The Old Mill Inn

5775 Mill Rd, Mattituck, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

Raw Bar

• The Peconic Bay Shellfish Platter $98.00

To Share & to Start

• House-Made Buttermilk Biscuits, Honey Butter $12.00
• Smashed Artichoke, Whipped Ricotta, Aged Balsamic $17.00
• Baby Kale & Squash Salad, Pumpkin Seeds, Aged Gouda $21.00
• Burrata & Beets, Pistachio Pesto, Focaccia ............06 $23.00
• Roast Oysters, ‘Nduja, Scallion Butter ..............206 $24.00
• Tuna Tartare, Avocado, Cucumber, House-Made Tortilla $27.00
• Grilled Point Judith Squid, Shishito, Chili, Basil Aioli $22.00
• Crab & Artichoke Dip, Sourdough Toast. .............4 $24.00
• Fried Oyster Sliders, Smokey Slaw, Fresno Chili Mayo $21.00
• Black Garlic Duck Wings, Creme Fraiche Ranch $19.00
• Beet Hummus, Tablouleh, Grilled Foccacia $16.00
• ‘Mattituck Mushroom’ Toast, Ricotta, Herbs $21.00
• Burrata, Confit Heirloom Tomato, Foccacia $24.00
• Tuna Tartar, Avocado, Cucumber, House-Made Tortilla $27.00
• Grilled Point Judith Squid, Shishito, Chili, Basil Aoili $22.00
• Crab & Artichoke Dip, Sourdough Toast $24.00
• Black Garlic Duck Wings, Creme Fraiche Ranch $21.00

Classics

• Little Gem Caesar Salad, Bacon, Anchovy, Breadcrumbs $24.00
• Baja Fish Tacos $24.00Gluten Free), Avocado Crema, Spicy Slaw
• Mortadella & Burrata Sandwich, Pistachio Pesto, Focaccia $26.00
• Fish & Chips $35.00Gluten Free), Classic Tartar Sauce... ........0
• Linguini & Local Littleneck Clams, Garlic, Fresh Herbs $36.00
• Simply Grilled w/Local Vegetables, Salsa Verde $42.00
• With our Market Vegetable Curry $42.00
• Roast Half Chicken, Duck Fat Potatoes, Spinach Rosemary Jus $38.00
• Double Burger, New School American, Onion, Aioli, Pickles, Fries $27.00
• Market Vegetable Curry, Coconut Milk, Chickpea $29.00
• Linguini & Littleneck Clams, Garlic, Fresh Herbs $36.00
• Millstone Half Chicken, Duck Fat Potatoes, Rosemary Jus $38.00
• Local Tilefish, Simply Grilled w/Local Vegetables, Salsa Verde $42.00
• Over Our Vegetable Curry $42.00
• Iberico Pork Chop, Roast Squash, Spinach, Apple Cider Jus $44.00

Sides

• Sauteed Organic Spinach... ......... 0.2.0.2. e ee nee $13.00
• Roast Local Squashes ..... 2... 2.0... eee ee ee ees $16.00
• Sauteed Spinach... .. 2... ee ee $14.00
• Roast Local Squashes ..... 2... 2... eee ee es $16.00

Negroni On Draft

• Gin, Campari, Carpano Antica $18.00

Bees Knees

• Rye Whiskey, Honey, Lemon $19.00

Mezcal Negroni

• Palomo Mezcal, Campari, Carpano $18.00

Cucumber Collins

• Gin, Fresh Cucumber, Ancho Verde $18.00

Blanco Tequila, Pear

• Cinnamon Rim $19.00

Good Morning Margarita

• Ritual Tequila, Fresh Lime, Agave $16.00

Beer &

• Draft $9.00

Old Mill Manhattan

• Rye, Carpano Antica, Averna $18.00

Apple Cider Spritz

• Apple Cider Cordial, Cremant $17.00
• Clarified Pina Colada $19.00A Milk-Punch Take On The Classic

Fig Old Fashioned

• Rye, Fig, Bitters $19.00

Hemingway Rum Punch

• Gosling’s Float $18.00

Spritz In Your Step

• Lyre’s Aperitivo, Wolffer Sparkling $16.00

Cider

• Bottle / Can $8.00

The Old Mill Inn: hours and how to order