Middle Island Pizza

586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

Salads

• Italian Garden Salad Small $7.90 | Large $11.95 • Iceberg
• Pizzeria Salad Small $8.95 | Large $12.95 • Iceberg
• Chicken Salads Small $9.95 | Large $13.95 • Iceberg
• Burrata Salad Small $11.95 | Large $16.95 • Arugula
• Greek Small $9.95 | Large $13.95 • Iceberg
• Caesar Small $8.95 | Large $12.95 • Chopped
• Antipasto Small $10.95 | Large $14.95 • Iceberg
• Spinach Gorgonzola Small $11.95 | Large $15.95 • Baby
• Caprese Salad Small $10.95 | Large $16.95 • Sliced
• Roma Steak Small $12.95 | Large $17.95 • Romaine
• Monterey Salad Small $10.95 | Large $14.95 • Baby
• Strawberry Fields Salad Small $11.95 | Large $15.95 • Mixed
• Burrata & Tomato Small $9.95 | Large $14.95 • Arugala
• Italian House Small $35.00 | Full $70.00 • Romaine &
• Gorgonzola Small $45.00 | Full $90.00 • Baby
• Greek Small $45.00 Full $90.00 • House salad
• Caesar Small $40.00 | Full $80.00 • Romaine
• Antipasto Small $45.00 | Full $90.00 • House
• Italian Garden Salad Small $7.95 | Large $10.95 • Iceberg
• Pizzeria Salad Small $8.95 | Large $11.95 • Iceberg
• Chicken Salads Small $9.95 | Large $12.95 • Choice of.
• Burrata Salad Small $11.95 | Large $15.95 • Arugula
• Greek Salad Small $9.95 | Large $12.95 • Iceberg
• Italian Cobb Small $11.95 | Large $14.95 • Romaine
• Caesar Salad Small $8.95 | Large $11.95 • Chopped
• Alfredo's Antipasto Small $10.95 | Large $13.95 • Romaine
• Mediterranean Salad Small $11.95 | Large $14.95 • Grilled
• Spinach Gorgonzola Salad
• Caprese Salad $11.95
• Campania Small $11.95 | Large $14.95 • Romaine
• Roma Steak Salad

Soups

• Chicken Noodle Pint $6.95 | Quart $12.95 • Shredded
• Vegetable Minestrone Pint $6.95 | Quart $12.95 • Red beans
• Pasta Fagioli Pint $6.95 | Quart $12.95 • Crushed
• Seafood Bisque Pint $6.95 | Quart $12.95
• Class Buffalo $9.95
• Chipotle $9.95
• Pineapple Habanero $9.95
• CBR $9.95
• Italian Style $9.95
• Chicken Soup Pint $5.95 | Quart $11.95 • Chopped
• Vegetable Minestrone Pint $5.95 | Quart $11.95 • Assorted
• Pasta Fagioli Pint $5.95 | Quart $11.95 • Crushed
• Italian Wedding Pint $5.95 | Quart $11.95 • Spinach

Appetizers

• Meatballs & Burrata $13.95
• Wings $9.95
• Crispy Calamari $15.95
• Zucchini $10.95
• Breaded Ravioli $10.95
• Mozzarella Sticks $9.95
• Baked Clams $11.95
• Breaded Mozzarella Pearls $11.95
• Caccio & Pepe Balls $11.95
• Italian Breaded Shrimp Cocktail $13.95
• Mussel Bowls $15.95
• Toasted Penne $9.95
• Fiamma Shrimp $10.95
• Grilled Portobello $10.95
• Arancini (3) $10.95
• 6 Chicken Wings or 10 Piece Boneless $8.95
• Baked Clams (5) $10.95
• Zucchini Sticks $9.95
• Cauliflower Wings $8.95
• Mussels $12.95
• Fried Calamari $12.95
• Mozzarella Sticks (6) $8.95
• Crispy Artichoke (8) $9.95
• Wild Mushroom Crostini (4) $12.95
• Burrata & Meatballs (3) $12.95
• Caccio & Pepe Balls (5) $10.95
• Potato Croquettes (5) $10.95
• Crispy Flounder Strips $10.95
• Garlic Mozzarella Pearls $9.95

Pasta

• Penne Alla Vodka $17.95Shallot, garlic, plum tomato, cream, romano cheese
• Spaghetti & Tomato Sauce $14.95Slow cooked, imported Mutti Italian tomatoes
• Nonno's Gnocchi $18.95Potato gnocchi pasta, ground beef and veal meat sauce, touch of cream
• Baked Penne $17.95
• Stuffed Shells $17.95
• Ravioli $16.95
• Carbonara $18.95penne pasta, pancetta, mushrooms, peas, onions, romano cheese cream sauce
• Braised Bolognese $17.95Fresh pappardelle pasta, red wine braised ground beef & veal in a slow cooked tomato sauce
• Sunday Pasta $20.95
• Authentic Lasagna $17.95
• Alfredo $17.95Fettuccine pasta, parmesan cream sauce
• Farm to Table $19.95
• Harvest Tortellini $19.95
• Stuffed Rigatoni $19.95
• Cavatelli Sicilia $19.95

Seafood

• Old School Favorites $20.95
• Shrimp Scampi $21.95
• Shrimp Parmesan $21.95
• Cadillac Shrimp $21.95
• Linguine Clam Sauce $19.95
• Seafood Chop-Chop $22.95
• Salmon Crostino $23.95
• Calabrian Salmon $23.95
• Flounder Milanese $24.95
• Seafood Fra Diavolo $24.95
• Fried Calamari Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Fried
• Calamari Marinara Small $70.00 | Large $140.00
• Mussels Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Mussels
• Clam Sauce Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Baby
• Shrimp Parmigiana Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Breaded
• Shrimp Scampi Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Jumbo
• Shrimp Marinara Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Jumbo
• Zuppa Di Pesce Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Shrimps
• Shrimp & Scallops Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Jumbo
• Salmon Crostino Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Baked
• Salmon Saparito Small $70.00 | Large $140.00 • Broiled

Eggplant Dinners

• Eggplant Parm $18.95
• Eggplant Rollatini $19.95

Parmesan

• Chicken $19.95 | Veal $21.95 • Tomato sauce

Carbonara

• Chicken $20.95 | Veal $22.95 • Tomato sauce

Francese

• Chicken $20.95 | Veal $22.95 • Egg battered

Marsala

• Chicken $20.95 | Veal $22.95 • Cremini & button

Milanese

• Chicken $21.95 | Veal $23.95 • Panko crusted

Martini

• Chicken $21.95 | Veal $23.95 • Panko parmesan

Vodka

• Chicken $20.95 | Veal $22.95 • House vodka

Grilled

• Chicken $19.95 | Veal $21.95 • Marinara sauce

Signature Sandwiches

• Cittero $12.95
• Chicken Florentina $12.95
• Mamma Mia $12.95
• Bella Donna $12.95
• The Club $12.95
• Chicken Buffalo $12.95
• Chicken Ranch $12.95
• Chicken Guido $12.95
• Little Italy $12.95
• Portobello Capri $12.95Grilled marinated portobello caps, baby spinach, sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, roasted pepper, pesto, balsamic reduction
• Italiano $12.95
• Barca $12.95
• Flank Steak $12.95
• Chicken Caesar $12.95
• Chicken Paisano $12.95
• The Goat $12.95
• The Avenue $12.95
• The Hot Chic $12.95
• The PLT $12.95
• The Belitza $12.95
• Angry Nonna $12.95
• Balsamico Chicken $12.95

Heros

• Meatball Parmigiana $12.95
• Chicken Parmigiana $12.95
• Sausage Parmigiana $11.95
• Eggplant Parmigiana $11.95
• Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $14.95
• Shrimp Parmigiana $14.95
• Sausage & Meatball Parmigiana $11.95
• Sausage & Peppers Parmigiana $11.95
• Chicken Cheesesteak $14.95
• Frittata: Peppers, Onion, Potato, Eggs $11.95
• Chicken Marsala Parm $15.95

Sides

• Broccoli Rabe $7.95
• Broccoli or Spinach or Asparagus $6.95
• Meatballs (3) $8.95
• Sausage $7.95
• Chicken $8.95

Grilled or Fried

• Pasta $7.95

Kids Menu

• Chicken Finger & Fries $11.95
• Cheese Ravioli (3) $8.95
• Penne with Butter or Tomato Sauce $6.95

Dessert

• NY Cheesecake $6.95
• Red Velvet $5.95
• Chocolate Lovin' Cake $6.95
• Rainbow Cheesecake $6.95
• Cannoli $3.95
• Tiramisu $5.95
• Tartuffo $7.95

Neopolitan

• Small (6 slices) $16.50 | Large (8 slices) $18.40
• Sicilian $20.95
• Grandma Pizza $20.95
• Large Pan Pizza $20.95

Ultra-Crispy Thin Crust

• Ultra-Crispy Thin Crust $9.95/12"

Cauliflower Crust

• Cauliflower Crust $13.95/12"

Gluten Free Crust

• Gluten Free Crust $12.95/10”

Gourmet Pizza

• Everything $28.95
• Buffalo Chicken $28.95
• BBQ Chicken $28.95
• Chicken Bacon Ranch $28.95
• Chicken Parm $28.95
• Chicken Vodka $28.95
• Margherita $25.95
• White $25.95
• Meat Supreme $28.95
• Salad Pizza $29.95
• Crispino $26.95
• Chicken Cheesesteak $28.95
• Thai Chili Chicken $28.95
• Tomato Basil $25.95
• Mamma Mia $28.95
• Vegetable Supreme $26.95
• Balsamic Chicken $28.95
• Rigatoni Vodka $26.95
• Tre Colore $25.95

Pizzette

• Greens & Burrata $15.95
• Vodka-Rita $14.95
• Honey Spice Pepperoni $14.95
• Spinach Artichoke $15.95
• L.I. Clam Casino $16.95
• Angry Vodka $14.95
• Wild Mushroom $15.95
• Fra Diavolo $14.95
• New Yorker $11.95
• Margarita $13.95
• Arthur Avenue $15.95
• Bianco $15.95
• Mama's Pizza $15.95
• Cowboy $16.95
• OG Chicken $15.95
• Veggetini $15.95
• Sweet Thai Chili $15.95
• Meatball & Burrata $16.95
• Blue Cheese Buffalo $15.95
• Italian Stallion $16.95
• Appetizers $50.00Baked Clams (30)
• Clams Casino (30) $50.00
• Stuffed Mushrooms (30) $60.00
• Fried Jumbo Ravioli (24) $50.00
• Mozzarella Sticks (30) $45.00
• Zucchini Sticks (30) $45.00
• Pigs In A Blanket (50) $55.00
• Chicken Fingers (30) $50.00
• French Fries $35.00
• Italian Sliders (12) $45.00
• Mini Rice Balls (20) $55.00
• Crispy Artichokes $50.00

Garlic Bread Parmigiana

• Garlic Bread Parmigiana $40.00
• Sausage & Pepperoni Stromboli Platter $55.00
• Chicken Wings (30) $45.00

Half Trays

• Roasted Potatoes $40.00
• Baked Mac & Cheese $55.00
• Asparagus $55.00
• Rice $40.00
• Garlic Knot Tray $50.00
• Sautéed Broccoli Or Baby Spinach $45.00
• Mixed Vegetables $55.00
• Roasted Garlic Mashed Potato $65.00
• Pasta All Forno Small $45.00 | Large $90.00 • Baked
• Pasta Pomodoro Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Slow
• Pasta Melanzane Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Diced
• Pasta Alla Mamma Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Slow
• Pasta Bolognese Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Hearty
• Pasta Primavera Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Fresh
• Venetian Pasta Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Grilled
• Pasta Alla Tuscany Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Grilled
• Pasta Carbonara Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Peas
• Tortellini Alfredo Small $55.00 | Large $110.00
• Pasta Casalinga Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Chicken
• Pasta Alfano Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Chicken
• Pasta Alla Vodka Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Cream
• Pasta Alla Vodka with Chicken Small $65.00 | Large $125.00 • Cream
• Pasta Amatriciana Small $65.00 | Large $125.00 • Onions
• Gnocchi Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Plum
• Pasta Antica Small $55.00 | Large $110.00
• Pasta Chicken Gorgonzola Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Chicken
• Pasta Palermo Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Sausage
• Pasta Rustico Small $55.00 | Full $110.00 • Sausage
• Lobster Ravioli Small $55,00 | Full $110.00 • Lobster

Chicken

• Chicken Parmigiana Small $60.00 | Large $120.00 • Pomodoro
• Chicken Cacciatore Small $60.00 | Large $120.00
• Chicken Marsala Small $60.00 | Large $120.00
• Chicken Francese Small $60.00 | Large $120.00 • Lemon
• Chicken Scarpiello Small $60.00 | Large $120.00 • Sausage
• Chicken Piccata Small $60.00 | Large $120.00 • Capers
• Chicken Roma Small $60.00 | Large $120.00 • Grilled
• Chicken Teriyaki Small $60.00 | Large $120.00 • Carrots
• Chicken Semi-Freddo Small $60.00 | Large $120.00 • Mixed

Carne

• Sausage & Peppers Small $50.00 | Full $100.00
• Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Small $50.00 | Full $100.00
• Pepper Steak
• Meatballs Small $60.00 | Full $120.00
• Veal Parmigiana
• Veal Marsala
• London Broil

Eggplant

• Eggplant Parmigiana Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Breaded
• Eggplant Rollatini Small $55.00 | Large $110.00
• Eggplant Napoletano Small $55.00 | Large $110.00 • Breaded

Platters

• Italiano Antipasto Small $70.00 | Full $140.00 • Dried
• Caprese Small $50.00 | Full $100.00 • Fresh

Bread Basket

• Bread Basket Small $20.00 | Full $40.00 • Garlic
• Focaccia’s Small $25.00 | Full $50.00 • Choice of
• Bruschetta Small $30.00 | Full $60.00 • Italian
• Fruit Small $35.00 | Full $70.00 • In-season
• Cheese Platter Small $45.00 | Full $90.00 • Cubed

Wrap & Panini Platter

• Wrap & Panini Platter $13.95/Per Person

Mini Cannoli Tray

• Small (12 pieces) $40.00 | Medium (24 pieces) $55.00
• Cookie Platter $20.00/per pound

Party Heroes

• Traditional Italian $18.95/foot
• Classic American $18.95/foot
• Chicken Club $21.95/foot
• Milano $21.95/foot
• Tuscan $21.95/foot
• Mamma Mia $21.95/foot
• Gallo $21.95/foot
• Chicken Portobello $21.95/foot
• Philly Cheese Steak $21.95/foot
• Chicken Cali $21.95
• Chicken Buffalo $21.95
• Chicken Ranch $21.95
• Bella Donna $21.95

Middle Island Pizza: hours and how to order