Underground Pizza

2 William Street, New York, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

Lunch Specials

• Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta Lunch Special $16.95
• Eggplant Parmigiana with Pasta Lunch Special $16.95
• Shrimp Parmigiana with Pasta Lunch Special $17.95
• Meatball Parmigiana with Pasta Lunch Special $16.95
• Chicken Marsala Lunch Special $18.95
• Chicken Francese Lunch Special $18.95
• Breakfast Pizza $30.95Egg and Cheese Breakfast Pizza with Bacon
• Egg and Cheese Breakfast Pizza $26.95
• Egg and Cheese Breakfast Pizza with Sausage $30.95
• Western Breakfast Pizza $32.95
• Personal Pizza $18.95Plain Personal Pizza (12")
• Margherita Personal Pizza (12") $21.95
• Buffalo Chicken Personal Pizza (12") $22.95
• BBQ Chicken Personal Pizza (12") $22.95
• Vegetable Personal Pizza (12") $22.95
• Everything Personal Pizza (12") $22.65
• 1-Topping Personal Pizza (12") $20.95

Regular and Sicilian Pizza

• Plain Cheese Pizza $26.95
• Upside-Down Pizza $32.95
• Grandma Pizza $31.95
• Fresh Mozzarella Pizza $30.95
• Chicken Pizza $30.95
• Chicken Tomato Pizza $32.95
• Tomato Basil Pizza $30.95
• Bacon Jalapeno Pizza $30.95
• Margarita Pizza $31.95
• Pizza Blanca $31.95
• Anchovies Pizza $30.95
• Vegetable Pizza $35.95
• Primavera Pizza $35.95
• Everything Pizza $36.95
• Stuffed 18" Pizza $36.95
• Single Topping Pizza $30.95
• Meatball Pizza $30.95
• Sausage Pizza $30.95
• Pepperoni Pizza $30.95
• Broccoli Pizza $30.95
• Black Olive Pizza $30.95
• Ham Pizza $30.95
• Mushroom Pizza $30.95
• Bacon Pizza $30.95
• Spinach Pizza $30.95
• A Drizzle of Mikes Hot Honey on Any Pie $1.95
• Ben's Artisan New Calabrese Pizza $35.95
• NEW! Pizza La San Danielle $36.95

Pizza by the Slice

• Plain Pizza Slice $4.00
• Sicilian Slice $6.00
• Single Topping Pizza Slice $5.00
• Chicken Pizza Specialty Slice $7.45
• Chicken Tomato Specialty Slice $7.45
• Tomato Basil Specialty Slice $7.45
• Bacon Jalapeno Specialty Slice $7.45
• Margherita Pizza Specialty Slice $6.45
• White Pizza Specialty Slice $6.45
• Anchovies Pizza Specialty Slice $6.45
• Vegetable Pizza Specialty Slice $7.45
• Vegan Pizza Specialty Slice $7.45
• Everything Pizza Specialty Slice $7.45
• Grandma Slice $5.00
• Bruscetta Pizza Specialty Slice $7.45
• Double Topping Pizza Slice $5.95
• Fresh Mozzarella Specialty Slice $6.45

Hot Heroes

• Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero $16.95
• Meatball Parmigiana Hero $16.95
• Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $16.95
• Grilled Chicken Hero $15.95
• Chicken Cutlet Hero $15.95
• Meatball Hero $14.95
• Shrimp Parmigiana Hero $19.95
• Shrimp Hero $18.95

Lunch Pasta

• Lasagna Lunch $17.95
• Fettuccine Alfredo Lunch $16.95
• Fettuccine Chicken Alfredo Lunch $18.95
• Spaghetti Marinara Lunch $12.00
• Rigatoni Vodka Lunch $17.95
• Rigatoni with Broccoli and Garlic Oil Lunch $16.95
• Baked Ziti Lunch $16.95
• Stuffed Shells Lunch $16.95
• Penne with Chicken, Broccoli, Garlic and Oil Lunch $17.95
• Penne with Chicken, Spinach, Garlic and Oil Lunch $18.95

Calzones

• Cheese Calzone $10.95
• Meatball Parmigiana Calzone $12.95
• Spinach Calzone $12.95
• Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Calzone $12.95
• Ham and Cheese Calzone $12.95
• Sausage and Cheese Calzone $12.95
• Pepperoni and Cheese Calzone $12.95
• Eggplant Parmigiana Calzone $12.95

Salads

• House Salad $11.95
• Caesar Salad $12.95
• Cold Antipasto Salad $17.95
• Mediterranean Salad $17.95
• Greek Salad $17.95
• Grill Calamari Salad $19.95
• Appetizers $13.95Buffalo Wings (6)
• Mozzarella Sticks (6) $13.95
• Fried Calamari $18.95
• Garlic Knots (6) $4.00
• Garlic Knots a La Carte $1.00
• (NEW) Fried Chicken Tenders $13.95

Beverages

• Snapple $3.75
• Bottled Water $2.00
• Canned Soda $2.00
• Soda (2 Liter) $5.00
• Bottle Soda (20 oz) $3.75

Rolls

• Sausage and Pepper Roll $10.95
• Chicken Roll $10.95
• Pepperoni Roll $10.95

Dinner Pasta

• Linguine Alla Pescatora $21.95
• Gluten Free Cheese Pizza $26.95
• Gluten Free Meatball Pizza $30.95
• Gluten Free Sausage Pizza $30.95
• Gluten Free Pepperoni Pizza $30.95
• Gluten Free Broccoli Pizza $30.95
• Gluten Free Black Olive Pizza $30.95
• Gluten Free Mushroom Pizza $30.95
• Gluten Free Bacon Pizza $30.95
• Gluten Free Spinach Pizza $30.95
• Gluten Free Margarita Pizza $30.95

Vegan Pizza

• Vegan Cheese Pizza (Large) $29.95
• Vegan Personal Pleese Cheese Pizza $21.95
• Vegan Vegetable Pizza Large (No Cheese) $28.95
• Vegan Vegetable Personal Pizza (No Cheese) $23.95
• Vegan Large Cheese and Vegetable Pizza $36.95
• Vegan Cheese and Vegetable Personal Pizza $26.95
• Vegan Cheese Pizza (Gluten Free) $28.95

Bens Artisan Non-Keto Personal Pizza

• The Classic Cauliflower Crust Pizza (Gluten Free) $19.95
• The Classic Pepperoni Keto Pizza (gluten free) $20.95
• White Velvet Cauliflower Crust Pizza (gluten free) $20.95
• Meat Lovers Cauliflower Crust Pizza (gluten free) $21.95
• The Wall Street Cauliflower Crust Pizza (gluten free) $21.95
• Bens Lasagna Cauliflower Pie $21.95

Bens Old Fashioned Sicilian Soups

• Bens Ministrone Soup $6.95

Bens Artisan Keto Personal Pizza

• The Classic Keto Pizza $19.95
• The Classic Pepperoni Keto Pizza $20.95
• White Velvet Keto Pizza $20.95
• Meat Lovers Keto Pizza $21.95
• The Wall Street Keto Pizza $21.95
• Bens Lasagna Keto Pie $21.95

New Novelty Pizza

• Tri Color Sicillian Pizza $35.95
• Tri Color Sicillian Pizza Slice $6.00
• Sicillian Pepperoni Cups Pizza $35.95
• Sicillian Pepperoni Cups Pizza Slice $5.95

Underground Pizza: hours and how to order