Rosemary & Sun-dried Tomato Ham$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Buffalo Chicken$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Blackened Turkey$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
EverRoast Chicken$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Hot Cappicola$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Bologna$9.00Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Tavern Ham$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Roast Beef$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Honey Maple Turkey$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Genoa Salami$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Pastrami$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Corned Beef$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Prosciutto$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Pepperoni$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Ovengold Turkey$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Chicken Salad$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments. *contains wheat .
Chipotle Chicken$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
Peppermill Turkey$9.50Build your sandwich the way you want it. Pick your bread, cheese, topping and condiments.
New York Style Subs
Vegetarian Reuben$13.00Saurkraut, Melted Swiss cheese, Roasted Sweet Red Peppers and Thousand Island on Rye
Reuben$14.00hot corned beef or pastrami, Thousand Island dressing, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut or coleslaw on rye
All American$13.00ham, turkey, roast beef, yellow American, lettuce, tomato on Sub bread (French baguette)
Old School$13.00bologna, yellow American on Sub (French baguette)
Original$13.00ham, fresh mozzarella, salt, pepper on Sub (French baguette)
Turkey Reuben$14.00hot turkey, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, thousand island dressing on rye
Buffalo Sandwich$13.00Buffalo Chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato on a Sub (French Baguette)
Little Italy$13.00prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, deli dressing on Sub (French baguette)
Lite Delight$13.00turkey, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard on Sub (French baguette)
Brooklyn Classic$13.00Genoa salami, pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, deli dressing on Sub (French baguette)
Lackluster$13.00honey turkey, Muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato on Sub (French baguette)
The Hot One$13.00pepperoni, hot cappicola, provolone, Tabasco, deli dressing on Sub (French baguette)
Say cheese$13.00yellow American, Swiss, Muenster, lettuce, tomato on Sub (French baguette)
Poultry Explosion$13.00turkey, honey turkey, chicken breast, yellow American, lettuce, tomato on Sub (French baguette)
Zack Attack (vegan)$13.00Lettuce, tomato, onions, banana peppers, cucumbers, pickles, roasted sweet red peppers and deli dressing on a Sub (French baguette)
Spicy One$13.00chipotle chicken, 3 pepper Colby Jack, lettuce, tomato, Fiery Chipotle mayo on Sub (French baguette)
Meatball Parmesan$13.00fresh made meatballs (contains wheat), Mozzarella, tomato sauce on Sub (French baguette)
Fresh Rose$13.00Made with tavern ham, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, deli dressing on Sub (French baguette)
Peppermill$13.00cracked peppermill turkey, Muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato, Pepperhouse Gourmaise on Sub (French baguette)
BBQ Chicken Melt$13.00hot chicken breast, Cheddar cheese, onions, crisp bacon, BBQ sauce on a Sub bread (French baguette)
Meese$13.00Genoa Salami, f-f-fresh mozzarella, balsamic vinegar on Sub (French baguette)
Spicy Horse Pig$13.00Tavern Ham (Peppenero Garlic Ham is discontinued), horseradish cheddar, lettuce, tomato, Fiery Chipotle Gourmaise on Sub (French baguette)
BLT Sub$13.00crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on Sub bread (French baguette)
Chicken Salad Sub$13.00Chicken salad, Cream Havarti cheese, lettuce, tomato on Sub (French baguette)
Blackened$13.00Blackened turkey, havarti cheese, lettuce, roasted sweet red peppers, deli dressing on Sub bread (French baguette)
Buffalo Special$13.00Buffalo chicken, feta crumbles, bacon, warmed up and topped with lettuce, tomato, Fiery Chipotle Gourmaise on Sub (French baguette)
Supreme$13.00warm roast beef, fresh mozzarella, onions on Sub (French baguette)
Turkey Melt$13.00hot turkey, Cheddar cheese, crisp bacon on Sub (French baguette)
Good A Rose$13.00Made with tavern ham, chipotle Gouda, lettuce, tomato, deli dressing on Sub (French baguette)
Catering / Assorted Sub Trays
5 Assorted Subs$70.505 of our most popular subs cut in half placed on a tray
6 Assorted Sub Tray$83.006 of our most popular subs placed on a tray
7 Assorted Sub Tray$95.507 of our most popular subs cut in half placed on a tray
8 Assorted Sub Tray$108.008 of our most popular subs cut in half placed on a tray
9 Assorted Subs$122.009 of our most popular subs cut in half placed on a tray
10 Assorted Subs Tray$135.0010 of our most popular subs cut in half placed on a tray
11 Assorted Sub Tray$148.0011 of our most popular subs cut in half placed on a tray
12 Assorted Subs$160.0012 of our most popular subs cut in half placed on a tray
Deli salads
Red Skin Potato Salad$5.00
Macaroni & Cheddar Salad$5.00
Cole Slaw$5.00
Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato Salad$5.00
Mixed Olives$7.50
Antipasto Salad$5.00
Chicken Salad (Container)$5.00* contains wheat
La Crema Coffee
Highlander Grogg Ground Coffee$17.99Butterscotch, caramel & vanilla 12 oz
Chocolate Raspberry Ground Coffee$17.99Raspberries drizzled with chocolate 12 oz bag
Chocolate Donut Ground Coffee$17.99Chocolate with a vanilla glaze 12 oz bag
Hawaiian Hazelnut Ground Coffee$17.99Hazelnut and coconut 12 oz bag
Brazilian Sunset Ground Coffee$17.99Almond, coconut & caramel 12 oz bag
Banana Foster Ground Coffee$17.99Banana and rum with caramel 12 oz bag
Gluten Free
Gluten Free Ginger Spice Cookie$4.75A soft and spicy ginger cookie filled with hand-chopped candied ginger.
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie$4.75A soft, chewy, gluten-free cookie packed full of chocolate chips!
Goat Cheese with Red Cherries Pint$11.99Mackenzie Creamery goat cheese and sweet-tart, bright red cherries. Mouthwatering and rich, it’s like a scoopable cherry cheesecake
Middle West Whiskey & Pecans Pint$11.99Middle West Spirits whiskey-fueled ice cream- with notes of butterscotch, honey, and vanilla-laden with crunchy, salty, toasted pecans
Lemon & Blueberries Parfait Pint$11.99Tart and über creamy lemon with from-scratch blueberry jam in fresh cultured buttermilk and cream
Brambleberry Crisp Pint$11.99Oven-toasted oat streusel and a sweet-tart “brambleberry” jam of blackberries and blackcurrants layered throughout vanilla ice cream.
Salty Caramel Pint$11.99A perfect balance of salty and sweet: sugar caramelized in our kitchen, blended with sea salt and grass-grazed Ohio milk.
Brown Butter Almond Brittle Pint$11.99Brown-butter-almond candy crushed into buttercream ice cream.
Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks Pint$11.99Salted and roasted ground peanuts with grass-grazed milk and crunchy, dark chocolate flecks.
Caramel Pecan Sticky Buns Jenis Ice Cream$11.99Rich coconut cream loaded with sticky dough, dark caramel and roasted pecans.
Garden Salads
Garden Salad$12.50mixed greens, red onions, broccoli, carrots, cucumbers, sweet corn
Antipasto Garden Salad$13.00homemade antipasto salad on top of mixed greens, red onions, cucumbers
Chicken Salad Salad$13.00*contains wheat homemade chicken salad on top of mixed greens, red onions, sweet corn, cucumbers
Lite Delight Salad$13.00mixed greens, turkey, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions
BLT Salad$13.00mixed greens, bacon, tomato, red onions, cucumbers
Classic Tollhouse Cookie (with walnuts)$4.75The classic! Just like your grandma used to make, only better.
I heart chocolate chips cookie$4.75Fall in love all over again with your childhood favorite. This just might be the best chocolate chip cookie ever.
The Best Peanut Butter Cookie$4.75Rich, crumbly, moist and dense peanut buttery goodness. Yum!
Snickerdoodle Cookie$4.75the best snickerdoodle around
Banana Chocolate Chip Muffin$4.99Real, ripe, organic bananas make these the best banana muffins around.
Marry Me Blueberry Muffin with crumb topping$4.99After you get to know it a little bit, you may just want to marry this moist muffin filled with blueberries and topped with our incredible crumb topping.
Seriously Good Chocolate Cupcake$4.99Seriously.
Carrot Cupcake with "cream cheese" icing$4.99Light and citrusy lemony goodness. Perfect for summer, or anytime you're craving a sweet and refreshing lemony treat.
Lovely Lemon Cupcake$4.99Light and citrusy lemony goodness. Perfect for summer, or anytime you're craving a sweet and refreshing lemony treat.
Original Whoopie Pie$4.25Soft, delectable dark chocolate cake surrounding fluffy, marshmallowy, whipped vanilla goodness.