Available Oct 19 - Oct 31$3.75Fun, spooky Halloween assorted cake pops this season to celebrate the holiday!Festive vanilla cake pops with classic spooky colors, purple, green, orange, and Halloween sprinkles that are perfect for the spooky season, available by the dozen.
Available Oct 19 - Oct 31$4.50Fun, spooky and bloody Halloween eyeball cake pops for this season to celebrate the holiday!These festive vanilla and chocolate cake pops are perfect for the spooky season, Halloween parties, and gatherings, available individually or by the dozen.
Halloween Cupcakes
Available Oct 14 - Oct 31$6.00Our special Halloween Cupcakes come in a pack of 6! With Chocolate, vanilla, and red velvet flavors and buttercream.Red Velvet Brain Jack Skeleton Bloody EyeballButtercream GhostBlack CatGreen Monster
Halloween Whoopie Pies
Available Oct 27 - Oct 31$5.75Fun Halloween treats this season!Chocolate and vanilla whoopie pies filled with sweet filling and topped with spooky gummy worms for a delightfully creepy Halloween treat!
Available Oct 14 - Oct 31$114.95
Cakes (21)$50.00Cakes Available In Store Today
Classic Birthday Cake (Large)
GF options$50.00Our most beloved flavor: moist vanilla cake filled with house-made berry jam and wrapped in silky vanilla buttercream. The perfect celebration cake.
Strawberry Shortcake Cake
GF options$60.00Buttermilk Bakeshop's version of a Strawberry Shortcake! Vanilla cake filled with a thin layer of strawberry jam, fresh strawberries, and meringue buttercream.
Pistachio Honey Cake
GF options$60.70Pistachio cake, honey mascarpone filling, fresh black berries on top.
Photo Cake$95.00Pre-order (min 2 days notice)
Red Velvet Cake
GF options$52.09Classic red velvet layers infused with a hint of cocoa, wrapped in our silky cream cheese frosting. Rich, velvety, and perfectly moist - a timeless Southern favorite that strikes the ideal balance between subtle chocolate notes and tangy sweetness.
Cookie Cake
GF options$35.60Select your cookie style:Salted Nutella: Rich chocolate cookie infused with hazelnut spread and finished with sea saltChocolate Chunk: Classic buttery cookie loaded with premium dark chocolate piecesSprinkle: Cheerful sugar cookie studded with rainbow sprinkles
Coconut Passion Fruit Cake
GF options$62.09A delicate vanilla cake, creamy coconut ganache, and a bright, tangy passionfruit layer. Decorated with floral elements, this cake perfectly balances rich, creamy coconut with the refreshing tartness of passionfruit.
Cranberry Carrot Cake
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$52.09Delicious cranberry carrot cake wrapped in our silky cream cheese frosting. Moist, warmly spiced, and irresistibly rich, this cake is perfect for the season.
Ding Dong Cake
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$60.00Deliciously rich chocolate cake decorated as a favorite childhood dessert! Wrapped in chocolate ganache, a chocolate crumb, and filled with fluffy vanilla cream. Moist, warmly spiced, and irresistibly rich, this cake is perfect for the season.
Rocher Cake
GF options$62.70An indulgent dream: dark chocolate cake layered with toasted hazelnut buttercream, enrobed in chocolate buttercream, and finished with a dramatic dark chocolate ganache drip. Pure luxury for chocolate lovers.
Vegan Cake
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$70.10Choose your perfect plant-based combination: moist vanilla, rich chocolate, or classic red velvet cake paired with silky vanilla or chocolate buttercream. Entirely vegan, completely delicious.
Quote
Seasonal Bar Box$19.40Try our Favorite Seasonal Bar Flavors. Select your box size and we will have it ready for pick up at the bakery!
Bar Box$4.85Order a box of our freshly baked bars now. Choose from the core flavors and we will have the box ready for pick up at the bakery!
Brookie$4.85
Brownie$4.85
Chocolate Covered Oreos$40.80Pre-order (min 2 days notice)
Gluten Free / Vegan Peanut Butter Bar$4.85
Lemon Bar$4.85
Sour Cherry Almond Bar$4.85
Strawberry Linzer$4.85
Vegan Brownie Bar$4.85
Whoopie Pies$5.70Pre-order (min 2 days notice)
Cookie Box$4.35Order a box of our freshly baked cookies now. Choose from the core flavors and we will have the box ready for pick up at the bakery!
Chocolate Chunk Cookie$4.35
Sprinkle Cookie$4.35
Chocolate Almond Oat Cookie$4.35
Gluten Free / Vegan Chocolate Chunk Cookie$4.35
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie$4.35
Salted Nutella Cookie (Copy)$4.35
Cupcake Box$4.35Choose your flavor or get an assorted box of our daily cupcakes.
Vegan Cupcake Box
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$50.20Choose your flavor or get an assorted box of cupcakes in three different flavors - Vanilla with Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate with Chocolate Buttercream, Red Velvet with Vegan VanillaButtercream
Red Velvet Cupcake$4.35Red Velvet with Cream Cheese Frosting
Apple Crumble Cupcake$4.35A delectable apple crumble cupcake filled with apple pie filling, perfect for the fall season.
DIY Cupcakes
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$49.206 vanilla cupcakes, 6 chocolate cupcakes, one vanilla bag and one chocolate bag, 3 assorted sprinkles.
Gluten Free Cupcake Box
Rainbow Candles$4.50
Gold Candles$4.50
Happy Birthday Cake Topper$7.50
Number Candle$4.50
Rose Gold Candles$4.50
French Macarons$3.66Our classic French macarons showcase delicate almond meringue shells in six signature flavors: rich Madagascar vanilla bean, decadent dark chocolate, bright raspberry, toasted pistachio, aromatic coffee, and indulgent tiramisu. Each flavor is filled with silky buttercream or ganache.
Mini Cupcake Box
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$36.00Choose your flavor or get an assorted box of our mini cupcakes, perfect for any celebration or party.
Mini Bar Box
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$43.89Order a box of our mini bars now. Our favorite flavors and we will have the box ready for pick up at the bakery!
The Little Celebration Box
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$50.00Our Little Celebration Box is an assortment of classic mini treats.6 mini cookies, 6 mini cupcakes, and 6 mini bar pieces!Perfect for gatherings and celebrations, plus it comes with a free pack of candles!
Deluxe Sweet Treats Platter
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$132.77Delight in our holiday platter featuring our most beloved treats: fresh-baked cookies, decadent cupcakes, festive cake pops, and delicate French macarons.
The Party Starter
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$79.00Best for: Small gatherings, school events, casual hostingIncludes• 12 assorted cupcakes• 12 assorted cookiesServes: 10–12 people
The Sweet Sampler
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$45.00Delight in our sweet sampler, featuring our most beloved treats.Best for: First-time customers, indecisive buyersIncludes• 4 cupcakes• 4 cookies• 4 bars or browniesServes: 4–6 people
Gluten Free Tasting Kit$33.50Pre-order (min 2 days notice)
Tasting Kit$33.50Pre-order (min 2 days notice)
Pre-order (min 2 days notice)$33.50
Buttermilk Original Buttermilk Pie$5.50A rich custard filling topped with crunchy raw brown sugar and sea salt. Like a crème brûlée in pie form.
Salted Nutella Pecan Pie$5.75A Buttermilk twist on our classic pecan pie. Our signature gooey pecan filling swirled with rich Nutella throughout, finished with a salted Nutella drizzle and a sprinkle of sea salt for the perfect balance of sweet and savory.