Nick & Toni's
136 N Main St, East Hampton, NY
Menu (As of 10/29)
- For the Table $22.00Warm Rosemary & Sea Salt Focaccia Whipped Honey Ricotta, Tomato Confit Pesto
- Nick & Toni’s Zucchini Fritti Lemon $23.00
- Marinated Castelvetrano & Alfonso Olives $12.00
Antipasti
- Nick &Toni’s Garden Greens Pickled Radish, Fresh Herb Vinaigrette $24.00
- Romaine Salad Caesar Dressing, Grana Padano DOP, Garlic Croutons $26.00
- Local Littleneck Clams Saffron Fennel Broth, Heirloom Beans, Toasted Bread $32.00
- Balsam Farms Baby Arugula Salad Halsey Farms Pear, Hazelnuts, Aged Balsamic $27.00
- Prime Beef Tenderloin Tartare* Calabrian Chile, Quail Egg, Crostini $34.00
Primi
- Penne alla Vecchia Bettola Spicy Oven Roasted Tomato, Grana Padano DOP 22/32
- Risotto Mattituck Farm Mushrooms, Grana Padano DOP 27/42
- House-made Tagliatelle Duck Ragù, Pecorino Romano DOP 26/36
- PIZZA AL FORNO Wood Fired 10” $24.00Margherita Pomodoro, House-made Mozzarella, Basil
- Salsiccia Pork Sausage Ragú, Besciamella, Smoked Provolone, Basil $28.00
- Pepperoni Pomodoro, House-made Mozzarella, Hot Honey $27.00
- Quattro Formaggio Ricotta, Mozzarella, Fontina, Parmigiano Reggiano $27.00
- Secondi $47.00Roasted Market Catch Sunchoke Crema, Roasted Sunchokes, Hazelnut Pesto
- Grilled Local Striped Bass Farrotto, Braised Endive $52.00
- Roasted Romanesco Cauliflower White Bean Purée, Walnut Salsa Verde $38.00
- Wood Grilled Berkshire Pork Chop Nick & Toni’s Garden Greens, Apple Mostarda $58.00
- Wood Grilled Prime New York Strip Steak* $85.00
- Contorni $16.00Baby Spinach Chickpeas, Lemon
- Roasted Mattituck Farm Mushrooms $17.00
- Crushed Yukon Gold Potatoes Grano Padano DOP $16.00
- Roasted Sunchokes Pecorino Romano DOP, Lemon $16.00
- Vero Filtered Sparkling & Still Water $8.00
Secondi
- Roasted Market Catch Sunchoke Crema, Roasted Sunchokes, Hazelnut Pesto $47.00
- Grilled Local Striped Bass Farrotto, Braised Endive $52.00
- Wood Oven Roasted Whole Fish Salsa Verde $49.00
- Wood Oven Roasted Romanesco Cauliflower White Bean Purée, Walnut Salsa Verde $38.00
- Wood Grilled Berkshire Pork Chop Nick & Toni’s Garden Greens, Apple Mostarda $58.00
- Wood Grilled Prime New York Strip Steak* $85.00
- Contorni $16.00Baby Spinach Chickpeas, Lemon
- Roasted Mattituck Farm Mushrooms $17.00
- Crushed Yukon Gold Potatoes Grano Padano DOP $16.00
- Roasted Sunchokes Pecorino Romano DOP, Lemon $16.00
- Vero Filtered Sparkling & Still Water $8.00
Desserts
- Flourless Chocolate Cake $16.00
- Warm Halsey Farm Apple Crostata $17.00
- Lemon Meringue Tart $17.00
- NICK & TONI’S TARTUFO (for two) $32.00
- Stracciatella Gelato $15.00
Chocolate Biscotti
- Concord Grape-rosemary Sorbetto $14.00
Tuille
- Nick & Toni’s Biscotti $14.00
For Five Coffee Roasters
- Grand Ave Roast $6.00
- Decaf Americano $7.00
- Mott Espresso $7.00
- Decaf Espresso $7.00
- Cappuccino / Latte $8.00
- Double Espresso $8.00
Organic Rishi Tea & Botanical
Organic Matcha Tea, Japan
- Matcha $8.00
- Matcha Cappuccino $9.00
- Matcha Latte $9.00
After Dinner
- VILLA MASSA LIMONCELLO [Sorrento] $14.00
- Espresso Martini $22.00
Amaro
- Cardamaro [Piemonte] $10.00
- Fernet Branca [Lombardy] $12.00
- Braulio Riserva [Lombardy] $23.00
- Nonino [Friuli] $14.00
- Giuseppe Cappelletti Pasubio [Alto Adige] $10.00
- Alta Gradazione ‘Amario’ [Lazio] $15.00
- Averna [Sicily] $13.00
- Dell’Etna Antico D’Erbe [Sicily] $15.00
Chinato
- Capellano [Barolo] $22.00
- S e B Borgogno [Barolo] $16.00
Chartreuse
- Les Pères Chartreux Yellow $20.00
- Les Pères Chartreux Green $20.00
- VEP Green $40.00
Bubbles
- PROSECCO JEIO Brut Valdobbiadene Superiore NV $68.00
- SPARKLING ROSÉ EMPIRE ESTATE Finger Lakes NV $72.00
White
- SAUVIGNON BLANC DOMAINE PASCAL BALLAND Sancerre 2025 $88.00
- VERMENTINO CANTINE LUNAE ‘Etichetta Griga’ Colli di Luni 2025 $72.00
- PINOT GRIGIO VIA ALPINA Friuli-Venezia Giulia 2024 $76.00
- ETNA BIANCO GRACI Sicily 2024 $84.00
- CHARDONNAY FAMILLE SAVARY Chablis 2025 $92.00
ROSÉ
- FRANCONIA CHANNING DAUGHTERS The Hamptons 2025 $72.00
- GRENACHE/CINSAULT CHÂTEAU MIRAVAL Cotes de Provence 2024 $80.00
RED
- SYRAH ETIENNE BECHERAS ‘Le Prieure d’Arras’ Saint-Joseph 2023 $84.00
- PINOT NOIR VINCENT GIRARDIN ‘St Vincent’ Bourgogne 2023 $92.00
- NEBBIOLO G.D. VAJRA ‘Albe’ Barolo 2022 $92.00
- SUPER TUSCAN TOLAINI ‘Al Passo’ Toscana 2022 $80.00
- CABERNET FRANC WÖLFFER ESTATE ‘Caya’ Long Island 2021 $84.00
Chilled Red
- SCHIOPPETTINO RONCHI DI CIALLA Colli Orientali del Fruili 2023 $76.00
- Beer $12.00NICK & TONI’S X SAND CITY BREWING CO.
- MONTAUK BREWING CO. ‘WAVE CHASER’ IPA Montauk, NY 12oz 6.4% ABV $10.00
- Zero Proof $16.00NON ALCOHOLIC ROSÉ Wölffer ‘Spring in a Bottle’
- PERONI LAGER Rome, IT 11.2oz 0.0% $8.00
- GUINNESS 0 NON ALCOHOLIC Dublin, Ireland 14.9 fl oz 0.0% $9.00
- Aplos Functional $15.00
- Paloma Pirata $15.00
- fresh grapefruit, Q grapefruit soda $15.00PHONY NEGRONI St. Agrestis, Brooklyn, NY 6.8oz
- Classic (Faux Gin), Smoky (Faux Mezcal) $15.00AMARO FALSO St. Agrestis, Brooklyn, NY 6.8oz
- Cocktails $22.00
Nick & Toni's: hours and how to order