Made In New York Pizza

271 1/2 Amsterdam Avenue, New York, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

World Famous

• Spicy Pepperoni Square $6 slice / $40 pieSlow-cooked tomato sauce, mozzarella, pecorino romano, and spicy pepperoni cups.

Slices & Pies

• Cheese $4.25 / $29
• Pepperoni $5.25 / $34
• Sausage $5.25 / $34
• Mushroom $5.25 / $34
• Vodka $5.25 / $34
• Classic Margherita $5.25 / $34
• White Spinach $6 / $40
• Street Fair $6 / $40
• Yo Paulie $6 / $40
• Buffalo Chicken $6 / $40
• BBQ Chicken $6 / $40
• Chicken Bacon Ranch $6 / $40
• Vodka-Roni $6 / $40
• New Margherita $6.25 / $42
• Sausage Jalapeño $6 / $39
• Pepperoni Sausage $6 / $39
• Margherita (Stracciatella) $6.25 / $42

Squares

• Spicy Pepperoni $6 / $40
• Classic Sicilian $5.25 / $34
• Upside Down Sicilian $5.25 / $34
• Original Grandma $5.25 / $34
• Drunken Grandma $5.25 / $34
• Pepperoni Grandma $5.50 / $36
• White Sicilian $6 / $40
• Eggplant Sicilian $6 / $40
• Veggie $6 / $39
• White $6 / $39
• Eggplant $6 / $39

Sides & Salads

• Garlic Knots $4.50
• Pepperoni Wheel $5.00
• Cheese Calzone $9.00

Chicken Roll

• Chicken Roll $10.00
• Caesar Salad $10.00
• House Salad $11.00

Vegan

• Vegan Pie $24.00

Gluten-Free

• Gluten-Free Personal Pie $20.00
• Additional Toppings $3 each

Beverages

• Bottled Water $2.50
• Smart Water $3.50
• Bottled Soda $3.50
• Gold Peak Ice Tea $3.50
• Monster $4.00
• Mexican Soda $4.00

Sauces & Extra Toppings

• Standard Toppings $5 per topping

Pepperoni

• Additional Toppings $6 per topping

Sauces Available

• Marinara $1.00
• Ranch $1.25
• Hot Honey $1.50

Made In New York Pizza: hours and how to order