The Pizzeria of Bay Shore

11 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY

Menu (As of 10/29)

Regular

• traditional new york style $21.95

Bayport Pie

• (our margarita) $29.95fresh mozzarella | pizza sauce | parmesan | olive oil crust

• Vodka Margherita $29.95fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | parmesan | olive oil crust
• Uncle Benny $32.95fresh mozzarella | cup & char pepperoni | pizza sauce | crumbled sausage | Mike's Hot Honey | basil | olive oil crust
• Aunt Danielle $32.95vodka sauce | pepperoni | stracciatella cheese | fresh basil | Mike's Hot Honey
• Bar Pie $31.95pizza sauce | light mozzarella | burrata | Mike's Hot Honey | basil | olive oil crust
• Tri-Fecta $29.95fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | pizza sauce | pesto | olive oil crust
• Bruschetta $32.95balsamic-infused crust | fresh bruschetta | burrata cheese | basil | balsamic glaze
• Buffalo Chicken $32.95marinated chicken | mozzarella | buffalo sauce
• Chicken Bacon Ranch $32.95breaded chicken | crispy bacon | mozzarella | cheddar | ranch
• Grandma $24.95marinara | mozzarella | grandma style crust
• Sicilian $24.95pizza sauce | mozzarella | thick sicilian crust
• The Honey Pep $31.95cup & char pepperoni | Mike's Hot Honey | basil | sicilian crust
• Crumbling Vodka $30.95fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | spicy crumbled sausage | grandma style crust
• Thai Chili Chicken $31.95marinated chicken | mozzarella | thai chili sauce | grandma style crust
• Upside Down $27.95mozzarella | marinara | olive oil | sicilian crust
• White $29.95ricotta | marscapone | mozzarella | white truffle oil | grandma style crust
• Meatball Burrata $31.95homemade meatballs | tomato sauce | burrata | basil | parmesan cheese | grandma style crust
• The Pizzeria Chicken $25.95breaded chicken cutlet topped with arugula | cherry tomatoes | red onion | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze | basil
• Chicken Francese $25.95white wine lemon butter sauce
• House $13.95mixed field greens | cherry tomatoes | red onion | cucumbers | freshly made croutons | mozzarella
• The Salad $15.95mixed field greens | honey crisp apple sticks | cherry tomatoes | croutons | candied pecans | parmesan crisps | cheddar
• Caesar $14.95romaine | shaved parmesan cheese | parmesan crisps | freshly made croutons | homemade caesar dressing
• Primiano Chop $15.95soppressata | prosciutto | fresh mozzarella | onions | sliced cherry peppers | romaine | tomato | red wine vinaigrette
• Primiano Chop Hero $15.95soppressata | prosciutto | fresh mozzarella | onions | tomato | sliced cherry peppers | romaine | red wine vinaigrette |
• The Pizzeria Chicken Wrap $11.95arugula | roasted red peppers | breaded chicken | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze
• Penne Alla Vodka $21.95housemade vodka sauce | penne pasta
• The Mezzi Rig $21.95mezzi rigatoni | mozzarella | spicy vodka sauce
• Beggar's Purse $21.95cheese filled pasta puches | crumbled sausage | vodka sauce
• Broccoli Rabe & Sausage $21.95orecchiete | broccoli rabe | crumbled sausage | garlic & oil
• Pasta with Meatballs $21.95
• Baked Ziti $21.95

Salad Pie

• House or Caesar $24.95

Gluten-Free Personal Pie

• Gluten-Free & Dairy Free Crust $15.95

Parmigiana

• Chicken • Meatball • Eggplant • Shrimp $25.95with tomato or vodka sauce
• Chicken • Meatball • Shrimp • Eggplant $14.95tomato or vodka sauce | mozzarella | semolina bread

Chicken Roll

• Chicken Roll $11.95
• Pepperoni or Broccoli Pinwheel $4.95

Garlic Bread

• Fried Ravioli $11.95

Calzone

• Baked or Fried $12.95topped with garlic, parmesan and olive oil
• Meatballs $12.95
• Wings $15.95Buffalo • BBQ • Thai Chili • Dry Rub

The Hero

• Chicken • Meatball • Shrimp • Eggplant $16.95burrata cheese | tomato sauce | fresh basil | olive oil | parmesan | semolina bread

Prosciutto Sandwich

• prosciutto di parma | fresh mozzarella | tomato | basil | olive oil | foccacia bread $14.95

Pesto Chicken Sandwich

• grilled chicken | fresh mozzarella | roasted red peppers | house made pesto | foccacia bread $14.95
• Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $11.95

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore: hours and how to order