Off The Bay

220 N Main St, Sayville, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

Salads

• Shrimp Cocktail (5 pc) $24.00Bacon +4 / Chicken +10 / Shrimp +12 / Crab cake
• Burrata Salad $16.00
• Caesar Salad $14.00
• The Bay Salad $28.00

For the Table…

• Short Rib Croquettes (4 pc) $20.00

On Bread

• Steakhouse Bacon $16.00
• Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich $22.00
• Crab Cakes (2 pc) $24.00
• Off The Bay Steakhouse Burger $25.00
• Fried Calamari $18.00
• Mussels Arrabbiata $15.00
• Shrimp Po’ Boy $28.00
• Wings (8 pc) $16.00
• French Dip $32.00
• Twice Baked Potato $18.00
• Lobster Roll $38.00
• Grilled Octopus $24.00

Entrées

• Bacon Jam Burger Sliders $18.00
• Grilled Swordfish $36.00
• Hasselhoff Potato $14.00Baywatch - covered in butter and seasoning
• Prime Rib $48.00
• Knight Rider $18.00bacon, cheddar, gruyere, chives
• Bay Fries $15.00
• Best Chicken On The Block $26.00

Soups

• Lobster Tagliatelle $48.00
• French Onion Soup $11.00
• Fish & Chips $28.00
• New England Clam Chowder $14.00
• Seafood Chowder $15.00

Sides

• Charred Broccolini $14.00
• Roasted Tricolor Carrots $12.00

Cocktails

• Old Fashioned $16.00
• Espresso Martini $19.00fresh espresso, amaretto, belgian chocolate
• Manhattan $16.00Rittenhouse rye, Carpano Antica, Angostura
• Whiskey Sour $17.00Bourbon, fresh lemon, cane sugar, egg white
• Black Manhattan $16.00
• Rittenhouse rye, Amaro Averna $17.00New York Sour
• Sazerac $17.00Rittenhouse rye, Peychaud’s bitters,
• Separatist $17.00Bourbon, Amaro Averna, demerara, fresh lemon
• Billionaire $19.00
• Paper Plane $17.00fresh lemon, Peychaud’s bitters, absinthe
• Gold Rush $16.00
• Mexican Firing Squad $16.00Blanco tequila, house grenadine, fresh lime
• Boulevardier $17.00
• Oaxaca Old Fashioned $17.00demerara sugar, Angostura
• Daiquiri $16.00White rum, fresh lime, cane sugar
• Penicillin $17.00Scotch whiskies, honey-ginger, fresh lemon
• Mojito $16.00White rum, fresh lime, mint, cane sugar
• Jasmine $17.00Fords Gin, Campari, Cointreau, fresh lemon
• Mai Tai $20.00Aged rum, cointreau, fresh lime, cashew orgeat
• Southside $16.00Fords Gin, mint, fresh lemon, Angostura
• Montauk Lemonade $16.00Montauk blueberry whiskey, fresh lemon, mint
• Bee’s Knees $16.00Fords Gin, fresh lemon, honey
• French Martini $18.00Grey Goose vodka, Chambord, pineapple
• Negroni $16.00Fords Gin, Campari, Carpano Antica
• Mule $19.00

RED

• Pinot Grigio, Bellussi Natora 14 / 56Pinot Noir, À Tout de Suite
• Sauvignon Blanc, Oyster Bay 10 / 40Malbec, BenMarco
• Albariño, Faustino Rivera 12 / 48Cabernet Sauvignon, Oberon
• Paso Robles, California 12 / 48Chardonnay, Laroque

Sparkling

• Rosé, Château Montaud 12 / 48Côtes de Provence, France
• Prosecco, Villa Jolanda $12.00
• Lunch Package $24 per person

add-ons

• Two-course DINNER $44 per person

Dessert Package

• Three-course DINNER $62 per person

Beer & Wine

• Apps & Drinks Package $95 per person
• Top-shelf Open Bar $69 per personchoose four shareable apps

Small Plates Menu

• Short Rib Croquettes ~ braised short rib balls, panko crusted and served $8.00with spicy horseradish sauce and crumbled Parmesan ~
• Wings ~ citrus and Old Bay glaze, with lemon and scallion ~ $8.00
• Bacon Jam Slider ~ with pickle and aged cheddar on a sweet slider bun ~ $6.00
• Hand Cut Fries ~ cut fresh from Idaho potatoes, crisped, seasoned, and $6.00piled high, served with our house dipping sauce ~
• French Onion Soup ~ homemade with melted Gruyère and crostini ~ $6.00
• Twice Baked Potato ~ stuffed with braised short rib, topped with aged $7.00cheddar, sour cream and chives ~
• Fried Calamari ~ with spicy pomodoro, lemon, and confit garlic aioli ~ $9.00
• Risotto ~ creamy Parmesan risotto ~ $5.00
• vinegar, house tartar sauce, and lemon ~ $12.00
• sweet slider bun with a side of chips ~ $11.00
• Lobster Roll Slider ~ Maine lobster, citrus seafood aioli, fresh herbs, $13.00scallions, served on a soft buttery bun with a side of chips ~

Off The Bay: hours and how to order