Carlo's Pizza Shirley

451 Glen Dr, Shirley, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

Most Ordered

• Neapolitan (Large) $21.95
• Garlic Knots (Dozen) $7.25
• Chicken Wings (6) $8.30
• Sicilian Pie $24.80
• Neapolitan (Small) $17.00
• Meatball Parmigiana Hero $10.90
• Caesar Salad (Large) $10.80
• Garlic Knots (Dozen) $7.25 / Regular Slice $3.35
• Sicilian Pie $24.80

Pizza

• Sicilian $24.80
• Deep Dish $26.10
• NeapolitanSmall $17.00 · Large $21.95

Specialty Pies

• Grandma Pizza Sicilian $26.80
• Capressi $34.76
• Stuffed Pizza (Meat or Veg) $32.55
• Grandma PizzaSicilian $26.80
• SpecialSmall $25.92 · Large $31.90 · Sicilian $34.76
• Salad PieSmall $27.47 · Large $32.94
• ShrimpSmall $26.44 · Large $35.54 · Sicilian $33.56
• Thick MargaritaSmall $23.32 · Large $32.85
• Greek SaladSmall $27.48 · Large $33.90
• Pizza by the Slice Regular Slice $3.35
• Special Pie Slice $5.20
• Grandma Slice $4.25
• Sicilian Slice $3.35
• Stuffed Slice (Meat or Veg) $6.40
• Salad Slice $7.60
• Salad Slice with Chicken $8.50

Pizza by the Slice

• Regular Slice $3.35
• Special Pie Slice $5.20
• Grandma Slice $4.25
• Sicilian Slice $3.35
• Stuffed Slice (Meat or Veg) $6.40
• Salad Slice $7.60
• Salad Slice with Chicken $8.50

Appetizers

• Baked Clams $11.85Seasoned with bread crumb, garlic & olive oil
• Clams Casino $12.45Seasoned with bell peppers, bacon, garlic & bread crumbs
• Fried Calamari $13.50Battered & deep fried, served with marinara sauce
• Zucchini Sticks $6.18Fresh zucchini sliced, breaded & fried to a golden brown, served with sauce
• Stuffed Mushrooms $12.45Seasoned and stuffed with crab meat, topped with mozzarella cheese
• Mussels Marinara or Bianco $12.45Sauteed in garlic, then simmered in your choice of sauce
• Broccoli Rabe $12.45Sauteed with sweet Italian sausage in garlic & oil
• Baked Ziti Balls $10.40Breaded and fried baked ziti covered in vodka sauce
• Breaded Raviolis $7.25
• Stuffed Knots $1.68 eachTomato or roasted peppers with prosciutto & fresh mozzarella
• Meatballs (2) $6.18Served with tomato sauce
• Italian Sausage (2) $6.18Served with tomato sauce
• Mozzarella Sticks $8.30Served with marinara sauce
• Rice Balls $6.75Filled with meat, peas, onions, and cheese. Add cheese & sauce +$1.05
• Garlic Bread $2.35
• Garlic Bread Parm $3.65Served with tomato sauce
• Clams Casino $12.45
• Zucchini Sticks $6.18
• Broccoli Rabe $12.45
• Hot Antipasto2 people $11.85 · 4 people $18.00 Stuffed
• Stuffed Knots $1.68
• Chicken Wings6 for $8.30 / $15.55
• Zeppoles6 for $4.15 · 12 for $6.25
• Garlic Knots3 for $1.72 · 6 for $4.80 · 12 for $7.25
• Chicken Fingers6 for $8.30 · 12 for $15.55

Soups & Salads

• Tossed Garden Salad $10.20Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, olives
• Antipasto Salad $11.95Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, cauliflower, peppers, and olives
• Scungilli or Calamari Salad $11.40Tender scungilli or calamari on a bed of lettuce with celery, olives, and tomatoes, served cold
• Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil $10.40In olive oil
• Tossed Garden Salad $10.20
• Antipasto Salad $11.95
• Caesar SaladSmall $8.25 · Large $10.80 Romaine lettuce
• Greek SaladSmall $8.25 · Large $11.85 Lettuce, tomato
• Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil $10.40In olive oil
• Chicken Bacon Cheddar SaladSmall $9.35 · Large $12.45 Lettuce, tomato
• Italian Chef SaladSmall $9.35 · Large $12.45 Romaine lettuce
• Pasta FagioliSmall $8.30 · Large $13.40
• Lentil SoupSmall $8.30 · Large $13.40
• Chicken SoupSmall $8.30 · Large $13.40
• StraciatellaSmall $8.30 · Large $13.40
• Seafood BisqueSmall $9.35 · Large $14.45

Heros

• Meatball $9.85
• Meatballs & Peppers $10.90
• Meatball Parmigiana $10.90
• Sausage $10.40
• Sausage & Peppers $11.40
• Sausage Parmigiana $11.55
• Sausage & Potatoes $11.40
• Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $13.50
• Veal & Peppers $12.45
• Veal & Peppers Parm $13.50
• Veal & Mushrooms $13.50
• Veal & Mushrooms Parm $13.50
• Potatoes & Egg $9.35
• Pepper & Egg $9.35
• Shrimp Parmigiana $14.50
• Eggplant Parmigiana $11.40
• Cold Italian (Boar's Head) $12.20
• Chicken Club $11.85
• Chicken Parmigiana $12.45
• Buffalo Chicken Parm $12.45
• BBQ Chicken Parmigiana $12.45
• Chicken, Bacon, Cheddar & Ranch $12.45
• Fresh Mozzarella, Basil & Tomato on Garlic Bread $10.40
• Broccoli Rabe Parm (Chicken or Sausage) $12.45
• Chicken Francese Parm $12.45
• ItemSmall TrayLarge Tray $18.00 per footCold Heros, 4ft or 6ftItalian or American. Includes mayo, oil & vinegar
• Hot Heros, 4ft or 6ftChicken, Meatball, Eggplant Parmigiana, Cheesesteak $19.00 per foot
• Grilled Chicken, 4ft or 6ftRoasted Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella $22.00 per foot

Chicken Entrées

• Chicken Marsala $20.75Chicken sautéed with mushrooms in marsala wine sauce and prosciutto
• Chicken Francese $20.75Chicken breast dipped in egg batter and sautéed in a wine and lemon sauce
• Chicken Piccata $20.75Chicken breast delicately sautéed with white wine, lemon & artichoke hearts
• Chicken Scarpariello $20.75Chicken breast and sweet Italian sausage delicately sautéed with a lemon, garlic & wine sauce
• Chicken Sorrentino $20.75Chicken sautéed in white wine topped with prosciutto, sliced tomato & mozzarella
• Chicken Mediterranean $20.75Chicken, eggplant, diced tomatoes & zucchini sautéed in chunk tomato and wine sauce, topped with mozzarella
• Chicken Parmigiana $20.75Chicken delicately sautéed and covered with mozzarella & tomato sauce
• Chicken Rollatini $20.75Breast of chicken rolled with cheese, ham & assorted seasonings, cooked in a wine sauce with mushrooms
• Chicken Cacciatore $20.75Chicken breast cooked with onions and peppers sautéed in a plum tomato sauce and a splash of wine
• Chicken Mediterranean $20.75

Veal Entrées

• Veal Rollatini $22.80Veal cutlet rolled with cheese, ham & seasonings, cooked in a delicate wine sauce with mushrooms
• Veal Francese $22.80Veal dipped in egg batter and sautéed in a wine and lemon sauce
• Veal Cacciatore $22.80Veal cooked with onions, mushrooms & peppers, sautéed with plum tomatoes and a splash of wine
• Veal Marsala $22.80Veal sautéed with mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce and prosciutto
• Veal Parmigiana $22.80Veal sautéed and covered with mozzarella & tomato sauce
• Veal Piccata $22.80Veal delicately sautéed with white wine, lemon & artichoke hearts
• Veal Sorrentino $22.80Veal sautéed in white wine, topped with prosciutto, sliced tomato & mozzarella
• Veal Cacciatore $22.80

Italian Favorites

• Chicken & Sausage Campagnola $19.70Chicken breast & sweet Italian sausage fried with sweet peppers, potatoes, onions and hot vinegar peppers
• Eggplant Parmigiana $19.70Eggplant delicately sautéed & covered with mozzarella and sauce
• Eggplant Rollatini $19.70Tender eggplant stuffed with our own seasonings, ricotta & mozzarella
• Sausage & Peppers Parm $18.65
• Carlo's Delight $18.65Combination of lasagna, stuffed eggplant & veal cutlet parmigiana
• Carlo's Special $18.65Combination of veal cutlet parmigiana & eggplant parmigiana
• Carlo's Italian Surf & Turf $23.85Golden fried shrimp & tender veal cutlet in our special marinara sauce, covered with mozzarella cheese
• Pasta Pleasure Combo $20.70Stuffed shells, ravioli, and manicotti
• Chicken & Sausage Campagnola $19.70
• Eggplant Parmigiana $19.70
• Carlo's Delight $18.65
• Carlo's Special $18.65
• Pasta Pleasure Combo $20.70

Pasta Dishes

• Baked Ziti $18.00
• Lasagna (Homemade) $18.00
• Manicotti (Homemade) $18.00
• Stuffed Shells Parm (Homemade) $18.00
• Ravioli Parmigiana $18.00Stuffed with cheese
• Lobster Ravioli $19.70Choice of alfredo, vodka, or marinara
• Tortellini Alfredo $18.66White cream sauce
• Rigatoni with Meat Sauce $21.20Our tomato sauce with ground beef
• Spaghetti with Broccoli $18.60Sautéed with garlic and oil
• Linguini Carretiere $17.50Fresh tomatoes, basil, garlic & olive oil
• Penne Arrabiata $17.50Garlic & hot cherry peppers in a spicy marinara sauce
• Penne alla Vodka $21.80Penne pasta in a pink creamy vodka sauce with red onions and ham
• Fettuccine Alfredo $19.80Fettuccine pasta in a creamy alfredo sauce
• Fettuccine Carbonara $20.85Prosciutto & peas in a white cream sauce with mozzarella on top
• Fettuccine Primavera $19.80Mushrooms, onions, broccoli, peppers, zucchini, and basil in a pink cream sauce
• Linguini Puttanesca $18.60Fresh tomatoes, garlic, capers, olives & anchovies
• Linguini with Clam Sauce $20.85Seasoned clam sauce, red or white, with garlic
• Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce $13.55Topped with our original tomato sauce
• Penne Alfredo with Chicken $24.30Pasta in a creamy alfredo sauce with sautéed chicken breast, fresh tomato, and peas
• Linguini con Broccoli Rabe $20.85Sauteed broccoli rabe, sweet Italian sausage, garlic & oil over linguini
• Pasta with Meatballs or Sausage (2) $19.75Linguini pasta topped with our tomato sauce, with meatballs or sausage
• Bow-Tie Pasta with Crab Meat $19.75Bow-tie pasta with onion and sun-dried tomato in a pink cream sauce
• Bow-Tie Pasta with Gorgonzola Cheese $19.75Bow-tie pasta with sun-dried tomatoes, prosciutto & mushrooms in a light pink sauce
• Rigatoni Boscaiola $19.75Rigatoni with sun-dried tomatoes, prosciutto, onions, and mushrooms served in tomato sauce with cognac and cream
• Ravioli Parmigiana $18.00
• Tortellini Alfredo $18.66 White cream sauce
• Linguini Carretiere $17.50
• Fettuccine Primavera $19.80
• Linguini Puttanesca $18.60
• Linguini con Broccoli Rabe $20.85

Paninis

• Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers & Fresh Mozzarella $8.30
• Mushrooms, Roasted Peppers & Fresh Mozzarella $8.30
• Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Fresh Mozzarella $8.30
• Eggplant, Roasted Peppers & Fresh Mozzarella $8.30

Sides

• Spinach or Broccoli $8.30
• French Fries $4.15
• Onion Rings $4.15
• Grilled Chicken $8.80
• Alfredo Sauce (16oz) $6.75
• Vodka Sauce (16oz) $6.75Side of Sauce4oz

Seafood

• Mussels Marinara or Bianco $20.75Mussels served in your choice of sauce
• Calamari or Scungilli Marinara $22.80Fresh squid or conch sauteed in our marinara sauce
• Seafood Scampi Combo $31.00Shrimp and lobster tail, sautéed in butter, garlic & white wine
• Seafood Terrano $28.00Lobster tail & shrimp sautéed in a marinara sauce
• Pescatore $27.00Shrimp, calamari, clams & mussels in a light marinara sauce
• Zuppa di Pesce $35.00Shrimp, scungilli, calamari, clams, mussels & lobster cooked together in a spicy, light marinara sauce
• Seafood Fra Diavolo alla Carlo $22.70Shrimp in a spicy marinara sauce served with mussels & clams
• Pescatore $27.00
• Zuppa di Pesce $35.00

Shrimp Entrées

• Shrimp Marinara $22.80Shrimp sautéed in our marinara sauce
• Shrimp Parmigiana $22.80Shrimp breaded, topped with mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce
• Shrimp Farfalle $22.80Shrimp combined with garlic, broccoli rabe & sun-dried tomatoes and sauteed in olive oil & white wine
• Shrimp Oreganata $22.80Shrimp topped with seasoned bread crumbs in a light sauce of butter, garlic & white wine
• Shrimp Scampi $22.80Shrimp in garlic, butter & wine sauce
• Shrimp Alfredo $22.80Shrimp sautéed in a creamy alfredo sauce
• Shrimp Piccata $22.80Shrimp sautéed with artichoke hearts with white wine, lemon, and butter
• Shrimp with Garlic & Oil $22.80Shrimp sautéed and seasoned in garlic & oil sauce
• Shrimp Fra Diavolo $22.80Shrimp in a spicy marinara sauce
• Shrimp in Pesto $22.80Shrimp sautéed in a creamy pesto sauce
• Stuffed Shrimp $22.80Shrimp stuffed with a crab meat filling
• Stuffed Francese $22.80Dipped in egg-batter and sautéed in a lemon wine sauce
• Shrimp Farfalle $22.80

Rolls & Calzones

• Chicken Roll $8.30
• Sausage Roll $8.30
• Calzone (with sauce) $6.75
• Calzone (with ham & sauce) $8.30
• Deep Fried Calzone $6.75
• Spinach Wheel $3.70
• Pepperoni Wheel $3.70
• Family Calzone $16.35
• Family Calzone (with ham & sauce) $19.35

Children's Menu

• Spaghetti & Meatball (1) $10.30
• Baked Ziti $10.30
• Ravioli (Cheese) $10.30
• Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana with Pasta $11.35
• Chicken Fingers with French Fries $10.30
• Spaghetti & Tomato Sauce $8.60

Dessert

• Cannoli

Catering Packages

• Feeds 10 $125.00
• Feeds 15-20 $275.00
• Feeds 30-35 $385.00

Salad Full TrayCaesar or Garden

• Feeds 50 $620.00
• Feeds 75 $720.00
• Feeds 100 $1,120

ItemSmall TrayLarge Tray

• Baked Clams $70.00 / $100.00
• Mussels Marinara or Bianco $70.00 / $100.00
• Fried Calamari $65.00 / $95.00
• Clams Casino $75.00 / $105.00
• Mini Rice Balls $65.00 / $90.00
• Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato $65.00 / $95.00
• Stuffed MushroomsWith crabmeat $65.00 / $95.00
• Broccoli RabeGrilled chicken or sausage $65.00 / $100.00
• French Fries $45.00 / $55.00
• Zucchini Sticks $45.00 / $55.00
• Mozzarella SticksMinimum 3 dozen $18.00 per dozen
• Chicken WingsHot or BBQ, minimum 3 dozen $18.00 per dozen
• Chicken FingersMinimum 3 dozen $18.00 per dozen
• Stuffed Pepper KnotsMinimum 3 dozen $23.00 per dozen
• Stuffed Tomato KnotsMinimum 3 dozen $23.00 per dozen
• Baked Ziti $65.00 / $90.00
• Baked Lasagna $75.00 / $105.00
• Baked Shells $70.00 / $90.00
• Baked Manicotti $65.00 / $80.00
• Baked Ravioli $65.00 / $80.00
• Eggplant Parmigiana $70.00 / $90.00
• Eggplant Rollatine $75.00 / $105.00
• Sausage and PeppersWith onions & tomato sauce $65.00 / $90.00
• Sausage Parmigiana $70.00 / $90.00
• Meatballs in Sauce $75.00 / $110.00
• Penne ala Vodka $70.00 / $95.00
• Cheese TortelliniAlfredo or tomato sauce $75.00 / $105.00
• Spaghetti with Clam SauceRed or white $70.00 / $100.00
• Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce $55.00 / $70.00
• Spaghetti and BroccoliWith garlic & oil $65.00 / $85.00
• Linguini with Garlic & Oil $55.00 / $70.00
• Linguini with Calamari Marinara $70.00 / $105.00
• Bowtie with Crab Meat $70.00 / $100.00
• Rigatoni Boscaiola $70.00 / $90.00
• Rigatoni with Meat Sauce $75.00 / $105.00
• Fettuccini Primavera $70.00 / $95.00
• Fettuccini Carbonara $70.00 / $95.00
• Fettuccini Alfredo $70.00 / $95.00
• Chicken Marsala $85.00 / $115.00
• Chicken Francese $85.00 / $115.00
• Chicken Parmigiana $85.00 / $115.00
• Chicken Cacciatore $85.00 / $115.00
• Chicken Piccata $85.00 / $115.00
• Chicken Mediterranean $85.00 / $115.00
• Chicken Sorrentino $85.00 / $115.00
• Chicken Scaprell $85.00 / $115.00
• Veal Parmigiana $80.00 / $125.00
• Veal Francese $80.00 / $125.00
• Veal Marsala $80.00 / $125.00
• Veal & Peppers $80.00 / $125.00
• Veal & Peppers Parm $85.00 / $135.00
• Shrimp Marinara $105.00 / $160.00
• Shrimp Fra Diavolo $105.00 / $160.00
• Shrimp Parmigiana $105.00 / $160.00
• Shrimp Scampi $105.00 / $160.00
• Shrimp Oreganata $105.00 / $160.00
• Seafood MarinaraShrimp, calamari, clams, mussels $105.00 / $160.00
• Greek Salad $60.00 / $80.00
• Caesar Salad $55.00 / $70.00
• Tossed Salad $50.00 / $60.00
• Antipasto $60.00 / $80.00
• Prices subject to change without notice. Racks & Sterno's available with a $20.00

Carlo's Pizza Shirley: hours and how to order