NextEats › New York › Food in Bay Shore › Goody Two Shoes › Menu Goody Two Shoes menu (As of 10/29)
42 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Queso Fries Gooey Goodness Poured Tableside $13.00 Deviled Eggs Bacon and Chives $13 / $19 Fish & Chips $19 / $16 BEER-BATTERED COD, SHOESTRING FRIES, TARTAR SAUCE, MALT VINEGAR Birria Egg Rolls $16 / $15 BRAISED SHORT RIB, MOZZARELLA, ONION, CILANTRO. CONSOMME FOR DIPPING Pigs in a Blanket $15 / $16 EVERYTHING BAGEL SEASONING, HOT MUSTARD, QUESO Feta Cheese Bunuelos $16 / $19 CASSAVA DOUGH BALLS STUFFED WITH FETA, HOT HONEY DRIZZLE, SIDE OF TZATZIKI Mezze Plate $19 / $17 ZUCCHINI-WRAPPED FETA KABOB, GARLIC HUMMUS, MARINATED OLIVES, CRUDITE, GRIDDLED FLATBREAD Flatbread $17 / $18 BRIE, MOZZARELLA, ROSEMARY, CAPICOLA, SPICY HONEY Nachos Grandes $18 / $17 BEEF & BEAN CHILI, LETTUCE, TOMATO, QUESO, JACK CHEESE, CHOPPED ONION, JALAPEÑO, CRUSHED AVOCADO, SOUR CREAM, HOUSE SALSA (SUB GRILLED CHICKEN +4) Chop Cheese Tacos $17 / $14 GRIDDLED BEEF, ONIONS, JALAPEÑOS, QUESO, LETTUCE, TOMATO, MAYO Spinach & Artichoke Dip With Tortilla Chips & Pita $14 / $16 Pupusas $16 / $13 HOUSE-MADE MASA CAKES STUFFED AND GRIDDLED. BRAISED BEEF AND MOZZARELLA Yucca Fries Spicy Ranch Drizzle, Avocado Dip $13 / $15 Sweet Potato Tacos $15 / $16 ROASTED SWEET POTATOES, GRILLED CORN, AVOCADO, COTIJA CHEESE, CILANTRO CREMA Chicken Quesadilla $16 / $13 GRILLED CHICKEN, JACK CHEESE, SPICY RANCH WITH SIDE OF SALSA & SOUR CREAM Mozzarella Sticks Giant Pretzel $16.00 FRESH-BAKED, SALTED PRETZEL WITH TRIO OF SAUCES Wings Bones or No Bones • SMALL $16 | LARGE $28 Sandwiches Korean Fried Chicken $19 / $18 HAND-DIPPED BREAST, GOCHU JONG, CHILI CRISP, PICKLED ONIONS, JALAPEÑO-CUCUMBER B&B PICKLS, CILANTRO CREMA Sweet & Spicy Grilled Chicken Melt $18.00 MOZZARELLA, SAUTEED ONIONS, JALAPEÑOS, HONEY DIJOB, GARLIC HERO Grilled Chicken Royale $18 / $19 BACON, CHEDDAR, CRUSHED AVOCADO, GARLIC AIOLI French Dip $19 / $17 GRIDDLED BEEF, PROVOLONE, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, GARLIC HERO, AU JUS Falafel Sammie $17.00 HOUSE-MADE FALAFEL PATTY, HUMMUS, SPIRALED BEETS & CARROTS, PICKLES, RED ONION, TZATZIKI ON A BRIOCHE BUN Salads, Bowls, & Soups $18.00 Beet & Arugula $18 / $13 GRILLED CHICKEN, SPIRALED BEETS, ARUGULA, SPINACH, FETA, SESAME SEEDS, HOUSE VINAIGRETTE Beef & Bean Chili Chopped Onion, Cheese, Jalapenos $13 / $19 Classic Cobb $19 / $18 GRILLED CHICKEN, ROMAINE, SPINACH, TOMATO, HARDBOILED EGGS, BACON, BLEU CHEESE, AVOCADO, WHITE BALSAMIC Chopped Salad $18 / $19 GRILLED CHICKEN, CUCUMBER, TOMATO, ONION, FETA, CHICKPEAS, ROMAINE, FRESH HERBS, LEMON, EVOO Greek Bowl $19.00 SPINACH, ROMAINE, CUCUMBER, TOMATO, CHICKPEAS, RED ONION, FETA, KALAMATA OLIVES, GRILLED CHICKEN, TZATZIKI, HUMMUS, LEMON, EVOO Harvest Bowl $19 / $9 BROWN RICE, FRESH SPINACH, GRILLED CHICKEN, ROASTED SWEET POTATOES, GRILLED CORN, RED PEPPERS, SPIRALED BEETS AND CARROTS, PICKLED RED ONION, COTIJA CHEESE, HONEY MUSTARD Grandma Debbie's Matzoh Ball Soup $9.00 BONE BROTH, CHICKEN, CARROTS. CURES EVERYTHING... Seasonal Soup de Jour See Server for Today's Offering $9.00 BUTCHER'S BLEND OF BRISKET, CHUCK, AND SHORT RIB. WITH SHOESTRING FRIES • Burgers Double Smash $16 / $19 TWIN SMASHBURGERS, ONIONS, PICKLES, KETCHUP, AMERICAN, ONPOTATO ROLLS Birria $19 / $18 BRAISED SHORT RIB, MOZZARELLA, PICKLED REN ONION, JALAPEÑOS, CILANTRO CREMA, CONSOMME FOR DIPPING Steakhouse Burger Bacon, Cheddar, Onion Haystack $18.00 French Onion Burger $18.00 DOUBLE-STACKED SMASH BURGERS, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, PROVOLONE CHEESE, GARLIC AIOLI, ON BRIOCHE SERVED WITH FRENCH ONION AU JUS FOR DIPPING Handhelds Plates $14.00 - - - - - - FOR THE TABLE - - - - - - French Toast Sticks Breakfast Fundido $17 / $16 QUESO, BLACK BEANS, BREAKFAST SAUSAGE, ONIONS, PEPPERS, TOMATO, JALAPEÑOS. TOPPED WITH A FRIES EGG. SERVED WITH TORTILLA CHIPS, GUAC, SALSA & SOUR CREAM Breakfast Slider Tower $16.00 CHEESE EGGS, BACON OR SAUSAGE, PILE OF FRIES, KETCHUP, SPICY RANCH, MAPLE MAYO FOR DIPPING. Avocado Flatbread $18.00 CRUSHED AVOCADO, 6-MINUTE EGGS, ARUGULA, TOMATO, CHOPPED BACON, JALAPEÑOS, EVERYTHING SEASONING OIL, FETA Brunch Burger $18 / $14 EVERYTHING CREAM CHEESE SPREAD, BACON, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, MAPLE MAYO The Bec $14 / $16 TWO FRIED EGGS, BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE ON A BRIOCHE BUN. SERVED WITH FRIES. Avocado BLT $16 / $18 TOASTED SOURDOUGH, CRUSHED AVOCADO, BACON, LETTUCE, SLAB TOMATO, GARLIC AIOLI. SERVED WITH FRIES Breakfast Birriarito $18.00 SCRAMBLED EGGS, BRAISED BEEF, REFRIED BEANS, FRIED YUCCA, CHEDDAR, JALAPEÑOS, CILANTRO CREMA CONSOMMÉ. SERVED WITH TORTILLA CHIPS, CRUSHED AVOCADO, SOUR CREAM Tostadas $16.00 CRISPY CORN TORILLAS, REFIRED BEANS, SHREDDED CABBAGE, FRIED EGGS, COTIJA CHEESE, SALSA ROJA Goody's Golden Pancakes $16 / $17 THREE HOUSE-MADE BUTTERMILK PANCAKES WITH HONEY BUTTER SYRUP, & CHOICE OF BACON OR SAUSAGE. CHOCOLATE CHIPS +1 Chicken & Waffles $17.00 BUTTERMILK WAFFLE POPS, DRY-RUBBED BONELESS WINGS, HOT HONEY, MAPLE SYRUP, HONEY BUTTER Coffee Aperol Spritz Aperol, Prosecco, Soda $14.00 Limoncello Spritz $14.00 LIMONCELLO, VODKA, PROSECCO, SIMPLE SYRUP, SODA Sunroom Spritz $14.00 APEROL, LEMON, EARL GRAY SIMPLE, ROSEMARY SPRIG Cocktails $13.00 Sweet Heat $13 / $14 HOUSE MADE LEMONADE WITH TABASCO ABSOLUT, TAJIN-SUGAR RIM. First Call $14 / $13 BOURBON, ESPRESSO,DEMERARA, REAGAN’S BITTERS, LEMON PEEL. Espresso Martini $15 / $14 VODKA,FRESHED BREWED ESPRESSO, CANTERA NEGRA, SHAVED CINNAMON. Bloody Mary $14.00 WITH ALL THE FIXINGS! CHOOSE YOUR LIQUOR: GHOST PEPPER TEQUILA, HORNITOS, TITOS, TABASCO ABSOLUT, BULLIET BOURBON. House-made Lemonade $14.00 TITOS & CHOICE OF: Hibiscus, Blood Orange, 1/2 & 1/2, Classic. Fig & Honey $14.00 KINSHIP GIN, BEEB’S FIG JAM, HONEY, PROSECCO. Red Santiago $14.00 TEQUILA, BLOOD ORANGE, LIME, AGAVE, SALTED RIM. Hot Honey Peach Marg $14.00 GHOST PEPPER INFUSED TEQUILA, LIME, HOT HONEY, PEACH, TAJIN RIM. Dragon Fruit Daiquiri $14.00 WHITE RUM, DRAGON FRUIT SIMPLE, FRESH LIME. Aperol, Prosecco, Soda $13 / $14 Blood Orange Spritz $14.00 FRESH BLOOD ORANGE JUICE, APEROL, PROSECCO, SODA Seasonal Spritz $14.00 OUR CLASSIC SPRITZ MADE WITH SEASONALLY AVAILABLE INGREDIENTS Classics $14.00 Americano House-made Lemonade $8.00 CHOICE OF: Hibiscus, Blood Orange, 1/2 & 1/2, Classic. Drink Menu $15.00 WHAT'S GOOD! Dragonfruit Daiquiri $15 / $14 WHITE RUM, DRAGONFRUIT SIMPLE SYRUP, FRESH LIME Red Santiago $14 / $15 TEQUILA, BLOOD ORANGE, FRESH LIME, AGAVE, SALTED RIM Espresso Martini $15 / $14 VODKA, CANTERA NEGRA, FRESH-BREWED ESPRESSO, SHAVED CINNAMON Hibiscus Punch $14 / $15 RUM, HIBISCUS, LIME, DEMERARA, PEACH, BLOOD ORANGE Dirty Pickle Martini Codka, Pickle Brine, Olive Bitters $15.00 Beeb's Jam Sesh $15 / $14 VODKA, FRESH LIME JUICE, BEEB'S BLACKBERRY JAM, TOPPED WITH GINGER BEER Hot Honey Peach Marg $14 / $15 GHOST PEPPER INFUSED TEQUILA, LIME, HOT HONEY, PEACH Fig and Honey $15 / $14 KINSHIP GIN, BEEB'S FIG JAM, HONEY, PROSECCO Mez Bird $14.00 MEZCAL, APEROL, PINEAPPLE, LEMON, DEMERARA Nuts About Earl $14.00 BOURBON, EARL GREY SIMPLE SYRUP, ORANGE & BLACK WALNUT BITTERS Citrus & Ember $14.00 MEZCAL, CAPLE, GRAPEFUIT, FRESH LIME, DEMARA, SMOKED TAJIN RIM Carajillo $14.00 LICOR 43, FRESH-BREWED ESPRESSO, SHAVED CINNAMON Tea for Two Two Green Tea Shots $10 / $9 Cheap Thrills $9 / $12 PBR & A SHOT OF RACK GIN The B.o.b $12 / $10 SHOT OF SAMBUCA & A PINT OF PACIFICO Low Life Miller High Life & Aperol $10 / $9 Mind Eraser $9 / $8 VODKA, CANTERA NEGRA, CLUB SODA, SIPPY STRAW M&M $8.00 A SHOT OF MEZCAL & A SHOT OF MONTENEGRO Spritzes $13.00 Negroni Gin, Campari, Sweet Vermouth $14.00 Manhattan $14.00 RYE WHISKEY, SWEET VERMOUTH, ANGOSTURA BITTERS Old Fashioned $14.00 BOURBON, SIMPLE SYRUP, CARDAMOM AND ANGOSTURA BITTERS Vesper Gin, Vodka, Lillet Blanc $14.00 Paper Plane Bourbon, Amaro, Aperol, Fresh Lemon $14.00 French Gimlet Kinship Gin, Elderflower Liqueur, Lime $14.00 NY Sour $14 / $13 BOURBON, FREHS LEMON, SIMPLE SYRUP, RED WINE FLOAT Amaretto Sour $13 / $14 AMARETTO, BOURBON, FRESH LEMON, SIMPLE SYRUP, MARASCHINO LIQUEUR Aviation $14.00 KINSHIP GIN, MARASCHINO LIQUEUR, FRESH LEMON Wine $14.00 Hei Matau $14 / $13 SAUVIGNON BLANC / MARLBOROUGH / 2025 Ca Del Doge $13.00 PINOT GRIGIO / DELLE VENEZIE / 2025 Maison Idiart $13.00 ROSE / LOIRE VALLEY / 2024 San Joaquin $13.00 PINOT NOIR / CALIFORNIA / 2020 Old Mountain $13.00 CABERNET SAUVIGNON / NAPA / 2024 Laguna Alta $13.00 MALBEC / ARGENTINA / 2023 Cans & Bottles $6.00 PBR $6 / $8 Corona $8.00 Fat Tire $8.00 Heineken $8 / $10 High Noon $10 / $8 Michelob Ultra $8.00 Montauk Wave Chaser $8 / $7 Miller Lite $7 / $6 Miller High Life $6 / $8 Modelo Especial $8 / $10 Sun Cruiser Iced Tea/vodka $10.00 Spiked Ade Electric Blue $10.00 ALCOHOL FREe Universal Donor Blood Orange, Coconut Creme, Maple $9.00 Hi-lo Sweet Tea, Lemon, Hibiscus, Agave $9.00 Soul Elixer 2.0 $9.00 PEACH, GRAPEFRUIT, EARL GREY SIMPLE, GINGER BEER Beers $8.00 Athletic Run Wild IPA $8.00 Guinness 0 $8.00 Corona Cero $8.00 Mich Ultra 0.0 $8.00 Goody Two Shoes: hours and how to order