Sunset Beach Hotel

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY

Menu (As of 10/31)

• Oysters $28.00Bobby's selection, half dozen
• Clams $26.00shinnecock little neck, half dozen
• Tartare $32.00deep-sea Montauk tuna, tomato, ginger
• Crudo $28.00scallop, fennel pollen & lemon
• Ceviche $30.00striped bass, coconut, fresno, mango
• Shrimp Cocktail $28.00
• Rillettes $29.00hickory smoked North Fork fish, créme fraîche & trout roe Plateau de Fruits de Mer Petit, Grand 80 150
• Greek $32.00classic, feta, fresh oregano
• Caesar $30.00romaine, garlic croutons, anchovies, parmesan
• Panier de Crudités $29.00
• Sweet Peppers $17.00roasted, fresh thyme, olive oil
• Eggplant Caviar $17.00toasted flat bread
• Whole Artichoke $29.00steamed, lemon vinaigrette
• Ricotta $19.00fresh & hand-whipped, crispy chili, honey
• Octopus $34.00red vermouth marinated, herbes de Provence
• Softshell Crab $32.00golden fried, sauce tartar
• Calamari Fritti $35.00zucchini, roasted garlic aoili
• Vitello Tonnato $33.00thinly sliced veal, tuna-caper sauce
• Niçoise $35.00chopped, tuna, soft egg
• Butter Lettuce $27.00whole head, creamy vinaigrette, crispy onions
• Linguini alle Vongole $44.00
• Montauk Swordfish $55.00white wine, garlic, bottarga char-grilled, sauce vierge
• Moules Frites $40.00
• Whole Branzino $58.00NE rope-grown mussels sunset classic
• Cold Poached Salmon $45.00
• Bouillabaisse $60.00sauce tartare, cucumber classic 3 fish, potatoes, saffron, rouille, croutons
• Monkfish $47.00tempura, antibes vadouvan sauce ~
• Spaghetti alla Nerano $36.00
• 'Ratatouille' $41.00zucchini, parmesan, basil baked summer vegetables ~
• Rôtisserie Poussin $54.00
• Beach Burger $35.00caesar salad special sauce, gruyère, frites ~
• Ribeye 12 oz ~ NY Strip 8 oz $95.00LaFrieda 850 club prime beef, espelette butter
• Sunset Frites $17.00
• Local Mushrooms $17.00
• Charred Shishito Peppers $17.00
• Green Leaf Salad $17.00Corn on the cob 17
• Sunset Frites with Caviar $50.00
• A Good Pickle $1.00
• Sunburn $25.00tequila, blood orange, lime, hibiscus
• Crodino $29.00biondo Sanbittèr rosso
• Petite Rosé $17.00wölffer estate
• NV Prosecco ‘Jeio' $20.00Bisol, It
• Louis Roederer 'Collection 246' $38.00Brut, NV
• 2025 Sancerre $27.00Domaine Roger Champault, Loire Valley, Fr
• 2023 Chablis $27.00Georges Deschamps, Burgundy, Fr
• NV White Xarel-lo Garnacha Blend $21.00Avaline, Penedes, Spain
• 2025 Pinot Gris $23.00Bedell Cellars, North Fork, New York
• Pink Sangria $25.00rosé, booze & berries

California

• Chardonnay Routestock Sonoma County 2024 $120.00Chardonnay Grgich Hills, Sonoma County 2023 150 Sauvignon Blanc, Merry Edwards, Sonoma County 2023 170 Chardonnay ‘Wester Reach’, Russian River Valley, Dumol 2023 220 Chardonnay, Arista, Russian River Valley 2019 235 Chardonnay, Far Niente, Napa Valley 2023 250

France

• ProvenceLady A, Château La Coste, Provence 2024 100 Whispering Angel, Château D’Esclans, Côtes de Provence 2025 120 Château Minuty ‘Prestige’, Côtes de Provence 2025 130 Rock Angel, Château d’Esclans, Côtes de Provence 2025 145 Domaine Ott Château Romassan, Bandol 2024 Garrus, Château D’Esclans, Côtes de Provence 2023 280 Château Minuty ‘281’, Côtes de Provence 2024 281
• Ruinart Rosé NVLouis Roederer, Brut Rosé 2017 300
• Billecart-Salmon ‘Le Rosé’ NV
• Perrier-Jouët ‘Belle Epoque Rosé’ 2013
• Dom Pérignon Rosé 2010

Sunset Beach Hotel: hours and how to order