The Fish Store

836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

Appetizers

• Clams on the Half Shell 8.99 | 17.99
• Oysters on the Half Shell 11.99 | 23.99
• Calamari $15.99
• Baked Clams $12.99
• Maryland Crab Cakes $15.99
• Oysters Rockefeller $15.99
• Shrimp Cocktail $13.99
• Coconut Shrimp $15.99
• Bacon Wrapped Sea Scallops $14.99
• Shrimp Quesadilla $16.99
• Clam Strips $10.99
• Clams Casino $14.99
• Stuffed Crabs $12.99
• Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms $12.99
• Buffalo Shrimp $15.99
• Prince Edward Island Mussels $14.99
• L.I. South Shore Clams $16.99
• L.I. North Shore Steamers $17.99
• Mozzarella Sticks $10.99
• Zucchini Sticks $10.99
• Loaded Potato with Shrimp $11.99
• Seafood Chili $14.99
• Cheese Nachos $11.99

Add Description

• Shrimp Nachos $15.99
• Seafood Chili Nachos $18.99
• Buffalo Wings $14.99

Samplers & Combos

• Cold Seafood Sampler $23.99
• TFS Fried Combo Platter $23.99
• Hot Seafood Sampler $23.99
• The Blue Point Combo $16.99

Salads

• Caprese Salad $16.99
• TFS Salad $16.99
• Caesar Salad $15.99
• Garden Salad $12.99
• Caprese Salad 16.99 / 17.67
• TFS Salad 16.99 / 17.67
• Caesar Salad 15.99 / 16.63
• Garden Salad 12.99 / 13.51

Soups

• Soup du Jour $9.99
• Manhattan Clam Chowder $9.99
• New England Clam Chowder $9.99
• Seafood Bisque $9.99
• Lobster Bisque $9.99
• Prices show cash / credit card 8.99 /9.35 1 Doz. - 17.99 / 18.71Clams on the Half Shell ........................................................................½ Doz.
• Oysters on the Half Shell .....................................................................½ Doz 11.99 / 12.47 1 Doz. - 23.99 / 24.95
• Freshly shucked local oysters served with cocktail sauce and lemon Calamari 15.99 / 16.63
• Baked Clams 12.99 / 13.51
• Long Island chopped clams and bread crumb seasoning, served with lemon 15.99 / 16.63Maryland Crab Cakes................................................................................
• Sautéed in a scallion sherry wine sauce overflowing with crabmeat 15.99 / 16.63Oysters Rockefeller.......................................................................................
• Shrimp Cocktail 13.99 / 14.55
• Coconut Shrimp 15.99 / 16.63
• Bacon Wrapped Sea Scallops 14.99 / 15.59
• Shrimp Quesadilla 16.99 / 17.67
• Stuffed with shrimp, tomato, cheddar and mozzarella cheese. Served with salsa and sour cream Clam Strips 10.99 / 11.43
• Delicious breaded clam strips, deep fried and served with homemade tartar sauce 14.99 / 15.59Clams Casino...................................................................................................
• Stuffed Crabs 12.99 / 13.51
• Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms 12.99 / 13.51
• Buffalo Shrimp 15.99 / 16.63
• Prince Edward Island Mussels 14.99 / 15.59
• L.I. South Shore Clams 16.99 / 17.67
• L.I. North Shore Steamers 17.99 / 18.71
• Mozzarella Sticks 10.99 / 11.43
• Zucchini Sticks 10.99 / 11.43
• Loaded Potato with Shrimp 11.99 / 12.47
• Seafood Chili 14.99 / 15.59
• Cheese Nachos 11.99 / 12.47
• Shrimp Nachos 15.99 / 16.63
• Seafood Chili Nachos 18.99 / 19.75
• Buffalo Wings 14.99 / 15.59
• Cold Seafood Sampler 29.99 / 31.19
• TFS Fried Combo Platter 23.99 / 24.95
• Hot Seafood Sampler 23.99 / 24.95
• The Blue Point Combo 16.99 / 17.67

Homemade Soups

• Soup Du Jour “Ask your Server” 9.99 / 10.39
• Something new and tasty every day 9.99 / 10.39Manhattan Clam Chowder .................................................................
• Classic tomato and vegetable bursting with flavor 9.99 / 10.39New England Clam Chowder ...........................................................
• Seafood Bisque 9.99 / 10.39
• Lobster Bisque 9.99 / 10.39

Fish Store Favorites

• Poached Salmon 26.99 / 28.07
• Flounder Francese 27.99 / 29.11
• Hand-cut Montauk flounder, pan-seared and finished in a francese sauce served over rice. Mango Peach Swordfish or Salmon 27.99 / 29.11
• Scampi Encrusted Sea Scallops 30.99 / 32.23
• Peppercorn or Sesame Crusted Tuna 28.99 / 30.15
• Coconut Shrimp 27.99 / 29.11
• Maryland Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes 25.99 / 27.03
• Lobster Marinara 38.99 / 40.55
• Cedar Plank Salmon 27.99 / 29.11
• Fish Tacos 26.99 / 28.07
• Lobster Roll Dinner 26.99 / 28.03
• Caprese Tilapia 25.99 / 27.03
• Lobster Mac & Cheese 29.99 / 31.19
• Shrimp Carbanaro 26.99 / 28.07
• Chilean Sea Bass 30.99 / 32.23

Land Lovers Menu

• 10oz Flat Iron Steak 29.99 / 31.19
• Chicken Portafino 24.99 / 25.99
• Grilled Chicken and Broccoli 22.99 / 23.91
• Chicken Parmigiana 23.99 / 24.95
• Linguine with Meatballs 23.99 / 24.95

Sandwiches

• L.I. Flounder Sandwich 17.99 / 18.71
• Hand cut and breaded flounder, fried and served on a roll w/ lettuce, tomato and onion. Maryland Crab Cake Sandwich 17.99 / 18.71
• Old Bay Crab Cake Sandwich 14.99 / 15.59
• Maryland Soft Shell Crab 19.99 / 20.79
• The Riley Burger 18.99 / 19.75
• Chicken Sandwich 15.99 / 16.63
• Meatball or Chicken Parm Hoagie 16.99 / 17.67
• Flounder Fillet $12.99/13.51
• Crab Cake (Old Bay) $11.99/12.47
• Crab Cake (Maryland) $13.99/14.55
• Seafood Salad $11.99/12.47
• Crawfish Salad $12.99/13.51
• Fried Shrimp $13.99/14.55
• Tuna Salad $12.99/13.51
• Broiled Cajun Catfish $13.99/14.55
• Fried Chicken $10.99/11.43
• Grilled Hamburger w/Cheese $10.99/11.43
• Grilled Hot Dogs (2) $9.99/10.39
• Shrimp Salad $13.99/14.55
• Lobster Roll single - $24.99/25.99
• Meal $28.99/30.15

Lobster and Crab Legs

• 1½ pound Lobster Dinner 46.99 / 48.87
• 2 pound Lobster Dinner 58.99 / 61.35Fill your lobster with our homemade seafood stuffing for an
• 6oz 35.99 / 37.43 Twin.....49.99 / 51.99
• 8oz 40.99 / 42.63 Twin.....64.99 / 67.59
• 10-12oz 48.99 / 50.95 Twin.....73.99 / 76.95
• 16-20oz 76.99 / 80.07 Twin.....135.99 / 141.43
• King Crab Leg Dinner 77.99 / 81.11
• Snow Crab Leg Dinner 39.99 / 41.59
• Surf & Turf 40.99 / 42.63
• Lobster Bake 48.99 / 50.95
• Captain Seth's Amazing Barge 135.00 / 140.40
• 1 Includes a $1.25

Seafood Pasta Dishes

• Gluten free pasta $2.00 / $2.08 extra per order
• Red or White Clam Sauce 24.99 / 25.99
• Mussels 24.99 / 25.99
• Prince Edward Island mussels cooked in a garlic wine or marinara sauce, served over linguine. Shrimp or Flounder Parmigi 27.99 / 29.11
• Linguine Shrimp Scampi 25.99 / 27.03
• Shellfish Marinara 29.99 / 27.03
• Shrimp and Scallops in Pink 26.99 / 28.07
• Crispy Calamari Delight 25.99 / 27.03

Fried Dinners

• Fish and Chips 19.99 / 20.79
• Clam Strips 16.99 / 17.67
• Calamari 19.99 / 20.79
• Fish Cakes 14.99 / 15.59
• Crab Cakes 16.99 / 20.79
• Oysters 22.99 / 23.91
• Boneless White Meat Chicken 14.99 / 15.59
• Buffalo Shrimp 19.99 / 20.79
• Soft Shell Crab or Sauteed 24.99 / 25.99
• Flounder Fillet 19.99 . 20.79
• Stuffed Flounder with Seafood Stuffing 22.99 / 23.91
• Stuffed Flounder with Spinach and Feta Stuffing 22.99 / 23.91
• Haddock 17.99 / 18.71
• Bay Scallops 18.99 / 19.75
• Sea Scallops 24.99 / 25.99
• Shrimp 19.99 / 20.79
• Catfish 18.99 / 19.75
• Cajun Catfish 18.99 / 19.75
• “Hat Trick” 23.99 / 24.95

Shrimp, Bay Scallops, & Flounder

• “Shellfish Medley” 23.99 /24.95

Shrimp, Clam Strips, Bay Scallops

• “Fisherman’s Platter” 24.99 / 25.99

Broiled or Grilled Dinners

• Flounder Fillet (Broiled Only) 22.99 / 23.91
• Stuffed Flounder with Seafood Stuffing 24.99 / 25.99Broiled Only
• Stuffed Flounder with Spinach and Feta Stuffing 24.99 / 25.99Broiled Only
• Codfish 21.99 / 22.87
• Bay Scallops (Broiled Only) 21.99 / 22.87
• Sea Scallops 26.99 / 28.07
• Shrimp 21.99 / 22.87
• Catfish 20.99 / 21.83
• Cajun Catfish 20.99 / 21.83
• Tuna 24.99 / 25.99
• Swordfish 24.99 / 25.99
• Salmon 23.99 / 24.95
• Wild Salmon 28.99 / 30.15
• Stuffed Shrimp (Broiled Only) 22.99 / 23.91
• Shrimp Scampi 22.99 / 23.99
• Mahi-Mahi 23.99 / 24.95
• Chilean Sea Bass 27.99 / 29.11
• Orange Roughy 23.99 / 24.95
• Tilapia 20.99 / 21.83
• “Hat Trick” 24.99 / 25.99

Sides

• Fries 4.99 / 5.19
• Curly Fries 4.99 / 5.19
• Sweet Potato Fries 5.99 / 6.23
• Baked Potato 3.99 / 4.15
• Mashed Potatoes 4.99 / 5.19
• Onion Rings 5.99 / 6.23
• Yellow Rice 3.99 / 4.15
• Creamed Spinach & Feta 6.99 / 7.27
• Corn on the Cob (Seasonal) 3.99 / 4.15
• Fresh vegetable of the day 6.99 / 7.27
• Linguine with marinara sauce 6.99 / 7.27
• Coleslaw 2.99 / 3.11
• Garlic Bread 3.99 / 4.15
• Garden Salad 5.99 / 6.23
• Broccoli 6.99 / 7.27
• Onion Straws 5.99 / 6.23
• Meatballs Marinara 6.99 / 7.27
• Kids Menu $11.99 / $12.47

Fountain Soda

• Root Beer Float $6.99 / $7.27

Red Wine

• Dessert $8.00 / $8.32

Seafood Sandwiches & Rolls

• Maryland Crab Cakes Sandwich $16.99
• PoBoy Crawfish Salad Sandwich $14.99
• Fish Store Flounder Reuben $15.99
• Low Fat Hawaiian Tuna Sandwich $15.99
• Fish & Chip $12.99

Seafood Wraps

• Danielle's Kickin' Shrimp Wrap $14.99
• Tex Mex Grouper Wrap $14.99
• Low Fat Salmon Wrap $14.99

Specialty Sandwiches & Heros

• Big Mama's Italian Shrimp Parmigina $15.99

Big Bayport Steak Hero

• Big Bayport Steak Hero $17.99
• Barbeque Chicken Sandwich $13.99

Includes

• Maryland Crab Cakes Sandwich $16.99/17.67
• PoBoy Crawfish Salad Sandwich $14.99/15.59
• Fish Store Flounder Reuben $15.99/16.63
• Danielle’s Kickin’ Shrimp Wrap $14.99/15.59
• Big Mama’s Italian Shrimp Parmigiana $15.99/16.63
• Tex Mex Grouper Wrap $14.99/15.59
• Barbeque Chicken Sandwich $13.99/14.55
• Low Fat Salmon Wrap $14.99/15.59
• Big Bayport Steak Hero $17.99/18.71
• Low Fat Hawaiian Tuna Sandwich $15.99/16.63
• Fish & Chip $12.99/13.51

Sandwiches or Wraps

• Lettuce, tomato, and onion. Avocado or cheese $1.50
• Grilled Tuna $14.99/15.59
• Grilled Swordfish $14.99/15.59
• Grilled Salmon $14.99/15.59
• Grilled Shrimp $13.99/14.55
• Grilled Chicken $13.99/14.55
• Fried or Broiled Cajun Catfish $13.99/14.55
• Fried or Broiled Flounder Fillet $15.99/16.63
• Fried Codfish $13.99/14.55
• Fried Shrimp $13.99/14.55
• Fried Chicken $13.99/14.55
• Fried Old Bay Crab Cake $13.99/14.55
• Seafood Salad $13.99/14.55
• Crawfish Salad $14.99/15.59
• Tuna Salad $13.99/14.55

Garden Salads

• Caprese Salad $14.99/15.59
• TFS Salad $14.99/15.59
• Caesar Salad $13.99/14.55
• Garden Salad $11.99/12.47

Rolls

• Lobster Roll $22.99/23.91
• Crawfish Roll $13.99/14.55
• Seafood Salad Roll $12.99/13.51
• Blacking seasoning or choice of cheese Cheddar, feta or Mozzarella $1.50 extra

Garden Salad

• (Choice of Salad Dressing on the Side) $1.99 ExtraBlackened Seasoning or Choice of Cheese (Cheddar-Feta-Mozzarella-Parm)
• Fresh Tossed $9.99/10.39
• Grilled Tuna $14.99/15.59
• Grilled Swordfish $14.99/15.59
• Grilled Mako $14.99/15.59
• Grilled Salmon $14.99/15.59
• Grilled Shrimp $14.99/15.59
• Grilled Chicken $12.99/13.51

Wraps

• Grilled Tuna $12.99/13.51
• Grilled Swordfish $12.99/13.51
• Grilled Salmon $12.99/13.51
• Grilled Shrimp $12.99/13.51
• Grilled Chicken $11.99/12.47
• Tuna Salad $12.99/13.51
• Seafood Salad $11.99/12.47
• Crawfish Salad $12.99/13.51
• Shrimp Salad $13.99/14.55
• Crab Cake (Old Bay) $11.99/12.47
• Crab Cake (Maryland) $13.99/14.55

Fried Dinners Cash / credit

• Crab Cakes $11.99/12.47
• Fish Cakes $10.99/11.43
• Fish & Chips $13.99/14.55
• Flounder Filet $14.99/15.59
• Stuffed Flounder Filet $16.99/17.67
• Bay Scallops $13.99/14.55
• Sea Scallops $17.99/18.71
• Shrimp $14.99/15.59
• Oysters $15.99/16.63
• Clam Strips $11.99/12.47
• Squid $14.99/15.59
• Cod $14.99/15.59
• Haddock $12.99/13.51
• Catfish $12.99/13.51
• Cajun Catfish $13.99/14.55
• Chicken Fingers $12.99/13.51
• Buffalo Shrimp $15.99/16.63

Fried Combo Dinners

• Fisherman’s Platter $15.99/16.63

Clam Strips & Flounder

• Hat Trick $14.99/15.59

Shrimp, Bay Scallops, Flounder

• (Broiled $1.00 Extra)
• Shellfish Medley $14.99/15.59
• Bucket of Fish $18.99/19.75

Fish Cakes-Cajun Catfish-Buffalo Shrimp

• Bucket of Mussels $19.99/20.79
• Bucket of Steamers $31.99/33.27

Broiled / grilled Dinners

• Tuna $16.99/17.67
• Swordfish $16.99/17.67
• Salmon Filet $16.99/17.67
• Wild Salmon $17.99/18.71
• Flounder Filet-(broiled only) $15.99/16.63

Stuffed Salmon-(Broiled Only)

• w/Seafood or Spinach + Feta $17.99/18.71

Stuffed Flounder-(Broiled Only)

• w/Seafood or Spinach + Feta $17.99/18.71
• Bay Scallops--(broiled only) $14.99/15.59
• Sea Scallops $18.99/19.75
• Shrimp $14.99/15.59
• Stuffed Shrimp-(broiled only) $15.99/16.63
• Shrimp Scampi-(broiled only) $15.99/16.63

The Fish Store: hours and how to order