11.50Breaded sliced eggplant fried golden brown. Served with a side of marinara sauce to dip.
Mac & Cheese Bites$10.50Eight golden bites filled with macaroni & bended cheedar cheeses. Served with a side of our house made ranch.
Mexican Street Corn Dip$11.75Traditional Mexican street corn flavors transformed into the creamiest corn-filled dip. Served with a basket of our hand cut tortilla chips.
Smash Burger$16.00Two of our steak burgers smashed onto a hot griddle, making a caramelized crispy outer crust and a juicy tender inside. Topped with American Cheese, Bacon, and fried sweet onions. Served on a toasted Brioche bun.
Southern Bell$16.25Grilled chicken breast topped with Jack straw onions, Pepper Jack cheese, lettuce, sliced tomato, chipotle mayo and served on a toasted hoagie.
Bye Bye Babe$15.50House smoked BBQ pork piled high on grilled Texas toast. Loaded with cheddar, Big Sexy sauce & coleslaw.
Want something simpler? We can make a plain bbq pork sandwich on our Texas toast for$11.00
The Hangover$15.50A steak burger grilled on a toasted bun, with smoked bacon, caramelized onions, & pepper jack cheese. Topped with a fried egg & BIG sexy sauce.
Papa’s BLT$14.00Toasted Texas toast brushed with sriracha mayo, loaded with smoked bacon, lettuce, & tomato.
Philly Cheese Steak$16.00Thinly sliced ribeye steak, grilled with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, shredded mozzarella, served on a toasted French roll. Served with a side of au jus.
Steak Sandwich$16.50A grilled sirloin steak sandwich topped with sauteed mushrooms and onions and served on a hoagie and your choice of fries, curly fries, or chips.
Grown Up Grilled Cheese$13.50A classic favorite spruced up! Pepper jack, cheddar, & American cheeses, with bacon sandwiched between two slices of Texas toast & grilled to perfection..
“Make Burgers Great Again”$15.50Signature 1/3 lb. steak burger topped with mushrooms, swiss cheese, & bacon.
Broasted Chicken Sandwich$15.00Broasted chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, onion, & mayo served on a brioche bun.
Broasted Pork Chop Sandwich$16.50Broasted pork chop, lettuce, tomato, onion, & mayo served on a brioche bun
O’Kelly$16.50A classic Reuben sandwich of thinly sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and 1000 island dressing grilled between two slices of rye bread.
Fish Sandwich$10.00Breaded white fish fillet on a toasted brioche bun w/tomato, lettuce, pickles, & American cheese. Served with a side of our homemade tartar sauce.
Ultimate Tots$14.00Our house smoked pulled pork, caramelized onions, bleu cheese, & coleslaw drizzled with our Big Sexy sauce & served in a skillet full of our golden tots.
Philly Tots$15.50Golden tots loaded with thinly sliced ribeye steak, green peppers, onions, mushrooms & shredded mozzarella cheese.
1/2 Broasted Chicken$16.50Served with choice of potato, coleslaw, and biscuit.
8pc. Broasted Chicken$20.00Served with 2 biscuits and 2 sides of coleslaw. Side potato not included.
2pc. Broasted Chicken$12.00 / $14.00 for all white meat.Your choice of breast & wing (white meat) or thigh & leg (dark meat). Served with a choice of potato, coleslaw, & a biscuit.
Fish Sandwich$11.50Breaded white fish fillet on a toasted brioche bun w/tomato, lettuce, pickles, & American cheese. Served with a side of our homemade tartar sauce.
Hand Battered Cod$13.00Beer battered fillets fried golden brown, served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & lemon wedge.
Breaded Perch$13.50Breaded fillets fried golden brown, served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & lemon wedge.
Breaded Shrimp$14.00Ten panko breaded shrimp fried golden brown, served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & cocktail sauce.
Baked Cod$13.00Tender cod fillets baked in a buttery white wine sauce served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & lemon wedge.
Walleye$17.00One large walleye fillet beer battered & deep fried to perfection, served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & lemon wedge.
Potato Pancakes$3.00Two homemade potato pancakes served with applesauce or syrup!
House Salad
Side$7.00 Large…$9.00
Chicken Salad$12.50Your choice of blackened chicken breast, broasted chicken fillet, or a grilled chicken breast on a bed of mixed greens topped with bacon, cheddar, tomatoes & sliced red onions.
Classic Caesar$10.50Chopped romaine tossed with our fresh house made Caesar dressing, house made garlic crusted croutons, & shaved parmesan cheese.
Taco Salad$14.50Seasoned ground beef, fiesta blended cheeses, and Pico de Gallo on a bed of mixed greens and served with a sour cream, tortilla chips and your choice of salsa Verde, sweet pineapple Pico, or spicy salsa Roja.
Steak Lovers Salad$16.50Tender strips of our grilled steak on a bed of mixed greens, mandarin orange, red onion, tomatoes, & sliced avocado.
Soup of the day$6.00 Bowl…$7.00Cup
Skillets & Pastas
Sexy Mac & Cheese$15.50Three cheese pasta loaded in a packed iron skillet with pulled pork & our Big Sexy sauce topped with golden panko breadcrumbs & then baked to perfection.
Skillet Mac & Cheese$15.50Three cheese pasta loaded in a packed iron skillet w/ andouille sausage & bacon topped with golden panko breadcrumbs & then baked to golden perfection.
Chicken Alfredo$16.25Creamy house made alfredo sauce served with linguine pasta topped with sliced grilled chicken breast & parmesan cheese.
“Jump the Border” Wrap$15.50Grilled steak strips, mixed greens, sliced red onion, green pepper, queso fresco, & our Southwest dressing.
Chicken Caesar Wrap$14.50Grilled chicken, chopped romaine lettuce, house made garlic crushed croutons, parmesan cheese, & fresh house made Caesar dressing.
Pizza
Gluten free crust is available for additional charge$3.00
The Hawaiian Hammer
Training Wheel$15.50 12”…$17.50 14”…$19.50
The “PMS”
Training Wheel$17.00 12”…$19.00 14”…$21.00
Sammi's Demise
Training Wheel$16.00 12”…$18.00 14”…$20.00
The Porker
Training Wheel$16.00 12”…$18.00 14”…$20.00
Buffalo Chicken
Training Wheel$16.00 12”…$18.00 14”…$20.00
Create Your Own
Training Wheel$15.50 12”…$17.50 14”…$19.50
Additional Toppings Each
Training Wheel$1.00 12″… $1.25 14″…$1.50
Additional Premium Toppings
Mac & Cheese: TW$3, 12”-$4, 14”-$5
Shredded Smoked Pork: TW$3, 12”-$4, 14”-$5
Sammies
Mary’s Open Faced Burger$15.501/3 lb. Steak burger topped w/ pesto, fried mozzarella, basil, sliced red onion, & shredded parmesan on garlic buttered Texas Toast.
BIG Sexy Burger$15.50Our signature 1/3 lb. Steak burger topped w/ bacon, our 3-cheese blend, jalapeños, jack straw onions, & our signature Big Sexy sauce on a toasted.
The Old School$15.501/3 lb. Steak burger with bacon, cheddar, tomato, lettuce, & bbq mayo on a toasted bun.
Loaded Tots
Buffalo Chicken Tots$14.00Buffalo chicken, house cheddar cheese, diced tomato, red onion, & jalapeños served in a skillet full of our golden tots with a Buffalo Ranch drizzle.
Genuine Broaster Chicken
(Please allow extra time for broasting)$2.00Add Served with your choice of hand cut fries, curly fries or house made chips.