Sammy's Fishbox

41 City Island Avenue, Bronx, NY

Menu (As of 10/30)

Sammys Red Wines (Must be 21 to Purchase)

• Robert Mondavi Private Selection Cabernet Sauvignon California $45.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Robert Mondavi Private Selection Merlot California $45.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Kendal Jackson Vintner’s Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon California $45.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Jacob’s Creek Shiraz Australian $36.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Ruffino Chianti Classico Italy $52.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Louis Jadot Beaujolais Village France $45.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Brancotti Pinot Noir New Zealand $45.00Must be 21 to purchase.

White and Blush Wines (Must be 21 to Purchase)

• Hess Select Chardonnay Napa, California Kendall, Jackson $45.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Vitner’s Reserve Chardonnay Sonoma, California $42.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Santa Margherita Pinot Grigio Italy $56.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Fontana Candida Pinot Grigio Italy $37.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Louis Jadot Pouilly Fuisse France $48.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Louis Jadot Chardonnay France $48.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Chateau St. Michelle Riesling Washington $42.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Beringer White Zinfandel Napa California $42.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Brancotti Sauvignon Blanc $45.00Must be 21 to purchase.

Import House Beer (Must be 21 to Purchase)

• Corona Extra Mexico Imported $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Corona Light Mexico Imported $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Heineken Holland Imported $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Modelo Especial Mexico Imported $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Stella Artois Imported $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Blue Moon Imported $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Guinness Extra Irish Stout Imported $8.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Red Stripe Jamaica Imported $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.

Premier House Beer (Must be 21 to Purchase)

• Corona Extra Mexico Premier $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Corona Light Mexico Premier $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Heineken Holland Premier $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Modelo Especial Mexico Premier $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Stella Artois Premier $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Blue Moon Premier $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Guinness Extra Irish Stout Premier $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Red Stripe Jamaica Premier $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.

Domestic House Beer (Must be 21 to Purchase)

• Budweiser $7.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Bud Light $7.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Coor’s Light $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Samuel Adams $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Odouls $7.00Must be 21 to purchase.
• Michelob Ultra Light $9.00Must be 21 to purchase.

Sea Treasures

• Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $19.954 pieces. Shell fish.
• Chiller Platter $28.95Shrimp cocktail, clams, and oysters.
• Littleneck ClamsMollusc.
• Cherrystone ClamsMollusc. Raw Clams
• Bluepoint Oysters $3.75Freshly shucked.
• Clams Casino $28.958 pieces. Clam in a halfshell that has been covered in bacon and a variety of toppings
• Littleneck Clams $28.95Cooked in red or garlic sauce.
• Baked Clams $19.958 Pieces
• Fresh Sweet Mussels $23.95With garlic, red sauce or tangy red sauce.
• Calamari Salad $19.95Cold.
• Tender Calamari $24.95Cooked in butter, garlic or tangy red sauce.
• Crispy Fried Calamari $23.95Served with red sauce or tartar sauce.
• Soft Shell Steamers $34.95Ipswich.
• Oysters Rockefeller $26.956 pieces. Our delicious version topped with creamed spinach, and mozzarella.
• Wood Roasted Oysters $21.956 pieces. Mollusk.
• Hot Antipasto $38.95Served for 2. Calamari, shrimp, king crab legs, baked clams, and mussels.
• Coconut Shrimp $26.95Golden, sweet, and crisp.
• Bang Bang Shrimp $24.95Crispy shrimp tossed in our creamy spicy sauce.
• Piri Piri Shrimp $36.95A spicy flavored seafood dish pan seared shrimp in a blend of garlic, lime, and habanero peppers.
• Fried Clam Strips $27.95Mollusc.
• Spicy Buffalo Wings $19.95Cooked wing of a chicken coated in sauce or seasoning.
• Buffalo Shrimp $19.95Shell fish.
• Buffalo Wings and Shrimp $24.95Spicy. Shell fish.
• Mozzarella Sticks $14.95Fried breaded mozzarella sticks with marinara sauce.
• Mussels in Red or Garlic Sauce $22.95Mussels cooked in a red or garlic sauce.
• Buffalo Wings $19.95Fried chicken wings sections.
• Maryland Lump Crabcake $26.95Quantity 1 piece
• Half Rack of Baby Back Pork Ribs $15.95
• Baked Clams.....1/2 Doz $14.95
• Baked Clams.....1 Doz $24.95
• Pot of Mussels- Red or Garlic $29.95

Sammy’s Chowders

• Manhattan Clams Chowder $9.95A thick, rich soup.
• New England Clam Chowder $9.95A thick creamy soup.
• French Onion Soup $9.95Soup that is made with stock, onions, and covered with either cheese, bread, or croutons.
• Lobster Bisque $9.95

Sammy's Fried Specials

• Our Famous Jumbo Fried Shrimp Special $29.95Shell fish.
• Fried Baby South African Lobster Tails Special $45.95Sherll fish.
• Fried Day Boat Sea Scallops $46.95Fried sea scallops.
• Southern Style Fried Chicken $28.95
• Super Fried Seafood Combo Platter $53.95Shrimp, Fillet of Fish, Scallops & Calamari
• Fried Whole Porgies $34.95
• Fried Whiting $33.95
• Fried Blue Fish $32.95
• Fried Tilapia $34.95
• Whole Fried Branzino $44.95
• Fried Calamari Platter $27.95
• Fresh Fried Fillet of Sole $42.95
• Chicken Finger Platter $27.95
• Fried Shrimp & Clam Strips Combo Platter $42.95

Jumbo Shrimp Combinations

• Jumbo Shrimp and Fried Baby Tails 2 Pieces Combo $59.95Shellfish and baby tails cooked in oil.
• Jumbo Shrimp and Fillet of Sole Combo $52.95Shellfish and mild slightly sweet fish.
• Jumbo Shrimp and Porgy Combo $45.95Shellfish.
• Jumbo Shrimp and Whiting Combo $44.95Shellfish and firm flaky fish.
• Jumbo Shrimp and Tilapia Combo $42.95Shellfish and mild flavored fish.
• Jumbo Shrimp and Whole Striped Bass Combo $69.95Shellfish and mild flavor fish.
• Jumbo Shrimp and Whole Branzino Combo $54.95Shellfish and European sea bass.
• Jumbo Shrimp and Whole Red Snapper Combo $74.95Shellfish and mild tasting red fish.
• Jumbo Shrimp and Sword Fish Combo $56.95Shellfish.
• Jumbo Shrimp and Artic Salmon Combo $48.95Shellfish and rich and oily fish.
• Jumbo Shrimp and BBQ Chicken Combo $38.95Shellfish and broiled, roasted, or grilled poultry.

Sammy’s Chef Specials

• Jumbo Shrimp Scampi $36.95Shellfish.
• Jumbo Stuffed Shrimp with Crabmeat $65.95Shellfish.
• Shrimp Scampi Caribbean $38.95Coconut, curry sauce.
• Shrimp Florentine $39.95Cream, white wine, butter, garlic, Parmesan, mozzarella, and fresh spinach.
• Delicious Sea Scallops a la Scampi $47.95Cooked and seasoned mollusk.
• Shrimp and Scallops Combo a la Scampi $49.95Shellfish and cooked and seasoned mollusk.
• Baked Fillet of Sole $42.95Mild slightly sweet fish.
• Baked Fillet of Sole Florentine $47.95Stuffed with spinach and mozzarella cheese.
• Fillet of Sole Stuffed with Crabmeat $64.95Mild slightly sweet fish.
• Fillet of Sole Stuffed with Jumbo Shrimp $66.95Mild slightly sweet fish.
• Baked Ocean Blue Fish $32.95Cooked in an oven.
• Alaskan Salmon Fillet $39.95Rich and oily fish.
• North Atlantic Cod Fillet $39.95Mild flavored fish.
• Sammy’s Famous Baked Whole Red Snapper $54.95Head on.
• Line Caught Swordfish $49.95
• New England Whole Striped Bass $39.95
• Wild Sweet Tasting Tilapia $37.95Mild flavored fish.
• Fresh Halibut Steak with Lemon Butter Sauce $46.95
• Fresh Halibut Steak with Mustard Sauce $46.95
• Farm Raised Catfish $37.95Mild, slightly sweet fish.
• Seafood Skewer $54.951/2- lobster tail, sea scallops, shrimp, king crab, sword fish, fillet of sole over Cajun rice.
• Maryland Lump Crab Cake Dinner $44.95Fish cake made from crab. 2 large crab cakes. Add rab cake for an additional charge.
• Traditional New England Lobster Hot Roll $47.95Served with coleslaw, french fries, and pickle.
• Traditional New England Lobster Cold Roll $42.95Served with coleslaw, french fries, and pickle.
• Twin Lobster Tail Platter $59.95Saltwater fish.
• Stuffed Twin Lobster Tail Platter $82.95Saltwater fish.
• Jumbo Snow Crab Legs
• Broiled Tilapia $37.95

Pacific Northwest Wood Roasted Fish

• Roasted Red Snapper $50.95Mild tasting red fish.
• Roasted Swordfish $49.95
• Roasted Halibut $47.95
• Roasted Salmon $49.95Rich and oily fish.
• Roasted Whole Striped Bass $41.95White fish with mild delicate flavor.
• Roasted Whole Mediterranean Branzino $44.95European sea bass.

Italian Specialties

• Jumbo Shrimp in Garlic Sauce Special $38.95Over spaghetti or angel hair pasta.
• Jumbo Shrimp in Red Sauce Special $38.95Over spaghetti or angel hair pasta.
• Shrimp and Scallops Special $42.95Over spaghetti or angel hair pasta.
• Shrimp, Scallops, and Baby Lobster Tails Special $57.95Prepared in red, garlic, or sauce over spaghetti or angel hair pasta.
• Shrimp Francese Special $37.95Over spaghetti or angel hair pasta.
• Baby Lobster Tails Special $49.95Prepared in red, garlic, or sauce over spaghetti or angel hair pasta.
• Pasta del Mar Special $64.95Whole lobster, clams, and mussels over spaghetti or angel hair past.
• Jumbo Shrimp Parmigiana with Side of Pasta Special $38.95Shellfish.
• Chicken Parmigiana with Side of Pasta Special $32.95Breaded chicken, tomato sauce, and cheese.
• Chicken and Shrimp Parmigiana Combo Special $38.95Covered in tomato sauce and cheese.
• Eggplant Parmigiana with Side of Pasta Special $31.95Eggplant topped with cheese and tomato sauce.
• Linguine with Sauce Special $31.95Red or white clam sauce.
• Large Pot of P.E.I. Succulent Rope Mussels Special $29.95Cooked in a garlic white wine or marinara sauce.

Sammy’s Broiled Combination

• Sammy’s Broiled Combination $54.95

Our Fabulous Feasts

• Italian Feast $259.95A Whole Maine Lobster, Shrimp, Clams, Mussels, Snow Crab Legs and Scallops all served on a bed of fresh pasta in red or garlic sauce. **Add King Crab Leg 1 lb. 50.00 more
• Paella de España $269.95This authentic Spanish Dish is loaded with Jumbo Shrimp, Sea Scallops, Clams, Mussels, Maine Lobster, Snow Legs, Chicken all sauteed and mixed with Spanish yellow rice. *Chorizo (Pork Sausage), only added on request. **Add King Crab Leg 1 lb. 50.00 more
• The Crab and Lobster Feast $259.95A whole 1 and 1/4 lb. Maine lobster with king crab legs, snow crab legs, crab catch of the day and jumbo fried shrimp all served over a bed of yellow rice.
• Seafood and BBQ FeastJumbo king crab legs, snow crab legs, fried shrimp, a full rack of ribs, and 1/2 a BBQ chicken, all served over a bed of yellow rice.
• Snow Crab & Lobster Feast $209.954 Giant Snow Crab Clusters, 1-1/4 lb. whole Maine Lobster, with 4 large fried Shrimp over a bed of yellow rice.
• Lobster Lovers Feasts $209.952-1 1/2lb. Maine Lobsters, and 2 clusters of Snow Crab Legs and 6 Jumbo Fried Shrimp over a bed of yellow rice

Sammy’s Seafood on Ice

• Chilled Shellfish Sampler $68.95A whole 1 and 1/4 lb. Maine lobster, 4-raw cherrystone clams, 4 raw littleneck clams, 2 raw oysters, and 4 chilled jumbo shrimp.
• Cold Shrimp Platter $38.958 jumbo shellfish.
• Clam Bake Special $45.95succulent platter consisting of whole 1-1/2lb. Maine lobster, *ipswich steamers, baked potato, corn on the cob and piping hot drawn butter * Based on availability or substitute w/littleneck steamers

Sammy’s Famous Montauk Chiller Seafood Tower

• Seafood Chiller $108.95

Shell Fish Extraveganza

• Shell Fish Extraveganza $108.95

Lobster Special

• Twin 1 and 1/4 lb. Lobsters Special $64.952 Whole

Sammy's Trio’s

• Snow Crab Legs, Lobster Tail, and Shrimp $112.95
• Lobster Tail, Steak, and Fried Shrimp $92.95

Surf and Turf at Sammy’s

• Lobster Tail and Fried Shrimp $55.95Shellfish.
• Lobster Tail and Baby Back Ribs $59.95A cut of meat taken from the top of the rib cage.
• Lobster Tail and New York Shell Steak $65.95Boneless strip steak.
• Lobster Tail and Filet Mignon $69.95Tenderloin.
• Fried Shrimp and Filet Mignon $68.95Shellfish and tenderloin.
• Fried Shrimp and NY Shell Steak $63.95Boneless strip steak.
• Fried Shrimp and 20 oz. Chicago Rib-Eye Steak $76.95Shellfish.
• Whole Red Snapper and Fried Shrimp $64.95Mild tasting red fish and shellfish cooked in oil.
• Whole Red Snapper and Lobster Tail $78.95Mild tasting red fish.
• Whole Red Snapper and NY Shell Steak $85.95Mild tasting red fish.
• Snow Crab Legs and Baby Back Rib $76.95A cut of meat is taken from the top of the rib cage.
• Snow Crab Legs and Fried Shrimp $86.95Shellfish.
• Snow Crab Legs and Shrimp Scampi $86.95Shellfish.
• Snow Crab Legs and Lobster Tail $82.95
• Chicago Rib-Eye and Shrimp $76.9520 oz. steak and 5 pieces of shrimp.
• Snow Crab Legs and NY Shell Steak $99.95Boneless strip steak.
• Snow Crab Legs and Filet Mignon $112.95Tenderloin.
• Baby Back Ribs - Pork and Fried Shrimp $45.95Shellfish.
• Chicken Surf and Turf $82.95Served with your choice of BBQ ribs or chicken with shell steak, and jumbo fried shrimp.
• New York Steak & Fried Shrimp $59.95
• Jumbo Fried Shrimp & Filet Mignon $49.95

Steak Lovers

• Our Famous Baby Back Pork Ribs $38.95A cut of meat taken from the top of the rib cage.
• Baby Back Ribs and BBQ Chicken Combo $37.95A cut of meat taken from the top of the rib cage.
• Tangy BBQ Chicken Dinner $29.95Poultry.
• Chicago Style Bone-In Rib Eye Steak 20 oz. $66.95An outstanding example of USDA prime. Well-marbled for peak flavor.
• 16 oz. Prime Shell Steak $48.95
• Filet Mignon 10 oz. $54.95Tenderloin.
• King Cut Prime Rib $48.95
• Sammy's Famous Sirloin Burger $21.95This is a really good burger!

Piri Piri Special Dinner

• Jumbo Shrimp Piri Piri Special Dinner $36.95Shellfish.
• Scallops Piri Piri Special Dinner $46.95Cooked and seasoned mollusk.
• Swordfish Piri Piri Special Dinner $46.95
• Halibut Piri Piri Special Dinner $46.95Flatfish.
• Whole Red Snapper Special Dinner $54.95Mild tasting red fish.

Our Chef's Special Saute'

• Sole Meuniere $42.95Mild slightly sweet fish.
• Shrimp Francese $36.95Shellfish.
• Chicken Francese $34.95Poultry.
• Mixed Seafood Saute $39.95
• Tender Scallops Saute $44.95Cooked and seasoned mollusk

Children’s

• Kid's Fried Shrimp $16.95Shellfish cooked in oil.
• Kid's Pasta with Marinara Sauce $9.95
• Kid's Hamburger Platter $13.95
• Kid's Basket of Chicken Fingers $13.95Breaded or battered crispy chicken.
• Kid's Rack of Baby Back Pork Ribs $14.95
• Kid's Hot Dogs $12.95sausage served on a bun
• Kid's Macaroni and Cheese $10.95Macaroni pasta in a cheese sauce.
• Kid's English Fish and Chips $14.95

Cajun Magic

• Shrimp Louisiana $36.95Shellfish.
• Blackened Swordfish $46.95
• Blackened Halibut $46.95Flatfish.
• Cajun Raised Catfish $37.95Mild, slightly sweet fish.
• Blackened Salmon $42.95Rich and oily fish.
• Blackened Tilapia $38.95Mild flavored fish.

Sammy's Special Dessert

• Expresso Gelato Truffle Special $9.95Made with espresso beans enrobed in dark chocolate.
• Amaretto Nut Gelato Truffle Special $9.95Rolled in almonds and chocolate chips.
• Dulce de Leche Gelato Truffle Special $9.95With caramel enrobed in milk chocolate.
• Tiramisu Gelato Truffle Special $9.95With marscapone gelato center.
• Cappuccino Gelato Truffle Special $9.95With chocolate chips enrobed in dark chocolate.
• Manhattan Truffle Special $9.95Vanilla and chocolate ice cream with cherry, and almonds center enrobed in dark chocolate.
• Mile-High Chocolate Fudge Cake Special $9.95If you like chocolate then this dessert has your name on it! Outrageous.
• Special Cheesecake $9.95A rich creamy cheese cake on a graham cracker crust bottom served with caramel decor.
• Red Velvet Cake $9.95Moist and delicious velvity cake with a white cream cheese frosting.
• Mile-High 24-Carrot Cake Special $9.95Super delicious layered carrot cake with the most creamy filling you will ever taste!
• Orange Sorbets Special $9.95Hollowed out shells filled with imported non-dairy orange sorbet.
• Lemon Sorbets Special $9.95Hollowed out shells filled with imported non-dairy lemon sorbet.
• Soft Ice Cream Cone $3.95
• Soft Ice Cream Dish $3.95
• Espresso Gelato $9.95made with espresso beans enrobed in dark chocolate

Chowders Soups and Bisque

• Manhattan Clam Chowder $9.95Homemade Tomato based red clam chowder.

Sides

• Italian Bread $6.00
• Sammy's Cheese $1.00
• Corn Bread $3.00
• Side Salad $5.00
• Pasta $5.00
• Baked Potato $5.00
• Yellow Rice $3.00
• French Fries $5.00
• Corn on the Cob $5.00
• Shrimp Stuffing $24.95
• Crab Stuffing $24.95
• Crab/Shrimp Stuffing $24.95Both crab & shrimp stuffing
• ONE Cluster Snowcrab Leg $39.95One cluster of Snowcrab (no side)

Fresh Fruit Smoothies

• Fresh Fruit Smoothie $8.00w/IceCream Non-Alcoholic Beverage

Sammy's Special Tropical Bar and Martini's (Must be 21 to Purchase)

• Limon Cosmo $19.95Must be 21 to purchase. Vodka, triple sec, lime juice, and cranberry juice.
• I Can-Elope Martini $19.95Must be 21 to purchase. Vodka, watermelon, splash of triple sec, lime juice, and pineapple juice.
• Apple Martini $19.95Must be 21 to purchase. Vodka, sour apple schnapps, and triple sec.
• Fuzzy Peach Martini $19.95Must be 21 to purchase. Vodka, peach schnapps, and triple sec with splash of cranberry.
• Watermelon Martini $19.95Must be 21 to purchase. Vodka, watermelon schnapps with a splash of triple sec.

Holiday Menus - Fried Specialties

• Jumbo Fried Shrimp $36.95

Holiday Menu - Prime Cuts of Beef

• Ribs & Chicken $36.95
• Baby Back Ribs $38.95

Holiday Menus - Surf & Turf at Sammy’s

• Baby Back Ribs & Fried Shrimp $44.95
• Baby Back Ribs & Lobster Tail $59.95
• Baby Back Ribs & Snow Crab Legs $76.95
• Salmon & Lobster Tail $54.95
• Snow Crab Legs, Lobster Tail & Shrimp $109.95

Coladas

• Hennessy Colada $23.95
• Dusse Coloda $21.95
• Pina Colada (Rum) $19.95
• Virgin Colada (Non-alcoholic) $8.00

Sauces

• Tarter Sauce $0.75Regular side of Tarter Sauce
• Large cup of Tarter Sauce $7.00
• Cocktail Sauce $1.00

KIDS Menu

• Jumbo Fried Shrimp $16.95
• Bowl of Pasta w/ Marinara Sauce $9.95
• Hamburger Platter (with cheese) $13.95
• Chicken Fingers $13.95
• 1/2 Rack of Ribs $14.95
• Sammy's Fish & Chips $34.95
• Hot Dogs (2) $12.95

Sammy's King Crab & Lobster Feast

• Sammy's King Crab & Lobster Feast $259.951 lb. King Crab Legs & Giant Snow Crab Clusters, 1 1/4 lb. Lobster & 4 Jumbo Fried Shrimp all served over a bed of Yellow Rice

Sammy's Specialty Drinks & Martini's​

• Hennessy VSOP Colada $21.95
• Frankenstein Monster $20.95
• The Ultimate Margarita $19.95
• Hennessey Colada $23.95
• City Island Iced Tea $20.95
• Limon Cosmo $18.95
• Creamy Piña Colada $19.95
• Frozen Daquiri's $19.95Banana or Strawberry
• Trouble In Paradise $19.95
• Bahama Breeze $19.95
• Tropical Punch $19.95
• Sex on the Beach $19.95
• Frozen Mudslide $19.95
• Frozen Margaritas $19.95
• Lemon Drop Martini $19.95
• Sour Apple Martini $18.95
• Espresso Martini $18.95
• Pear Martini $19.95
• Strawberry Daiquiri $19.95
• Gilly's Aperol Spritz $18.95

Homemade Sangria

• white or red by the glass $15.95
• By the Pitcher $29.95

Sammy's Fishbox: hours and how to order