O'Toole's Way

518 West 30 Street, New York, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

• pancakes, berries, maple syrup $10.00

“I Don’t Care”

• chicken fingers $10.00
• scrambled eggs, tater tots, bacon $10.00

“I Don’t Want That”

• for kids 12 and under $10.00grilled cheese

“Whatever”

• cheeseburger $10.00

“Fine”

• mac + cheese $10.00

Large Plates

• fresh market veggies $16.00
• two eggs - irish bacon - irish banger $14.00irish cheddar onion dip |

Cheese Plate

• whipped marmite butter $13.00
• irish cheddar - cashel blue $65.00roasted garlic - fries |
• baked beans $28.00

Short Rib Cottage Pie

• quince - fig - pear $24.00shrimp +15 / chicken +12 / salmon +14 / steak
• colcannon - irish cheddar $34.00

Sandwiches and Burgers

• beef bone broth - caramelized onionshouse chips or mkt salad -
• buffalo or guinness bbq $32.00apple cider and bourbon reduction |
• gratinated cheese - baguette soldiers $16.00

O’toole’s Burger

• crudités $15.00

Wagyu Beef Sliders

• burger sauce - b+b pickles $32.00charred lemon - fries |
• red wine vinaigrette $18.00
• toasted brioche bun $26.00

Fillet of Atlantic Salmon

• THE DUBLIN DIP “with its own gravy” $30.00salsa rosa - arugula - charred lime |
• toasted brioche bun $24.00
• shaved USDA prime rib - irish cheddar $19.00classic caesar dressing |

Pub Salad

• toasted baguette $34.00
• fresh mkt veggies $15.00lemon - grilled baguette |
• sherry vinaigrette $16.00

Fried or Grilled Chicken Sandwich

• salt and vinegar $30.00

The High Line

• quinoa - hummus - dried cranberry $22.00remoulade - toasted brioche bun |
• broccoli - toasted almonds $15.00sour cream - scallions |
• irish chip shop curry sauce $26.00
• carrot - maple dressing $18.00
• remoulade - brioche bun $22.00
• hp sauce - fries $22.00
• blue cheese dressing $15.00

Hand Rolled Sausage Roll

• garlic breadcrumbs - caesar dressing $22.00
• herb “zesto” - charred lime $38.00

Bar Pies

• puff pastry - hp sauce $18.00
• hollandaise - garden salad $22.00

For the Table

• roasted butternut & zucchini $22.00goat cheese - fresh arugula |
• Righteous Bloody Mary $21.00
• tomato - mozzarella - basil $18.00
• Fries $10.00
• irish chip shop curry sauce $26.00
• house mix - grilled shrimpparmesan & truffle oil +2 / dirty them
• Tier of All Three $58.00
• Home Fries $9.00
• Irish Espresso Martini $19.00
• Bacon $9.00

Steak Tartare

• egg yolk - crostini $26.00
• black & white pudding - baked beans $28.00

BBQ Chicken

• Fries $10.00
• aromatic cous cous – cilantro $26.00
• guinness bbq sauce - mozzarellaparmesan & truffle oil +2 / dirty them

Sirloin Steak on Toast

• red onion $21.00
• SHISHITOS grilled lime - tajin $10.00
• thumbit sauce contains mustard $2.00

Margherita

• GRILLED ASPARAGUS lemon $12.00
• tomato - mozzarella - fresh basil $18.00
• Tier of All Three $3.00prosciutto - garden squash - margherita
• Tier of All Three $6.00prosciutto - garden squash - margherita

Proudly Supporting Purveyors Including

• crostini - bt sauce $55.00
• Grilled Broccolini $10.00
• Tier of All Three $58.00
• CHAMP MASHED POTATOES fresh scallions $10.00
• Irish Bacon or Bangers $10.00
• Sourdough Toast $8.00

Morning Things

• irish cheddar onion dip $14.00

Sandwiches

• House-made Soda Bread $13.00
• beef bone broth - caramelized onionshouse chips or mkt salad -
• whipped marmite butter $18.00toasted sourdough - bacon |
• gratinated cheese - baguette $16.00

Signature Table-side

• house-made potato pancake $26.00toasted brioche bun |
• crispy bacon - red wine vinaigrette $18.00

Sausage Roll

• bell and evans chicken breast $19.00classic caesar dressing |
• hand rolled spiced irish sausage $22.00hot honey - marmite butter |
• puff pastry - hp sauce $18.00
• toasted baquette $34.00
• hp sauce

Espresso Rubbed

• market veggies - sherry vinaigrette $16.00

Red Pepper Hummus

• espresso rubbed grilled hanger steak $18.00carrot - maple dressing |
• chopped romaine - red onion - tomato $16.00fresh market veggies |
• breakfast potatoes - grilled tomato $22.00garlic breadcrumbs - caesar dressing |
• fried eggs - bt sauce $34.00

Brunch ‘Toole-box

• A Lil’ O’the Hair of the Dog $22.00toasted brioche bun |

Cottage Pie

• Proper Irish Coffee $15.00
• potato pancake - two poached eggs $30.00colcannon - irish cheddar |

Bananas Foster French Toast

• guinness battered atlantic cod $22.00goat cheese - fresh arugula |

Bottomless Irish Coffees

• candied pecans - whipped cream $20.00
• salt and vinegar $30.00
• 1.5 hours for $45.00

Spice Bag

• Mimosa $14.00
• red onion $21.00

Grilled Asparagus

• Colcannon $4.00irish mashed potatoes

Steak Frites

• roasted garlic - fries $5.00

Ham + Cheese Toastie

• cheddar - toasted brioche $7.00

Smoked Salmon

• capers - lemon crème fraîche $8.00

Toast

• marmite butter $9.00

Pavlova

• Irish Coffee Tiramisu $10.00

O'Toole's Way: hours and how to order