Sarge's

548 3 Avenue, New York, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

Classic Sarge's Sandwiches

• Pastrami $28.79
• Rolled Beef $28.79
• Hot Corned Beef $27.76
• Boiled Ham $21.58
• Fresh Roast Turkey $24.67
• Tongue $29.82
• Hot Brisket of Beef $27.76
• Chopped Liver $23.64
• Turkey Pastrami $25.70
• Chicken Salad $20.55
• Roast Beef $27.76
• Egg Salad $18.49
• Salami $23.64
• Tuna Salad $19.52
• Hard Salami $23.64
• Whitefish Salad $22.61
• Half Sandwich and Soup $25.70

Soups

• Pick Any Two or Three Meats From the Above for $32.91
• Old Fashioned Chicken Soup $10.25
• Corned Beef & Pastrami $32.91

Coleslaw and Russian Dressing

• Souper Soup $15.40
• Half Sandwich and Soup $25.70
• Mushroom Barley Soup $10.25
• Sweet Baby Dave’s Pastrami $29.82
• Vegetable Soup $10.25
• Split Pea Soup $10.25
• Corned Beef or Pastrami Rueben $32.91
• Borscht $10.25With Sour Cream | Served Hot or Cold
• Hudson $33.94
• French Onion $12.31

Hot Sandwiches

• Beef Burger $20.55
• The Third Avenue $37.03
• Fried Kreplach $15.40 WHITEFISH / $27.76
• The Third Avenue $37.03 FRENCH ONION
• With fried onions $12.31
• Souper Soup $16.43 CONSOMMÉ / $8.19 $16.38
• Potato Pancake (1) $7.16
• Rice or Noodles $10.25 / $20.50 CHICKEN FINGERS / $17.46
• Hot Open Brisket $31.88 BORSCHT / $10.25

French Fries and Stuffed Derma

• Cheeseburger $22.61
• Hot Open Brisket $31.88

With French Fries and Gravy

• Patty Melt $22.61
• French Dip $32.91
• Skyscraper $27.76

With Horseradish Sauce

• Cheesesteak $32.91
• Sliders $20.55
• Cookout Burger $25.70
• Chicken Loco $31.88

and Onions

• Veggie Burger $17.46
• Chicken Parmesan $28.79
• Boneless Chicken Sandwich $24.68
• The Suzy Greenberg $28.79

Sides

• French Fries $10.25

on a Toasted Club Roll

• Sweet Potato Fries $11.28
• And Onions $9.22
• Jumbo Onion Rings $13.34Side of Bacon
• Breakfast Sausage $9.22
• Potato Salad $7.16
• Chicken Pot Pie $21.58
• Coleslaw $7.16
• Corned Beef Hash $18.49
• Macaroni Salad $7.16
• Baked Beans $10.20
• Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Roll $11.28

Substitute Ham or Sausage

• Kasha Varvishkas $12.31
• Pickled Tomatoes $8.19

Egg Barley

• Tossed Green Salad $10.20
• Grilled Cheese $11.28
• And Mushrooms $12.31Choice of American or Swiss.
• Stuffing $9.22
• Fruit Salad $8.19
• BLT on White Toast $16.43

Salad Platters

• Tuna Melt $26.73
• Tuna, Chicken or Egg Salad $23.64
• Turkey Club $28.79
• Chopped Liver $25.70
• Chicken Salad Club $27.76
• Whitefish $27.76
• Sarge’s Favorite $31.88

Unreal Deli

• 100% Plant Based $43.21ASSORTED COLD CUTS ALA SARGE
• Unreal Turkey or Corned Beef Sandwich $19.52
• Unreal Turkey or Corned Beef Reuben $23.64
• Hot Corned Beef Platter $33.94
• Wine By the Glass $10.25

Salads

• Hot Pastrami Platter $36.00
• Caesar Salad $20.55
• Combo Hot Corned Beef & Hot Pastrami Platter $37.03
• Chopped Salad $22.65

Chick Peas and Roasted Corn

• Tongue Platter $38.06
• Cobb Salad $26.73
• Chef’s Salad $27.76

Sarge's Jewish Classics

• Nova Scotia $23.64 / $8.19
• Smoked Whitefish Salad $23.64
• Potato, Kasha or Spinach Knish $8.19
• Nova Special $41.15
• Grilled Knockwurst on a Bun $10.25

Square Potato Knish Stuffed with

• Herring $13.34 EACH Hot Dog / $14.37
• Corned Beef $16.43
• Pastrami $18.49
• Tossed Green Salad $10.25
• Hard Salami $23.64
• Whitefish Salad $22.61

Pickled Herring Filet

• Gefilte Fish (Seasonal) $11.28
• Chopped Liver $15.40
• Bagel, Roll or English Muffin $4.07
• With marinated onions $6.13BAGEL, ROLL OR ENGLISH MUFFIN

Pickled Herring

• Stuffed Derma $17.46

In Cream Sauce

• Stuffed Cabbage $17.46
• Toast $3.04

All - Day Breakfast

• Fried Kreplach $15.40
• With fried onions $16.43THREE FRESH EGGS SERVED ANY STYLE
• Potato Pancake (1) $7.16
• Chicken Fingers $17.46
• Three Fresh Eggs Served Any Style $16.43

Traditional Classics

• Nova Scotia $10.25
• Pastrami or Corned Beef $12.31
• Boiled Chicken in the Pot $34.97
• Corned Beef Hash $11.28
• Pot Roast $34.97

Omelettes

• Garden $22.61 HALF ROAST CHICKEN / $34.97

With Stuffing, Potato and Vegetable

• Western $20.55 ROAST TURKEY / $34.97
• Hot Pastrami Platter $37.03
• Chicken Parmesan $28.79 CHEESEBURGER
• Roast Turkey $34.97
• Tongue Platter $38.06

Ham, Peppers and Onion

• Cheese $20.55
• Corned Beef & Cabbage $37.03
• Delicatessen $30.85
• “Specials” $30.85
• Original New York $11.28
• Topped with Strawberries $13.34

Make Your Own

• Broiled Salmon $36.00

From the Griddle

• French Fries $10.25
• Candied Sweets $9.22
• Challah French Toast $17.46 BAKED YAM / $9.22
• Corn on the Cob $8.19
• Baked Potato $8.19
• Fresh Broccoli $8.19
• Stack of Pancakes $17.46Blueberry or Chocolate Chip
• Mashed Potato $8.19
• Sliced Carrots $8.19
• Boiled Potato $8.19
• String Beans $8.19
• Home Fries $9.22
• Sweet Peas $8.19
• Sweet Potato Fries $11.28
• Creamed Spinach $10.25

Beverages

• Bagel, Roll or English Muffin $4.07
• Dr. Brown’s Soda $4.07
• Bagel, Roll or English Muffin $6.13
• Fountain Soda $4.12
• The Suzy Greenberg $28.79 SKYSCRAPER / $27.76
• “Specials” $30.85

With Cream Cheese

• Can of Soda $3.50
• Toast $3.04

Wheat, White or Rye

• Legendary Egg Cream $6.13

Chocolate or Vanilla

• Milkshake (Extra Thick) $9.22
• Columbian Coffee $4.07

Jewish Dairy Specials

• Premium Hot Tea $4.07
• Cheese Blintzes (3) $24.67
• Matzo Brei $19.52
• Juices $5.10
• Bacon, Ham, Sausage or Turkey Bacon $5.10

Apple, Cranberry, Grapefruit or Tomato

• Noodle Kugel $14.37
• Potato Pancakes (3) $19.52
• Orange Juice $6.13
• Iced Tea/iced Coffee $5.10
• Andy’s 18Th Hole $6.13
• French Fries $10.25
• BLT on White Toast $16.43
• Baked Yam $9.22
• Bottled Water $2.58

Alcoholic Beverages

• Wine By the Glass $10.25
• Beer $9.27
• House Liquor $12.31
• Premium Shelf $15.10
• Champagne $13.34
• Mimosa $13.34
• Screwdriver $13.34
• Bloody Mary $13.34

NY’s Best K

• Nova Scotia $23.64
• Challah French Toast $17.46
• Smoked Whitefish Salad $23.64
• Stack of Pancakes $17.46
• Nova Special $41.15Blueberry or Chocolate Chip

Onion, Tomato, Lettuce

• Herring $13.34 EACH

With Sour Cream

• Nova Scotia $10.25
• Noodle Kugel $14.37
• Pastrami or Corned Beef $12.31
• Matzo Brei $19.52
• Corned Beef Hash $11.28

With Apple Sauce

• Omelettes $19.52POTATO PANCAKES (3)
• Garden $22.61

Tomatoes, Onion, Mushrooms and Broccoli

• Western $20.55

Delivery

• Delicatessen $30.85
• Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip $13.34

& Takeout

• Apple Strudel $10.25
• Turkey or Corned Beef $5.15
• Carrot Cake $11.28
• Chocolate Fudge Cake $11.28
• Chocolate Mousse Cake $11.28
• Seven Layer Cake $11.28
• Banana Cream Pie $10.25
• Chocolate Cream Pie $10.25
• Pecan Pie $10.25
• Apple Crumble Pie $10.25
• Key Lime Pie $8.19
• A LA Mode $13.34

Large Black & White Cookie

• Large Chocolate Chip Cookie $5.10

French Ice Cream

• Chocolate or Vanilla $10.25 / $8.19
• Ruggelach (6) $8.19 / $9.22
• Rice Pudding $8.19
• Fruit Jello $8.19
• Pumpkin Pie (Seasonal) $8.19

Half of Our Classic Sandwich

• French Fries $10.25

Fried Mushrooms

• Sweet Potato Fries $11.28
• And Onions $9.22
• Pastrami $28.79
• Rolled Beef $28.79
• Sweet Baby Dave’s Pastrami $29.82
• Snaporazzo Hot Dog $8.19Side of Bacon

Jumbo Onion

• Hot Corned Beef $27.76
• Boiled Ham $21.58
• Rings $13.34
• Breakfast Sausage $9.22
• Fresh Roast Turkey $24.67
• Tongue $29.82
• Potato Salad $7.16
• Corned Beef Hash $18.49
• Corned Beef or Pastrami Rueben $32.91
• Potato, Kasha or Spinach Knish $8.19
• Hot Brisket of Beef $27.76
• Chopped Liver $23.64
• Coleslaw $7.16
• Baked Beans $10.22
• Turkey Pastrami $25.70
• Chicken Salad $20.55

Grilled To Perfection

• Grilled Knockwurst on a Bun $10.25
• Roast Beef $27.76
• Egg Salad $18.49
• Pickled Tomatoes $8.19
• Hudson $33.94
• Macaroni Salad $7.16
• Salami $23.64
• Tuna Salad $19.52

and Sauerkraut, Grilled

• Hot Dog $14.37 KASHA VARVISHKAS $12.31
• Stuffing $9.22
• Corned Beef $16.43 EGG BARLEY AND
• Fruit Salad $8.19
• Pastrami $18.49 MUSHROOMS / $12.31
• Pick Any Two or Three Meats From Above for $32.91
• Gefilte Fish (Seasonal) $11.28

Corned Beef & Pastrami

• Chopped Liver $15.40 SALAD PLATTERS

Recommended

• Coleslaw and Russian Dressing $32.91Bagel, Roll, Club Bread or Wrap
• Stuffed Derma $17.46
• Stuffed Cabbage $17.46 CHOPPED LIVER / $25.70

Mushroom

• Barley Soup $10.25 / $20.50

Cold Cut Platters

• Matzo Ball Soup for 2 $29.82 VEGETABLE SOUP $10.25 / $20.50
• French Dip $32.91
• Assorted Cold Cuts Ala Sarge $43.21
• Split Pea Soup $10.25 / $20.50 ENTREÉS
• Kreplach Soup for 2 / $29.82

Potato Salad / Feeds Two

• Cheesesteak $32.91
• Hot Corned Beef Platter $33.94
• Boiled Chicken in the Pot

Sarge's Famous Burgers

• Pot Roast $34.97
• Hot Pastrami Platter $36.00
• Chicken Loco $31.88
• Beef Burger $20.55
• Half Roast Chicken $34.97

Choice of Potato and Vegetable

• Patty Melt $22.61
• Legendary Egg Cream $6.13
• Chicken Pot Pie $21.58

Potato Salad and Coleslaw

• Boneless Chicken Sandwich $24.61
• Corned Beef & Cabbage $37.03

and French Fries

• Can of Soda $3.60
• Sliders $20.55
• Broiled Salmon $36.00

Melted American Cheese

• Chocolate or Vanilla $11.28BACON EGG AND CHEESE ON A ROLL
• Cookout Burger $25.70
• Milkshake (Extra Thick) $9.22

Sauteéd Mushrooms, and Onions

• Premium Hot Tea $4.07
• Grilled Cheese $11.28

Potatoes & Vegetables

• Veggie Burger $17.46
• Juices $5.10

Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato

• Milk $4.07
• Tuna Melt $26.73 SALADS
• Baked Potato $8.19

With Tomato and American Cheese

• Chocolate Milk $5.10

on Grilled Rye

• Caesar Salad $20.55
• Mashed Potato $8.19
• Boiled Potato $8.19
• Columbian Coffee $3.60 / $3.86 $4.38
• Turkey Club $28.79
• Chopped Salad $22.61
• Premium Tea $3.60 / $3.86 $4.38
• Home Fries $8.95
• Iced Tea/iced Coffee $4.12 / $4.63 $5.15
• Sweet Potato Fries $11.29 FOUNTAIN SODA / $3.35
• Chicken Salad Club $27.76

Sarge's: hours and how to order