Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

27 Brower Court, Staten Island, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

Appetizers

• Garlic BreadPlain $9.50 · With mozzarella $11.50
• Potato Croquettes (3) $13.00
• Mozzarella Sticks (6) $14.00
• Mozzarella en Carrozza $14.50
• Mac & Cheese Bites (12) $15.00
• Fried Zucchini $15.50
• Baked Clams (8) $17.50
• Hot Antipasto $22.00
• Shrimp Cocktail (6) $18.50
• Fried Shrimp (6) $19.00
• Fried Calamari $17.00
• Clams on a Half Shell (12) $19.00
• Mussels Marinara $17.00
• Sautéed Spinach $15.00
• Sautéed Broccoli $16.00
• Sautéed Broccoli Rabe $19.50
• Rice Ball $6.50
• Rice Ball Parmigiana $11.50
• With vodka sauce $14.00
• Eggplant Rollatini (2) $14.50
• Buffalo Wings6 wings 11.00 · 12 wings 19.00 · 20 wings 27.00
• Chicken Fingers (6) $16.00
• Chicken Fingers with French Fries $18.95
• French Fries $9.50
• Onion Rings $9.50
• Buffalo Calamari $17.00

Soups

• Pasta FagioliSmall $7.50 · Large $15.00
• Chicken NoodleSmall $7.50 · Large $15.00
• LentilSmall $7.50 · Large $15.00
• Tortellini in BrodoSmall $8.45 · Large $16.90
• Tortellini in Brodo with SpinachSmall $9.45 · Large $17.90

Salads

• Garden Salad $14.75
• Caesar Salad $13.50
• Cold Antipasto $16.00
• Caprese Salad $15.00
• Chef Salad $17.00
• Tuna Salad $15.50
• Buffalo Chicken Salad $17.00
• Fried Chicken $2.00
• Fresh Mozzarella $2.00
• Grilled Shrimp $5.50
• Fried Shrimp $5.50
• Tuna $4.50
• Cucumber $1.00
• Black Olives $1.00
• Tomato $1.00
• Tortilla Salad Bowl $2.00
• Wheat Tortilla Bowl $2.00
• Garlic Crust Bowl $10.00
• Old Fashioned Gourmet Pizza Regular Pie $20.00Specialty pies are 18 inches unless marked personal. Topping prices are listed for half or whole pies.
• Sicilian Pie $30.00
• Nonna's $28.00
• Lasagna Pie $34.00
• Clam Pie $35.00
• Vodka Pie $29.00
• Chicken Marsala $32.50
• Chicken Francese $32.50
• Chicken Parmigiana $32.50
• Margherita $28.00
• Fresca $33.00
• Grandpa Pie $33.00
• La Caprese $33.00
• Vegetarian $36.00
• White Pie $29.00
• Spinach & Artichoke Pie $35.00
• Buffalo Chicken Pie $34.00
• Alfredo Bacon Pie $35.00
• Chicken Caesar Salad Pie $33.00
• Garlic Marinara Pie $31.00
• Garbage Pie $41.00
• Pan Pie $30.00
• Deep Dish Pepperoni Pie $38.00 / $34.00
• Sausage & Broccoli Rabe $36.00
• Chicken Bruschetta $35.00
• Tuscan $33.00
• Philly Cheesesteak Pie $36.00
• Eggplant Parmigiana $33.00
• Gluten-Free Personal Pie $17.00
• Cauliflower Personal Pie $18.00
• Upside Down Sicilian Pie $35.00
• Upside Down Round Pie $33.00
• Chipotle Chicken Pie $34.00
• BBQ Chicken Pie $34.00
• Chicken, Vodka, Pesto & Burrata Pie $42.00
• Vodka, Chicken & Garlic Pie $34.00
• Angry Sicilian Pie $41.00
• Tri-Color (M.V.P.) Pie $35.00
• Burrata Pie $38.00
• Bonnie Pie $33.00
• Pizza ToppingsExtra CheeseHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• PepperoniHalf pie $3.00 · Whole pie $6.00
• SausageHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• MeatballHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• HamHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• BaconHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• AnchoviesHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Black OlivesHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• BroccoliHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Fried ChickenHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Grilled ChickenHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Grilled EggplantHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Fried EggplantHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Fresh TomatoHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Roasted GarlicHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Fresh GarlicHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• PeppersHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Long Hot PeppersHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Cherry PeppersHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• MushroomsHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• OnionsHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• RicottaHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• SpinachHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• PineappleHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• ArtichokesHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• ProsciuttoHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• JalapeñosHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Hot HoneyHalf pie $2.50 · Whole pie $4.00
• Broccoli RabeHalf pie $3.00 · Whole pie $5.00
• BasilHalf pie $0.75 · Whole pie $1.00
• Fried ShrimpHalf pie $7.00 · Whole pie $10.00
• Grilled ShrimpHalf pie $7.00 · Whole pie $10.00
• CalamariHalf pie $6.00 · Whole pie $14.00

Stuffed Pizza

• Broccoli & Spinach $35.50
• Sausage & Peppers $37.00
• Fried Eggplant $35.50
• Roman Pizza $40.00
• Panelle Stuffed PieHalf $25.00 · Full $50.00

Pizza Slices

• Pizza Slices Regular Slice $3.50
• Sicilian Slice $4.50
• White Slice $4.50
• Nonna's Slice $4.50
• Vodka Slice $4.50
• MOR Slice $5.50
• Pepperoni Slice $4.50
• Spinach & Artichoke Slice $4.50
• Chipotle Chicken Slice $4.50
• Deepdish Pepperoni Slice $6.00
• Margherita Slice $4.50
• Buffalo Slice $4.50
• Chicken Marsala Slice $4.50
• Chicken Francese Slice $4.50
• Chicken Parm Slice $4.50
• Eggplant Parm Slice $4.50
• BBQ Chicken Slice $4.50
• Alfredo Bacon Slice $4.50
• Lasagna Slice $4.50
• Upside Down Sicilian Slice $4.50
• Upside Down Round Slice $4.50
• Tri-color (mvp) Slice $6.00
• Vodka & Chicken & Pesto & Burrata Slice $6.00
• White Clam Slice $6.00
• Bonnie Slice $6.00
• Burrata Slice $6.00
• Angry Sicilian Slice $6.00
• Panelle Slice $6.00
• Sausage & Longhot Slice $5.00
• Vodka & Chicken & Garlic Slice $6.00

• Pasta $4.00Choose penne, rigatoni, spaghetti, linguine, ziti, fettuccine or whole-wheat pasta. Cavatelli or tortellini
• Garlic & Oil $15.50
• Alfredo $20.50
• Marinara $16.50
• Broccoli with Garlic & Oil $18.50
• Clam Sauce Red or White $21.50
• Carbonara $21.50
• Pomodoro $20.00
• Primavera $20.00
• Vodka $19.50
• Puttanesca $19.00
• Baked Ziti $20.50
• Lasagna $19.50
• Manicotti $19.00
• Ravioli $19.50
• Stuffed Shells $19.50
• Spaghetti with Meatballs $20.50
• Bolognese $20.50
• Broccoli Rabe with Sausage $22.50
• Plain Pasta $10.00
• Pasta with Butter $13.50
• Grilled Chicken $4.00
• Grilled Shrimp $6.00
• Fried Shrimp $6.00
• Grilled Calamari $4.50
• Fried Calamari $4.50
• Sausage $3.50
• Meatball $4.00
• Tomato $2.00
• Mozzarella $2.00
• Grated Cheese $1.00
• Broccoli $4.00

Entrées

• Eggplant Parmigiana $22.50
• Eggplant Florentine $24.25
• Eggplant Rollatini $22.50
• Veal Parmigiana $25.00
• Veal Marsala $26.25
• Veal Francese $26.00
• Chicken Parmigiana $23.50
• Chicken Marsala $24.75
• Chicken Francese $24.75
• Chicken Rollatini $26.75
• Shrimp Parmigiana $25.00
• Shrimp Francese $26.00
• Shrimp Oreganata $26.00
• Shrimp Scampi $26.00
• Shrimp Marinara $25.00
• Clams & Shrimp Marinara $28.95
• Calamari & Clams Marinara $27.40
• Shrimp & Calamari $28.45
• Zuppa di Mussels $25.00
• Zuppa di Pesce $30.45
• Calamari Marinara $23.50
• Grilled Chicken with Broccoli Rabe $24.00
• Grilled Chicken with Grilled Vegetables $22.00
• Meatball $4.00
• Tomato $2.00
• Fresh Mozzarella $2.00
• Mozzarella $2.00
• Vodka Sauce $4.00
• Marinara Sauce on Pasta
• Vodka Sauce on Pasta $2.00
• Bolognese on Pasta $4.00

Nonna's Heroes

• Chicken Parmigiana $18.00
• With vodka sauce $21.00
• Grilled Chicken with Mozzarella $16.50
• Eggplant Parmigiana $17.00
• Meatball Parmigiana $16.50
• Sausage Parmigiana $16.50
• Veal Parmigiana $20.00
• Shrimp Parmigiana $18.00
• Potato or Pepper & Egg $16.00
• Broccoli Rabe & Sausage $18.00
• Broccoli Rabe & Chicken Cutlet $19.00
• Chicken Marsala $19.25
• Chicken Francese $18.50
• Chicken Cacciatore $18.50
• Sausage, Pepper & Onion $17.00
• Veal Marsala $21.00
• Veal Francese $21.00
• Philly Cheesesteak $20.00
• Nonna’s NY Cheesesteak $19.00
• Chicken Hero $14.50
• Vodka Sauce $3.00
• Fresh Mozzarella $2.00
• Mozzarella $2.00
• American Cheese $2.00
• Roasted Peppers $1.25
• Lettuce $0.75
• Tomato $1.00
• Onion $1.00
• Jalapenos $0.50
• Oil & Vinegar
• Mayo $0.50
• On Garlic Bread $2.00
• Sauce $1.00
• Mushrooms $1.50

Burgers

• Burger $13.00
• Cheeseburger $14.00
• Cheeseburger Special with French Fries $17.00
• Bacon Cheeseburger $15.00
• Bacon Cheeseburger with Fries $18.80
• Pizza Burger $18.00
• Burger Special with French Fries $16.00
• Mozzarella or Fresh Mozzarella $2.00
• Mushrooms $2.00

Handmade Rolls & More

• Rolls $9.00
• Stromboli $10.00
• Buffalo Chicken Roll $10.00
• Garlic Knots (6)Plain $5.00 · With mozzarella $7.00
• Zeppoles12 for $4.00
• Calzone (Baked or Fried)Regular 10.00 · Family 16.50 · Mega family 33.00
• Garlic Knot Chicken Sandwich $9.00
• Garlic Knot Veal Sandwich $12.00
• Calzone ToppingsFried ChickenRegular $2.00 · Family $2.50 · Mega Family $4.00
• BroccoliRegular $1.00 · Family $2.50 · Mega Family $4.00
• PepperoniRegular $1.00 · Family $2.50 · Mega Family $4.00
• SausageRegular $1.00 · Family $2.50 · Mega Family $4.00
• SpinachRegular $1.00 · Family $2.50 · Mega Family $4.00
• HamRegular $1.00 · Family $2.50 · Mega Family $4.00
• MeatballRegular $1.00 · Family $2.50 · Mega Family $4.00

Wraps

• Chicken Caesar $14.50
• Italian $15.00
• American $15.00
• Grilled or Fried Chicken $15.50
• Eggplant $15.00
• Grilled Vegetables $15.00
• Buffalo Chicken $15.00
• Grilled or Fried Chicken with Broccoli Rabe $16.25
• Honeymoon $15.50
• Vodka $15.50
• Cheeseburger $16.00
• Chicken Parmigiana $15.50
• Eggplant Parmigiana $15.50
• Fried Shrimp $5.00
• Grilled Chicken $4.00
• Fried Chicken $4.00
• Bacon $3.00
• Lettuce $0.50
• Tomato $0.50
• Roasted Peppers $1.25
• Fresh Mozzarella $2.00
• Vodka Sauce $2.00

Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria: hours and how to order