SusieCakes x See’s Candies Milk Bordeaux™ Cupcake 4-Box$23.00LIMITED TIME ONLY. Four mouthwatering chocolate cupcakes frosted with brown sugar buttercream, covered in chocolate sprinkles and topped with a See's Candies Milk Bordeaux™ candy piece. Available through 10/18 or until sold out.
SusieCakes x Komen Ribbon Cupcake 4-box$25.0024HR NOTICE REQUIRED. Same day orders will not be fulfilled.
SusieCakes x Komen Ribbon Flourless Cupcake 4-box$27.0024HR NOTICE REQUIRED. Same day orders will not be fulfilled.
Snickerdoodle Cupcake 4-box$23.00SEASONAL. Four cinnamon cupcakes frosted with cinnamon buttercream, topped with a buttery snickerdoodle cookie crumble. Available through 11/1.
Pumpkin Cinnamon Loaf$19.99SEASONAL. Pumpkin loaf made with Libby’s pumpkin & our harvest spice blend, topped with a sweet cinnamon glaze. Serves 8. Available through 11/1.
Banana Chocolate Chip Cake$54.99SEASONAL. 4-layer cake baked with ripe bananas and semi-sweet chocolate chips, filled and frosted with our signature cream cheese frosting, and brown jimmies trimming the outside base. Available through 11/1.
German Chocolate Cake$54.99SEASONAL. 4-layer chocolate cake layered with our hand-stirred caramel filling made with Texas pecans and shredded coconut, frosted with chocolate buttercream, and topped with an extra spoonful of the same delicious filling. Available through 11/14.
Apple Crumble Pie$45.99SEASONAL. Our bestselling 9-inch pie loaded with Granny Smith apples and brown sugar on a flaky pie crust, topped with a sweet handmade crumble. Available through 12/24.
Take & Bake: Apple Crumble Pie$45.99SEASONAL. Enjoy our bestselling pie fresh from your own oven! Packed with Granny Smith apples and brown sugar on a flaky pie crust, and finished with a sweet handmade crumble. Just bake at home and fill your kitchen with the smell of homemade pie. Available through 12/24.
Boo! - Chocolate / Chocolate
Boo! - Red Velvet$27.00Available through 10/31.
Halloween Cupcake DIY Box$63.00A dozen assorted chocolate and vanilla cupcakes for you and your family to decorate. Includes orange-colored vanilla buttercream, chocolate buttercream, black/orange/purple sanding sugar, and Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Halloween Cupcake Deco 4-box$21.00Four cupcakes topped with Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Halloween Cupcake Deco 8-box$42.008 cupcakes topped Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Halloween Cupcake Deco 12-box$63.0012 cupcakes topped with Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Halloween Mini Cupcakes$35.88One dozen bite sized cupcakes topped with Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Dia de los Muertos Cake$69.99Cake pictured – 9" cake with orange inscription
Jack-O-Lantern Cake$69.99Cake pictured – 9" cake with black inscription
Black SusieKitty Cake$77.99Cake pictured – 6" cake with no inscription"
Spider Web Vintage Cake$89.99Cake pictured – 9" cake with green inscription
Spider Hero Cake$84.99Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration Cake with black inscription
Despicable Cake$74.99Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration Cake with black inscription
Andy's Room Cake$89.99Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration Cake with red inscription
Rainbow Sprinkle Cake$67.99Cake pictured – 6" Vanilla Celebration with white outside buttercream
Floral Heart Cake$82.99Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration with white vanilla buttercream
Football Cake$64.99Cake pictured – 9" cake with no inscription
Holly Cake$59.99Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration with no inscription
Holiday Wreath Cake$79.99Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration with red inscription"
Christmas Vintage Wreath Cake$84.99Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration with red inscription"
Holiday Cookie Decorated Cake$105.99Cake pictured – 9" cake with green inscription"
Hanukkah Vintage Cake$84.99Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration with Hanukkah blue inscription
Hanukkah Cookie Decorated Cake$105.99Cake pictured – 9" cake with Hanukkah Blue inscription
Black Heart Vintage Cake
Halloween Cupcake Deco 4-box$21.00Four cupcakes topped with Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Halloween Cupcake Deco 8-box$42.008 cupcakes topped Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Halloween Cupcake Deco 12-box$63.0012 cupcakes topped with Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Halloween Mini Cupcakes$35.88One dozen bite sized cupcakes topped with Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Halloween Flourless Cupcake 4-box$23.00Four cupcakes topped with Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
Cupcakes
SusieCakes x See’s Candies Milk Bordeaux™ Cupcake 4-Box$23.00LIMITED TIME ONLY. Four mouthwatering chocolate cupcakes frosted with brown sugar buttercream, covered in chocolate sprinkles and topped with a See's Candies Milk Bordeaux™ candy piece. Available through 10/18 or until sold out.
Halloween Cupcake DIY Box$63.00A dozen assorted chocolate and vanilla cupcakes for you and your family to decorate. Includes orange-colored vanilla buttercream, chocolate buttercream, black/orange/purple sanding sugar, and Halloween-themed sprinkles. Available through 10/31.
SusieCakes x Komen Ribbon Cupcake 4-box$25.0024HR NOTICE REQUIRED. Same day orders will not be fulfilled.
SusieCakes x Komen Ribbon Flourless Cupcake 4-box$27.0024HR NOTICE REQUIRED. Same day orders will not be fulfilled.
Snickerdoodle Cupcake 4-box$23.00SEASONAL. Four cinnamon cupcakes frosted with cinnamon buttercream, topped with a buttery snickerdoodle cookie crumble. Available through 11/1.
Holiday Mini Cupcakes
Four Vanilla with SusieBlue buttercream, red Happy Holidays inscription & snowflake sprinkles
Available through 12/24."$75.00
Four Vanilla with SusieBlue buttercream, red Merry Christmas inscription & holiday sprinkles
4 Box Cupcake Assortment$21.00Baked from scratch, daily in our on-site kitchen. Decorations may change depending on season or holiday.
8 Box Cupcake Assortment$42.00Baked from scratch, daily in our on-site kitchen. Decorations may change depending on season or holiday.
12 Box Cupcake Assortment$63.00Baked from scratch, daily in our on-site kitchen. Decorations may change depending on season or holiday.
Gender Reveal Cupcake Box
Happy Birthday Cupcake Dozen Box$75.00One dozen cupcakes - assorted chocolate, vanilla & red velvet, personally inscribed for a birthday celebration!
Mini Bouquet Box
Mini Cupcake Assorted Dozen Box$35.88Bite-sized cupcakes, baked from scratch daily! Perfect for parties, celebrations, kids’ birthdays, or anytime you want an easy-to-share treat. Available in Red Velvet, Vanilla, Chocolate, and Flourless Chocolate dozen boxes.
SusiePink Cupcake DIY Kit$63.00A dozen assorted chocolate and vanilla cupcakes for you and your family to decorate. Includes SusiePink and white vanilla buttercream, sprinkles, and sanding sugar.
So - Vanilla Cupcake/SusieBlue Buttercream$25.00Much! - Red Velvet Cupcake/Cream Cheese Frosting
Thanksgiving Mini Cupcakes
Single Cupcake$5.25Baked from scratch, daily in our on-site kitchen. Decorations may change depending on season or holiday.
Hanukkah Frosted Sugar Cookie Platter
Take & Bake: Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough$35.99Bake and save! Our classic chocolate chip cookie dough is now available in convenient 12-count packs. Just pop them in the oven and enjoy warm, freshly baked cookies anytime.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Platter$71.85Everyone’s favorite classic! 18 soft, buttery cookies baked with brown sugar and plenty of semi-sweet chocolate chips.
Chocolate Chip Cookies 4-box$15.96Everyone’s favorite classic! Four soft, buttery cookies baked with brown sugar and plenty of semi-sweet chocolate chips.
Snickerdoodle Cookie 4-box$15.96Our snickerdoodle cookies are classic! Characterized by their pillowy texture and irresistible cinnamon-sugar coating, these cookies have a slightly crispy exterior and a soft, tender center, making them a true crowd-pleaser.
Turkey Frosted Sugar Cookie Platter
Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake$34.0024HR NOTICE REQUIRED. Same day orders will not be fulfilled. Our delicious chocolate chip cookie just got bigger! Enjoy an extra-large 8in cookie cake decorated with a buttercream and confetti sprinkle border and your custom inscription.
By the Slice
2 Specialty Cake Slices$16.50Pick two decadent slices of our handcrafted specialty cakes. Each slice is made with premium ingredients and unique flavor combinations, perfect for treating yourself or sharing a sweet moment with someone special.
Tasting Kit
Cake Flight$59.75The perfect way to try all seven current flavors of Susie’s cakes. One slice of Vanilla Celebration, Old-Fashioned Chocolate, Red Velvet, Classic Marble, Carrot, and one slice each of our 2 rotating cake flavors.
Single Cake Slice$8.25Each slice is made with premium ingredients and unique flavor combinations, perfect for treating yourself or sharing a sweet moment with someone special.
Cakes - Available Today
Banana Chocolate Chip Cake$54.99SEASONAL. 4-layer cake baked with ripe bananas and semi-sweet chocolate chips, filled and frosted with our signature cream cheese frosting, and brown jimmies trimming the outside base. Available through 11/1.
German Chocolate Cake$54.99SEASONAL. 4-layer chocolate cake layered with our hand-stirred caramel filling made with Texas pecans and shredded coconut, frosted with chocolate buttercream, and topped with an extra spoonful of the same delicious filling. Available through 11/14.
Celebration Cake$54.996-layers of vanilla cake baked with colorful sugar confetti, filled & frosted with our signature retro-blue vanilla frosting.
Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake$54.99“Just like you remember!” 6-layer, towering high, moist chocolate cake layered and frosted in rich, dark chocolate buttercream frosting.
Southern Red Velvet Cake$49.994-layer deep red, moist cake lightly flavored with cocoa, filled & frosted with traditional cream cheese frosting.
Classic Marble Cake$49.994 layers of vanilla and chocolate cake marbled together with chocolate chips. Layered with vanilla buttercream and frosted with chocolate buttercream & a decorative band of white vanilla buttercream at the base.
Carrot Cake$49.994-layer cake baked with pecans & golden raisins, layered with our unique “praline filling,” and frosted with traditional cream cheese frosting.
Candles Cake
Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration Cake and SusiePink inscription$59.99
Daisy Cake
Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration Cake and SusieBlue inscription$54.99
Dinosaur Cake
Strawberry Fields Cake$69.9924HR NOTICE REQUIRED. Same day orders will not be fulfilled.
Taco Cake
Susie's Vanilla Cake (made without gluten)$54.99NEW! 24-hr notice required. Susie's Vanilla Cake (made without gluten). Cake is 4 layers and is made with SusieBlue vanilla buttercream.
1/4 Sheet Cake48-HOUR NOTICE REQUIRED. 1/4 sheet cake. Cake pictured - Chocolate with white vanilla buttercream inside and out.
Traditional Pumpkin Pie
Apple Crumble Pie$45.99SEASONAL. Our bestselling 9-inch pie loaded with Granny Smith apples and brown sugar on a flaky pie crust, topped with a sweet handmade crumble. Available through 12/24.
Pumpkin Cheesecake Slice
Take & Bake: Apple Crumble Pie$45.99SEASONAL. Enjoy our bestselling pie fresh from your own oven! Packed with Granny Smith apples and brown sugar on a flaky pie crust, and finished with a sweet handmade crumble. Just bake at home and fill your kitchen with the smell of homemade pie. Available through 12/24.
Whipped Cream (12 oz)$3.95The perfect topping to any of our seasonal pies! Add this fluffy, house whipped cream to your pie order. Available through 12/24.
Susie's Vanilla Cake (made without gluten)$54.99NEW! 24-hr notice required. Susie's Vanilla Cake (made without gluten). Cake is 4 layers and is made with SusieBlue vanilla buttercream.
Southern Pecan Pie
Apple Crumble Pie$45.99SEASONAL. Our bestselling 9-inch pie loaded with Granny Smith apples and brown sugar on a flaky pie crust, topped with a sweet handmade crumble. Available through 12/24.
Take & Bake: Apple Crumble Pie$45.99SEASONAL. Enjoy our bestselling pie fresh from your own oven! Packed with Granny Smith apples and brown sugar on a flaky pie crust, and finished with a sweet handmade crumble. Just bake at home and fill your kitchen with the smell of homemade pie. Available through 12/24.
Holiday Frosted Sugar Cookie Platter
Apple Crumble Pie$45.99SEASONAL. Our bestselling 9-inch pie loaded with Granny Smith apples and brown sugar on a flaky pie crust, topped with a sweet handmade crumble. Available through 12/24.
Take & Bake: Apple Crumble Pie$45.99SEASONAL. Enjoy our bestselling pie fresh from your own oven! Packed with Granny Smith apples and brown sugar on a flaky pie crust, and finished with a sweet handmade crumble. Just bake at home and fill your kitchen with the smell of homemade pie. Available through 12/24.
Menorah Cake
Cake pictured – 9" Vanilla Celebration with Hanukkah Blue inscription$69.99