The Rustic Tavern
823 Newville Rd, Carlisle, PA
Menu (As of 10/31)
Salads
- Soup of the Day $4.99
- Baked French Onion $5.99
House Greek Salad
- Tavern Stuffed Mushrooms with Crab Imperial $14.99
Our own Rustic Tossed Salad
- potatoes, cheese, onions, and $12.99provolone cheese, then baked crisp and delicious —
- Romano cheese $10.99
- portabello mushrooms $15.99Gluten free flat bread available —
- [GF] Bacon Wrapped Scallops $14.99
- Saganaki Imported Flaming Greek Cheese $12.99
Jumbo Breaded Rustic Wings
- Dark Horse Chardonnay California $8.00 / $34.00
- Sweet Chili, Old Bay, Hot, Mild, BBQ, Hot Garlic with celery $8.99 • 1 lb for $13.99and bleu cheese 1/2 lb for
- William Hill Chardonnay California $9.00 / $36.00
- Ecco Domani Pinot Grigio Italy $8.00 / $34.00
- Breaded Buffalo Scallops with celery and bleu cheese $14.99
- Relax Riesling Germany $8.00 / $34.00
- Cheesy Garlic Bread with marinara sauce $9.99
- Santa Ema Sauvignon Blanc Chile $8.00 / $34.00
- Barefoot Moscato California (glass only) $9.00
Red
- tomato, onion, and Asian slaw $12.99
- Dark Horse Cabernet California $9.00 / $36.00
- Mirassou Pinot Noir California $9.00 / $36.00
Steamer
- Alamos Malbec Argentina $9.00 / $36.00
Apothic Winemaker’s Blend
- [GF] ½ lb. Steamed Texas Bay Shrimp $12.99
- (Zinfandel, Merlot, Cab, Syrah) $9.00 / $36.00
- [GF] 1 Dozen Fresh Steamed Clams in Garlic Butter $9.99
House Wine
- [GF] 1 Dozen Prince Edward Island Mussels in Garlic Butter $9.99
- Chardonnay, Cabernet, Merlot, White Zinfandel by the glass $7.00
- with drawn butter $12.99
Rustic Ribeye Steak Sandwich
- Squeezed OJ, Sierra Mist $7.50
Sugar, Muddled Orange
Coco Rita
- “Awarded Best” $18.99
- Sierra Mist $7.50
- Triple Sec, Sours, Lime $10.00
Mr. Boston Black Raspberry
- Juice in a copper mug $8.00
- Liqueur, Lemonade $8.00
Local
- Onions, and Mayo $11.99
- Porterhouse $34.99
- (Sautéed Shrimp, tomatoes, $10.99and spinach in a feta cream sauce)
- 2 lbs. of St. Louis Pork Ribs $26.99
- 1 lb $18.99
- Center Cut Pork Chops $19.99
Orange & Cream
Splash of Orange Juice
- Cheese, Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions $12.99
Crown Royal, Sour Apple
- Tomatoes, Feta & Greek Dressing $12.99
Midwest Beef
- 8 oz. Filet Mignon $34.99
- 12 oz. New York Strip $27.99
Add Ons
[GF] Broiled Fresh Maine Scallops
- Jumbo shrimp stuffed with Crab Imperial $29.99
- Fresh Northern Scallops broiled with old bay $29.99and lemon pepper butter —
- Lemon-Pepper Panko Broiled Haddock $19.99Fresh, lightly broiled with butter, panko seasoned
- Cheese Tortellini and Crab Alfredo $24.99Tossed with crab, shrimp, scallops in our house alfredo
- Broiled Shrimp Scampi $24.99in our feta cream sauce over fettuccine
[VB] Rustic Crab Cakes
- “Award Winning” in-house specialty $29.99
- chili marinade and broiled to perfection $22.99
Crab Stuffed Haddock
- Stuffed and baked in our creamy Imperial Sauce $26.99
Jumbo Breaded Shrimp
Rustic Pasta
- Choose three items with two sides $33.99
Rustic Center Cut Pork Chop
- in creamy alfredo sauce $22.99
Breaded Chicken Parmesan
- house marinara sauce $24.99
- Pounded & breaded chicken topped with marinara[VB] Broiled Rustic Crab Cake –
- and provolone. Served over spaghetti $18.991/2 lb. Steamed Northern Snow Crab Legs –
Breaded Shrimp
- Charred chicken tossed in our house alfredo & fettuccine $18.991/2 lb. Steamed Northern Snow Crab Legs –
Fettuccine Alfredo
- Fettuccine tossed in our house alfredo $16.99Stuffed Shrimp with Imperial Crab –
Veggie of the Day
Onion Rings
- Specialty Coffees $8.50 each
The Rustic Tavern: hours and how to order