NextEats › Ohio › Food in Lima › Steak House › Old City Prime › Menu Old City Prime
215 S Main St, Lima, OH
Menu (As of 10/30)
Dessert Appetizers $13.00 Everything Bagel Smoked Salmon Deviled Eggs $13 / $15 Norwegian smoked salmon, cream cheese, egg yolk, chives, and everything bagel seasoning Gourmet Wild Mushroom Flatbread $15.00 Cremini, shiitake, and oyster mushrooms, Neufchâtel cheese, fresh thyme, and truffle oil Soup $10.00 Butternut Squash Bisque $10.00 Roasted pumpkin seeds, nutmeg, and crème Side $9.00 Sweet Potato Steakhouse Fries $9.00 Crispy coated, served with maple Dijon dipping sauce Georgia Peach Cobbler Cheesecake and graham cracker crust $12.00 Raw Bar $29.00 Iced Seafood Plate $29 / $19 Three blue point oysters, three shrimp prawns, lobster cocktail, Maryland blue crab, traditional condiments Fresh Blue Point Oysters $19.00 East Coast blue point, on ice, traditional condiments (1/2 dozen or full dozen) Iced Jumbo Shrimp Prawns $4.00 each Cocktail sauce, fresh horseradish Table Appetizers $26.00 Lobster Meat Hot Pot $26 / $15 Shelled lobster meat, beurre blanc white wine butter sauce, toasted baguette crostini Oysters Rockefeller (4) $15 / $14 Spinach, bacon, parmesan Steakhouse Potato Skins $14 / $13 Piped with a filling of applewood smoked bacon, caramelized onions, parmesan, truffle salt, garlic chive cream cheese Bacon Wrapped Stuffed Medjool Dates $13.00 Goat cheese, applewood bacon, smokey chipotle, maple glaze Millionaire Bacon Pork Belly $13 / $15 Smoked, grilled, maple bourbon sauce Bacon Wrapped Sea Scallops $15 / $16 Maple sage glaze, maple bourbon sauce Maryland Lump Crab Cakes $16 / $21 Island jerk remoulade, mango pico, arugula Ahi Tuna & Spicy Crab Sushi Tower $21 / $14 Marinated ahi tuna poke, spicy crab salad, sushi rice, avocado, pickled cucumber, wonton chips, spicy mayo, unagi sauce & wasabi Lump Crab Stuffed Mushrooms $14 / $17 Maryland blue crab, parmesan, herbs British Isle Cheese Board $17.00 Crown stilton, Donovan's cheddar, double gloucester, grapes, berries, gourmet nuts, jam, crostini & water wafers Soups $13.00 Lobster Bisque $13 / $11 Lobster stock, cream, sherry, topped with lobster meat Baked, smoked provolone $11 / $10 Tomato Basil Bisque $10.00 Very light, touch of cream, parmesan crisp Ocp Classic Tableside Caesar Salad The original classic recipe $21.00 a la carte with entree $14.00 Chilled Iceberg Wedge a la carte $19.00 with entree $13 / $21 Steakhouse Cobb Salad $21 / $29 Mixed greens, dried cherries, apples, bleu cheese, candied pecans, bacon, pickled red onion, baby beets, pecan molasses dressing Ultimate Steakhouse Salad $29.00 Mixed greens, dried cherries, apples, bleu cheese, candied pecans, bacon, red onion, tomato, croutons, house-made dijon vinaigrette 7 oz. grilled chicken breast $10.00 Pacific salmon $16.00 3 jumbo shrimp $12.00 Grilled tenderloin filet tips $14.00 USDA Prime Graded Beef Cuts $59 -9 ounce filet Old City USDA Prime cuts are the most marbled, tender & flavorful, less than 3% of all beef is graded Prime. Beef Tenderloin Filet Mignon $59 -9 ounce filet Very lean and tender, house-made demi glace Usda Prime Ribeye Delmonico $64 / $59 16oz, center cut, well marbled, most flavorful Usda Prime New York Strip Steak $59 / $72 14oz, zero tail trimmed, center-cut, tender and very flavorful 12oz, 35 days aged Angus $72 / $69 Usda Prime Porterhouse Steak $69 / $46 22oz, filet tenderloin & NY Strip sirloin all in one steak Wagyu Top Sirloin Steak $46 / $42 10oz, Australian Greg Norman farms Wagyu marble score of 7 Pork Loin Chop $42.00 14oz, double bone French cut, marinated for tenderness, very moist and delicious. Served over Dijon demi glace Veal Loin Chop Ocp Surf & Turf $68.00 10oz Wagyu sirloin, cold water lobster tail South African Lobster Tail $27 / $13 highest quality cold water lobster, boriled, warmed butter 3 oysters $13 / $12 Three shrimp $12 / $19 Jumbo Lump Crab Oscar $19.00 Crab meat, asparagus, hollandaise Lobster Meat Hot Pot $19.00 Shelled lobster meat, beurre blanc white wine butter sauce Flavor Enhancements $4.00 House Demi Glace $4.00 24 hour, rich, house-roasted veal bone and red wine reduction sauce, all natural, no thickeners Blackened Cajun Rubbed Crust $4 / $6 Au Prouvé Style $6.00 Cracked peppercorns and cognac sauce Maitre D’ Butter-flamed Tableside $6.00 Bleu cheese infused sauce $6 / $4 Béarnaise Sauce $4 / $5 French sauce of herbs, eggs, butter Cognac Caramelized Onions $5.00 Sautéed Gourmet Mushrooms $5.00 Plated Entrees $39.00 Prime Beef Tips $39.00 Grilled, gourmet mushrooms, onions, house-made demi glace, Yukon Gold mashed potatoes Ocp Bacon Wrapped Ground Steak Meatloaf $39 / $37 House-ground wagyu & prime beef, bread crumbs, herbs, parmesan cheese, ketchup glaze, applewood smoked bacon Roasted Twin Duck Breast à L’orange $37 / $41 Maple Leaf Farms, sous vide and roasted, Asian orange glaze, jasmine rice, fresh vegetables Pork Shank Osso Bucco $41 / $44 Yukon Gold mashed potatoes, roasted winter vegetables Showboat Seafood Pasta $44 / $32 Diver scallops, shrimp prawns, Maryland crab, farfalle bow tie pasta, scampi butter cream sauce Wild Mushroom Black Pepper Ravioli $32.00 With a parmesan mushroom cream sauce Seafood Classics $49.00 Chilean Sea Bass $49 / $42 Lemon beurre blanc, Jasmine rice, microgreens, basil oil Pacific King Salmon $42 / $44 Spiced rub, seared and baked, mango chutney Jumbo Diver Sea Scallops New Orleans $44 / $79 Pan seared, fire roasted sweet corn, crispy smoked pork belly, garlic béchamel South African Lobster Tails $79.00 Highest quality cold water lobster, broiled warmed butter Baked Idaho Potato Large, olive oil rub, kosher salt $8 / $9 Make it loaded, bacon, cheddar, sour cream and chives +4 Garlic & Herb Mashed Yukon Gold Potatoes $8 / $10 Grilled Asparagus Spears with Hollandaise $10.00 Old City Fresh Brussels Sprouts $10.00 Flash fried, bacon, shallots, garlic, soy sauce glaze House Made Macaroni and Cheese $10.00 Cavatappi pasta, cheddar béchamel sauce Pan Roasted Broccolini $10.00 Olive oil, parmesan, pepper flakes Au Gratin Potato Casserole $10 / $26 Thinly sliced, cream, thyme, gruyere & parmesan cheese Ocp Lobster Mac & Cheese $26 / $10 Cavatappi, cheddar béchamel, lobster, toasted Old Bay panko Creamed Spinach $10.00 Garlic, onion, butter, cream béchamel, parmesan, nutmeg Cognac Caramelized Onions & Mushrooms $10.00 Sweet vidalia onions, gourmet mushroom blend Ocp Fresh Donuts Coffee & Espresso $6.00 Regular or decaf $6 / $5 Italian Roast Espresso $5.00 Classic Cappuccino $5 / $9 Italian roasted beans, frothed milk, cinnamon Ocp House Coffee $9.00 Bailey’s Irish Cream, Frangelico, whipped cream Bavarian Coffee $9.00 Peppermint Schnapps, Kahlua, sugar, whipped cream Cafe Disaronno $9.00 Amaretto Disaronno, white crème de cacao, whipped cream Ice Cream Parfaits & Cocktails $8.00 Ice Cream $8 / $12 Vanilla bean or butter pecan Grasshopper $12.00 Green crème de menthe, white crème de cacao, whipped cream, mint leaf Brandy Alexander $12.00 Brandy, dark crème de cacao, whipped cream, nutmeg Old City Prime: hours and how to order