NextEats › Ohio › Food in Cleveland › Polish Food › Prosperity Social Club › Menu Prosperity Social Club
1109 Starkweather Ave, Cleveland, OH
Menu (As of 10/30)
Tequila List Small Plates $15.00 Lamb Pelmeni $15 / $14 lamb dumplings with a sour cherry glaze, griddled mushrooms, and sour cream. Smoked Whitefish Dip (gf) $14 / $13 served with housemade chips and cabbage relish. Dill Pickle Baby Carrots (v) $13 / $11 with apple-carrot butter and crispy onions. Sauerkraut Balls (df, vg) $11.00 with whole grain mustard aioli. Crispy Smoked Tofu (v) $11 / $13 with spicy currywurst sauce. Beet Buterbrodi (vg) $15.00 with farmers cheese, pickled onion, and smoked salt served on Good Company Bakehouse toasted rye. Cabbage Rolls $15 / $12 with housemade tomato sauce and mashed potatoes. (contains pork) Potato Latkes (gf, df) $12.00 with apple-cherry chutney. Pierogies (vo) $12.00 with caramelized onions and sour cream. Crispy Chicken Livers $15.00 with pickled mustard seeds and parsley salad. Salad and Sandwiches $13.00 Sandwiches include one side. Roasted Beet Salad (v)† $13 / $15 arugula, dill, candied walnuts, and dijon vinaigrette. Prosperity Burger $15.00 lettuce, tomato, onion, borscht aioli, and bacon jam, served on a Good Company Bakehouse milk bun. Kielbasa Sandwich $15 / $16 caramelized onions, peppers, and horseradish mustard, served on a Good Company Bakehouse hoagie. Schnitzel Sandwich (vo) $16.00 cabbage slaw and spicy aioli, served on a pretzel bun. Big Plates $22.00 Fish Fry (vo) $22 / $28 beer-battered haddock, cabbage slaw, housemade tartar sauce, and mac n cheese. Euro Platter $28 / $24 cabbage roll, pierogies, potato pancake, kielbasa with peppers and onions. Pork Schnitzel $24 / $23 with mashed potatoes, braised red cabbage, and mushroom gravy. Chicken Paprikash $23.00 with creamy paprika sauce and egg noodles. Sides $6.00 Mac n Cheese (vg) $6.00 German Potato Salad (vo) $6.00 with bacon and crispy onions. Cucumber Salad (v) $6.00 with chili oil and fresh dill. Fries (vo) $6.00 with schmaltz aioli and curry ketchup. Mashed Potatoes (vg) $6.00 Dessert $12.00 Made by Good Company Bakehouse, available while supplies last! Brownie Sundae (vg) $12 / $7 chocolate brownie, vanilla ice cream, fudge sauce, whipped cream Lemon Bar (vg) $7.00 lemon curd, short dough crust, seasonal berries Carrot Cake Roll (vg) $7 / $4 carrot cake, brown butter cream cheese, salted-caramel sauce Sunday Brunch $15.00 Biscuit with Sausage Gravy $15.00 big housemade biscuit / sausage gravy / smoked cheddar cheese / 2 eggs* any style / fried potatoes + fried chicken $5 / $19 Polish Breakfast (Vo) $19 / $12 2 potato pierogies / kielbaski / herbed scrambled eggs / bacon crumble / smoked cheddar / fried potatoes Standard Breakfast $12 / $15 2 eggs* any style / fried potatoes / good company english muffin w/ arugula butter Eggs Florentine $15.00 2 poached eggs* / grilled tomato/sautéed arugula / traditional hollandaise / good company english muffin / fried potatoes + avocado $2.00 + bacon $2 / $14 Wake-up Call Empanada (Vo) $14 / $26 stuffed with andouille sausage / pepper medley/onions/nacho cheese / egg / topped with tequila-lime pico/served with fried potatoes Steak and Eggs $26.00 8 oz Texas Sirloin / 2 eggs* any style / fried potatoes + sautéed mushrooms $2.00 + sautéed onions $2.00 + blue cheese crust $2 / $15 Breakfast Sandwich $15 / $12 maple breakfast sausage / folded egg/american cheese / good company english muffin / served with a side of sausage gravy and fried potatoes Lemon Poppyseed Pancakes (2)(VG) $12.00 served with raspberry preserves and chantilly cream French Toast (3)(VG) $12.00 thick-cut good company bakehouse pullman bread, fresh berries, honey-cinnamon butter and maple syrup The Lunchie Side of Things $22.00 Beer Battered Fish Fry $22.00 beer-battered hand-dipped haddock* / fried potatoes / vinegar slaw / housemade tartar sauce Vegan Beer Battered Fish Fry (V) $22 / half $7 full $13 beer-battered heart of palm / vegan tartar sauce / fried potatoes Wedge Salad (GF) half $7 full $13 tomatoes / pickled onions / bacon / blue cheese crumbles / creamy herb dressing + chicken (pulled or breast) $4.00 + tofu $4.00 + shrimp $7 / $13 Tavern Cheeseburger $13.00 ⅓ lb steak burger / american cheese / lettuce / tomato / pickle / good company bakehouse milk bun / fried potatoes + bacon $2.00 + fried egg $2 / $13 American Patty Melt $13 / $18 ⅓ lb steak burger / american cheese / lettuce / tomato / pickle / good company bakehouse vegan dill rye / fried potatoes Shrimp* and Grits (GF) $18.00 cheesy homemade grits / sautéed shrimp in cajun sauce / smoked andouille sausage / peppers and onions + fried egg $2 / $12 sautéed onions/sour cream $12.00 with maple syrup $4 / $12 sautéed onions / sour cream $12 / $6 Bacon (3) $6 / $5 Smoked Kielbaski $5 / $6 Maple Sausage Patties (2) $6 / $4 Two Eggs Any Style $4 / $4.50 Fried Potatoes (V) $4.50 with honey-cinnamon butter $4.50 / $3 Side of Toast (2)(VG) · Side of Sausage Gravy Brunch Cocktails $10.00 See “Drinks” tab for wine, bubbly, and bottles & cans Prosperity’s Famous Bloody Mary $10 / $9 vodka / housemade bloody mix / cheese + olive + pickle skewer / chili-salt rim Mimosa $9 / $20 bubbles and your choice of: orange / blood orange / passionfruit / mango / pineapple / cranberry / white cranberry / pomegranate / mango Mimosa Flight $20 / $14 4 half mimosas: blood orange, apple cider, pear, white cranberry Cucumber Melon Cosmo $14 / $15 cucumber vodka / midori melon liqueur / white cranberry / lime / ginger / honey bitters Espresso Martini $15.00 vodka / coldbrew / espresso liquor / amari di rucola Prosperity Punch $15.00 aged rum / banana liqueur / french ginger liqueur / disaronno amaretto / mango / orange / lime Paloma Aperol Spritz $15.00 blanco tequila / aperol / amaro nonino / sparkling wine / grapefruit radler / grapefruit bitters Smoky and Spicy Margarita $15.00 mezcal / housemade mango habanero hot sauce / agave nectar / lime / half chili salt rim / spritz of islay scotch Grounds for Divorce $15 / $14 old forester bourbon / coldbrew coffee liqueur / campari / carpano antica sweet vermouth / cocoa bitters Blood Orange Old Fashioned $14.00 old forester bourbon / muddled orange and cherry / blood orange juice / bitters / sugar (available non-alcoholic) Maple Ginger Old Fashioned $14 / $15 old forester bourbon / french ginger liqueur / maple syrup / orange bitters (available non-alcoholic) Butterfly Knees $15.00 butterfly pea-infused gin / elderflower / honey / lemon / soda Cocktails $14.00 Fireside Chat $14.00 amaro montenegro, allspice dram, orange curacao, banana, cocoa bitters. Ruby Devil $14.00 vodka, cherry liqueur, pomegranate, ruby red grapefruit, lemon, averna italian amaro. Cucumber Melon Cosmo $14.00 cucumber vodka, midori melon liqueur, white cranberry, lime, ginger, honey bitters. Espresso Martini $14 / $15 vodka, coldbrew coffee, coffee liqueur, averna italian amaro, carpano antica sweet vermouth. Paloma Aperol Spritz $15 / $14 blanco tequila, aperol, amaro nonino, sparkling wine, grapefruit radler, grapefruit bitters. El Diablo $14.00 reposado tequila, crème de cassis, lime, ginger beer. Smoky and Spicy Margarita $14.00 mezcal, housemade mango habanero hot sauce, agave nectar, lime, half chili-salt rim, spritz of islay scotch. Social Club $15 / $14 french gin, dry vermouth, raspberry, lemon, prosecco, salt. Aviation $14 / $15 french gin, crème de violette, luxardo maraschino, lemon. White Wine / Rosé $15.00 Leitz's ‘Eins Zwei Zero’ N/A Sparkling Rosé $15 / $10 Brundlymayer ‘L+T’ Gruner Veltliner (Austria) $10.00 (France) $12.00 Bishop’s Peak Chardonnay (California) $12.00 (France) $12.00 Red Wine/sangria $12.00 (Chile) $12.00 (France) $11.00 Grounded Wine Company Cabernet Sauvignon (California) $11.00 Seasonal Sangria $9.00 ask your server about today’s sangria Bubbly $9.00 La Forestina Prosecco (Italy) $9.00 (France) 750ml $45 / $11 (Italy) $11.00 (France) 750ml $75.00 North American $6.50 Athletic Atletica Mexican Style N/A Lager $6.50 Athletic Run Wild Hazy N/A IPA $6.50 / $6 Blue Moon Wheat Ale $6 / $6.50 Ciderboys Strawberry Magic Hard Cider $6.50 / $6 Fat Heads Bumbleberry $6.00 Fat Heads Sunshine Daydream Session IPA $6 / $6.50 Founders Porter $6.50 / $6 Great Lakes Dortmunder Gold $6 / $4 Miller High Life $4.00 Miller Lite $4 / $6 Modelo Mexican Lager $6 / $4 Montucky Cold Snack Lager $4 / $7.50 New Holland Tangerine Hazy IPA $7.50 / $5 P.O.C. Pilsner $5 / $7.50 Three Floyd’s Zombie Dust American Pale Ale $7.50 Victory Sour Monkey Sour Ale $7.50 / $7 High Noon $7.00 (rotating flavors) Sun Cruiser Hard Blueberry Lemonade $7.00 Sun Cruiser Hard Iced Tea $7.00 (rotating flavors) $7.00 European $13.00 Chimay White Trappist Tripel (Belgian) $13 / $7 Damm Daura Gluten Free Lager $7.00 Damm Daura Gluten Free IPA $7 / $11 (Belgian) $11.00 Duvel (Belgian Strong Ale) $11 / $6.50 Guinness Irish Stout $6.50 Guinness N/A Irish Stout $6.50 / $11 Lindemans Framboise Raspberry Lambic Okocim Lager (Poland) Tallboy $6 / $11 Orval Trappist (Belgian Pale Ale) $11 / $6 Pilsner Urquell Lager (Czech-Republic) $6 / $10 Reissdorf Kolsch (Germany) Tallboy $10 / $13 (Belgian) $13 / $8 Samuel Smith Organic Apple Cider Saison Dupont Tallboy Can Stiegl Grapefruit Radler Tyskie Lager Weihenstephaner (German Hefe Wheat) $7.50 / $11 Westmalle Trappist Dubbel (Belgian) $11.00 Fancy Sours & Shareables $44.00 (Belgian Sour) 375 ml $44 / $100 (Belgian Sour) 750ml $100 / $20 Mortalis Hydra Slushmallow $20 / $12 (Belgian Sour) 11.2oz $12.00 Fancy Stouts & Shareables $15.00 Goose Island Bourbon County Stout Original 2025 12oz $15 / $25 16.9oz $25.00 1.5oz pours $10.00 1792 Bottled in Bond $10.00 1792 Full Proof $10 / $20 2XO Double Oak “The Innkeeper’s Blend” $20.00 2XO Double Oak “The Phoenix Blend” $20 / $11 Angel’s Envy Port Finish $11 / $30 Bardstown Château de Laubade Armagnac Finish $30.00 Bardstown Aged in Foursquare Rum Barrels $30 / $12 Ben Holladay Bottled in Bond 6 Year Missouri Bourbon $12.00 Ben Holladay Soft Red Wheat Bottled in Bond $12 / $18 Blanton’s Single Barrel $18 / $20 Booker’s $20 / $7 Buffalo Trace $7 / $13 Colonel E.H. Taylor Jr. Bottled in Bond $13 / $15 Elijah Craig Barrel Proof $15 / $10 Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel $10 / $40 Heaven Hill 18 Year $40 / $13 Henry McKenna Bottled in Bond 10 Year $13 / $6.5 Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7 $6.5 / $8.5 Jack Daniel’s Bonded Tennessee Whiskey $8.5 / $17 Jefferson’s Ocean Aged at Sea $17.00 Jefferson’s Pritchard Hill Aged in Cabernet Barrels $17 / $6.5 Jim Beam $6.5 / $7 Jim Beam Black 7 Year $7 / $20 Joseph Magnus Finished in Sherry & Cognac Casks $20 / $40 Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend Finished in Armagnac, Sherry & Cognac $40 / $35 Knob Creek 18 Year $35 / $7.5 Maker’s Mark $7.5 / $8 Maker’s Mark 46 $8 / $10 Maker’s Mark Cask Strength $10 / $35 Maker’s Mark Cellar Aged Limited Edition $35 / $30 Old Fitzgerald Bottled in Bond 10 Year $30 / $6.5 Old Forester 86 Proof $6.5 / $12 Old Forester 1910 Old Fine Whisky $12 / $25 Old Forester 1924 10 Year $25 / $50 Old Forester The President’s Choice Limited Edition Bourbon $50 / $20 “Continental Breakfast” $20 / $5 Old Grand-Dad $5 / $8 Old Grand-Dad 114 $8.00 Penelope Four Grain $8 / $14 Penelope Four Grain Architect (French Oak Finish) $14.00 Penelope Four Grain Barrel Strength $14.00 Penelope Four Grain Toasted Barrel $14 / $16 Rabbit Hole Dareringer PX Sherry Finish $16 / $45 River Roots Full Proof 13 Year (140 Proof) $45 / $13 Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel $13 / $30 Russell’s Reserve 13 Year $30 / $18 Smoke Wagon Uncut Unfiltered $18 / $11 Wild Turkey Rare Breed Barrel Proof $11 / $8 Woodford Reserve $8 / $30 Woodford Reserve 2024 Batch Proof $30 / $40 Woodford Reserve Double Double Oaked Extra Aged $40 / $25 Yellowstone Limited Edition 2025 (10 Year) $25.00 Alberta Premium Cask Strength Rye $10 / $20 Angel’s Envy Rye Finished in Caribbean Rum Casks $20 / $12 Caribou Crossing Single Barrel Canadian Whisky $12 / $50 Heaven Hill Heritage Collection Corn Whiskey 20 Year $50 / $35 High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram $35 / $25 High West Bourye Limited Edition $25 / $15 Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye $15 / $8.5 Jack Daniel’s Triple Mash Bottled in Bond $8.5 / $17 Jefferson’s Ocean Double Barrel Rye Aged at Sea $17 / $10 Michter’s American Whiskey (Unblended) $10 / $40 Michter’s Single Barrel Rye 10 Year $40 / $14 New Riff Malted Rye 6 Year $14 / $6.5 Old Forester Rye $6.5 / $50 Old Forester The President’s Choice Limited Edition Rye $50 / $15 Redwood Empire Emerald Giant Cask Strength Rye $15.00 Redwood Empire Lost Monarch Bourye Cask Strength $15 / $7 Rittenhouse Rye Bottled in Bond $7 / $20 River Roots Single Barrel Rye 11 Year (Exclusive Release) $20 / $13 Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel Rye $13 / $12 Sagamore Double Oak Rye $12 / $8 Sagamore Straight Rye $8.00 Sazerac Rye $8 / $10 Sazerac Rye 100 Proof $10 / $18 WhistlePig Rye 10 Year $18 / $6.5 Wild Turkey 101 Rye $6.5 / $13 Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye Barrel Proof $13 / $14 Willett Family Estate Rye $14.00 Scotch $18.00 1.5oz pours Ardbeg Uigeadail Single Malt $18 / $35 The Balvenie French Oak 16 Year Single Malt $35 / $6.5 Dewar’s White Label $6.5 / $15 The GlenDronach 12 Year Single Malt $15 / $10 Glenfiddich 12 Year Single Malt $10 / $25 Glenmorangie 18 Year Single Malt $25 / $13 Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban (Port Cask Finish) $13 / $45 Johnnie Walker Blue Label $45 / $20 Lagavulin 16 Year Single Malt $20 / $25 Lagavulin Distillers Edition Single Malt $25 / $13 Laphroaig 10 Year Single Malt $13 / $20 The Macallan 12 Year Sherry Oak $20 / $16 Port Charlotte 10 Year Heavily Peated Single Malt $16 / $15 Talisker 10 Year Single Malt $15.00 Irish $7.00 1.5oz pours Bushmills Black Bush (Oloroso Sherry Finish) $7.5 / $20 Green Spot Château Montelena Finish $20 / $6.5 Jameson $6.5 / $20 Redbreast Tawny Port Finish $20 / $25 Redbreast 15 Year Single Pot Still $25 / $9 Teeling Small Batch Rum Cask Finish $9 / $6.5 Yellow Spot 12 Year Single Pot Still $25.00 Japanese $35.00 1.5oz pours Hakushu 12 Year Single Malt $35 / $25 Hibiki Harmony $25 / $125 Hibiki 21 Year $125 / $16 Nikka Coffey Malt $16 / $35 Yamazaki 12 Year Single Malt $35.00 Blanco + Silver $8.00 Casamigos Blanco $8 / $17 Cierto Blanco $17 / $8 El Tesoro Blanco $8 / $3.50 Espolon Silver $3.50 / $8 G4 Blanco $8 / $3.50 Gran Centenario Plata $3.50 / $7 Herradura Silver $7 / $5 Onda Blanco $5 / $7 Patron Silver $7.00 Tequila Ocho Plata $7.00 Reposado $9.00 Casamigos Reposado $9 / $10 G4 Reposado $10 / $4 Gran Centenario Reposado $4 / $10 Tequila Ocho Reposado $10 / $8 Herradura Reposado $8 / $13 Tequila Ocho Reposado $13.00 El Tesoro Reposado $13.00 Cristalino $10.00 1800 Cristalino $10.00 Anejo + Extra Anejo $10.00 Casamigos Anejo $10 / $32 Don Julio 1942 $32 / $9 Herradura Anejo $9 / $27 Herradura Legend aged in new charred oak $27 / $47 Tears of Llorona Extra Anejo $47.00 aged in Sherry, Scotch, and Brandy casks Mezcal $15.00 Bozal Borrego Artisanal Mezcal $15 / $11 with Wild Berries and Rack of Lamb suspended in the still Casamigos Mezcal Joven $11 / $5.50 Pelotón Mezcal $5.50 Prosperity Social Club: hours and how to order