Bagel Supreme | Wallington

457 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ

Menu (As of 10/29)

Featured

• Pumpkin Bagel $3.50
• Pumkin Spice Latte $6.49Iced latte with milk and pumpkin sweet cream cold foam
• Choose a base + up 3 mix-ins $4.75
• The Buffalo Bulk Bagel $12.95Scallion cream cheese, double fried eggs, crispy bacon, avocado and buffalo sauce. A gooey, cheesy masterpiece.
• The Sweet & Salty Bagel $12.95Bagel of your choice loaded with thick-cut bacon, fried eggs, honey-maple walnut cream cheese and maple syrup.
• The Supreme Cluck-N-Crunch Bagel $12.95Breaded chicken cutlet, fried egg, melted pepper jack cheese, crispy bacon, pickled jalapeños, and mike's hot honey.
• The Loaded Tot Supreme Bagel $12.95Bagel of your choice with scrambled eggs, melted cheddar, crispy tater tots, taylor ham, cream cheese and ranch.
• Muscle Builder Bagel $10.50Scrambled eggs, steak strips, cheddar, grilled onions
• Egg White BLT Bagel $10.50Egg whites, turkey bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo
• The Avocado Smashhhhhh Bagel $10.95Soft-scrambled eggs, creamy smashed avocado, melted pepper jack. Crispy onions and russian dressing.
• The Early Bird Bagel $10.95Fluffy egg whites, turkey bacon, and sautéed baby spinach with melted swiss. Hint of sweet honey mustard.
• Mexican Burrito Wrap $9.953 Eggs, sausage, home fries & pepper jack cheese
• Brooklyn Burrito Wrap $9.953 Eggs, bacon, home fries & american cheese
• Supreme Burrito Wrap $9.953 Egg, ham, home fries & mozzarella
• Light Burrito Wrap $9.953 Egg whites, spinach, tomato & avocado
• Downtown Omelette $11.99Bacon, mushrooms & swiss
• Eastside Omelette $11.99Sausage, mushroom, mozzarella
• Smoked salmon & onion $11.99
• Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.95
• Egg Salad Sandwich $8.95
• Whitefish Salad Sandwich $12.25
• Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich $9.95
• Chocolate Thunder Shake $9.99Chocolate Protein, Banana, Cocoa, Peanut Butter, Oats, Almond Milk
• Cotton Candy Cloud 9 Milkshake $10.99Vanilla ice cream, cotton candy syrup, milk, whipped cream, rainbow sprinkles
• Cold Brew Bang Milkshake $10.99Vanilla ice cream, cold brew, milk, chocolate drizzle, cold foam
• Strawberry Cheesecake Milkshake $10.99Vanilla ice cream, fresh strawberries, cheesecake pieces, crushed biscoff, milk
• Tiramisu Dream Milkshake $10.99Milk, soft serve, scoopable tiramisu, espresso shot, cocoa powder, sweet cream cold foam

Manny's Smash Combo

• The Classic Smashsmash patty, American cheese, pickles, onions, ketchup, chipotle mayo · Side of curly fries
• Milkshake of your choice $17.99
• BAGELS no spread $2.25Plain Bagel - no spread
• Half Dozen Bagels - no spread $8.50
• One Dozen Bagels - no spread $16.00
• Butter Bagel $3.75
• Plain Cream Cheese Bagel $4.75
• Butter & Cream Cheese Bagel $4.75
• Butter and Grape Jelly Bagel $3.99
• Cream Cheese and Grape Jelly Bagel $4.75
• Peanut Butter and Grape Jelly Bagel $4.75
• Nutella Bagel $4.75
• Grilled Cheese Bagel $5.95
• Grilled Cheese & Meat Bagel $6.95
• Cream Cheese & Meat Bagel $6.95
• Nutella and Grape Jelly Bagel $5.99
• Chocolate Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Jalapeño Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Honey Pecan Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Cranberry Walnut Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Strawberry Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Scallion Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Vegetable Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Olive Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Lox Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99
• Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese Bagel $5.99

Lox Specials

• The Classic Bagel $11.95Smoked salmon, plain cream cheese, tomato, red onion & capers
• The Nova Supreme Bagel $15.95Smoked salmon, veggie cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, capers & cucumber
• The Avocado Special Bagel $16.95Smoked salmon, scallion cream cheese, avocado, tomato & red onion

The Workout Carb-up Menu

• The Fat Supreme- The Ultimate Breakfast Bagel $12.95Crispy bacon, sausage, eggs, double-hash brown stack, melted american, and russian dressing.

Protein & Performance Bagels

• Lean Jersey Bagel $10.50Egg whites, turkey sausage, spinach, swiss

Supreme Signature Lineup

• The Jersey Supreme Bagel $10.95Thick-cut taylor ham, two over-easy eggs, melted american cheese, crispy golden hash brown and chipotle mayo.
• The Meal-Lover's Supreme Stack Bagel $10.95Crispy bacon, sausage patty, double-layered with melted american and sharp cheddar. Finished with mayo.
• The Hangover Cure Bagel $10.95Bacon, eggs, melted american cheese tater tots and hot honey drizzle.

The Classics

• Egg Sandwich $5.75
• Egg & Cheese Sandwich $6.50
• Egg Whites Sandwich $6.75
• B.L.T Sandwich $7.50

Breakfast Wraps

• Morning Delight Wrap $9.953 Egg whites, turkey bacon, spinach & cheddar cheese
• Vegetarian Wrap $9.953 Egg whites, peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes
• Texas Burrito Wrap $9.953 Eggs, pastrami, home fries & swiss cheese

Muffins, Baked & Desserts

• Muffin $3.99Assorted Muffin Choices.
• Croissant $3.75Toasted/Untoasted w/ choice of butter extra.
• Apple Turnover $3.75
• Crumb Cake $4.00Choose a type.
• Cookie $3.75Choose type/topping.
• Pound Cakes $3.99Choose a flavor.
• Rugula $2.99
• Summer Cookies $5.95
• Harvest Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.50
• Harvest Sprinkle Cookie $3.50
• Harvest M&M Cookie $3.50
• Choco-Chip Cookies $3.99
• Chia Cake $5.99
• Watermelon $5.75

City Sized Omelettes

• Bacon Treat Omelette $11.99Bacon, onions & cheddar cheese
• Western Omelette $11.99Ham, peppers, onions & pepper jack
• Chicharron Omelette $11.99Sausage, onions, peppers & swiss
• The Greek Delight Omelette $11.99Egg whites, tomatoes, onions & feta cheese
• Health Start Omelette $11.99Egg whites, spinach, peppers & onions
• French Toast Platter Omelette $11.99(4) French toast triangles. bacon or ham

Pancakes / Waffles

• Pancake $7.50
• Waffle $7.50
• Chocolate Overdose $8.752 Pancakes w/nutella, syrup, chocolate chips & powdered sugar
• All American Breakfast $12.99Pancake or waffle served with sunny side up eggs, bacon or sausage and maple syrup.

Salad Sandwiches

• Tuna Melt Sandwich $8.95
• Chicken Salad Sandwich $8.95

Lunch Wraps

• Manny's Wrap $11.95Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, spinach & pesto sauce
• California Wrap $11.95Roast beef, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, russian dressing
• Manhattan Wrap $11.95Turkey, bacon, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing
• Chicken Caesar Wrap $11.95Grilled chicken lettuce, caesar dressing
• Buffalo Wrap $11.95Grilled chicken, lettuce, hot sauce, bleu cheese
• European Wrap $11.95Grilled chicken, spinach, olives, roasted peppers & mozzarella
• Veggie Wrap $11.95Mixed greens, spinach, dill, roasted peppers, mozzarella, balsamic vinegar

Boars Head Sandwiches

• Salami Boars Head Sandwich $10.95
• Bologna Boars Head Sandwich $10.95
• Imported Ham Boars Head Sandwich $10.95
• Roast Beef Boars Head Sandwich $10.95
• Corned Beef Boars Head Sandwich $10.95
• Pastrami Boars Head Sandwich $10.95
• Oven Gold Turkey Boars Head Sandwich $10.95
• Cracked Pepper Mill Boars Head Sandwich $10.95

Subs

• The Godfather Sub $11.95Grilled roast beef, cheddar cheese, mushrooms, onion, russian dressing. Served with chips and pickle.
• Lawyer Sub $11.95Grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Served with chips and pickle.
• The Vegetarian Sub $11.95Spinach, onions, roasted peppers, tomato, balsamic vinegar, oil. Served with chips and pickle.
• Chicken Pesto Sub $11.95Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, spinach, pesto sauce. Served with chips and pickle.
• Turkey Supreme Sub $11.95Turkey, bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing. Served with chips and pickle.
• Italian Sub $11.95Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, oil, vinegar. Served with chips and pickle.
• Good Fella Sub $11.95Breaded chicken, melted mozzarella, roast peppers, balsamic vinaigrette. Served with chips and pickle.
• Pepper Jack & Pastrami Sub $11.95Grilled pastrami, melted pepper jack, roasted peppers, Russian dressing. Served with chips and pickle.
• Mom's Delight Sub $11.95Grilled chicken, mozzarella, arugula, roasted peppers, balsamic vinegar & oil. Served with chips and pickle.
• Turkey & Avocado Sub $11.95Turkey breast, avocado, tomato, olive oil. Served with chips and pickle.

Fresh Salads

• Manny's Salad $9.95Mixed greens, turkey, swiss, tomato, cucumber, boiled eggs. Honey mustard.
• Mediterranean Salad $9.95Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumber, kalamata olives, red onion, crumbled feta cheese. Oil and vinegar.
• Mulberry Street Salad $9.95Fresh mozzarella, mixed greens, tomatoes, roasted peppers, black olives and balsamic vinagrette
• Granny's Orchard $9.95Mixed greens, granny smith apples, dried cranberries, walnuts, feta cheese. Served with raspberry vinaigrette.
• Chicken Caesar Salad $9.95Romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, parmesan cheese, croutons. Caesar dressing.
• Grilled Chicken Supreme Salad $9.95Tender grilled chicken breast over mixed greens served with tomato and cucumber, oil and vinegar.
• The Scoop Salad $9.95Your choice- tuna salad or chicken salad with mixed greens, tomatoes and cucumbers.
• The Chef's Salad $9.95Mixed greens, turkey, salami, swiss cheese, italian dressing.

Hot Specialty Paninis

• Light Delight Panini $11.95Turkey, swiss, deli mustard
• Green Market Panini $11.95Grilled vegetables, brie cheese & balsamic vinaigrette
• Supreme Club Panini $11.95Turkey, bacon, onion, tomato, swiss & honey mustard
• Special Treat Panini $11.95Ham, swiss, lettuce & honey mustard
• Chicken Classic Panini $11.95Grilled chicken, lettuce, swiss & honey mustard
• Southwestern Panini $11.95Turkey, bacon, cheddar cheese, chipotle sauce

The Lunch Box

• (5) Pcs w/french fries $10.95
• Philly Cheese Steak Lunch Box $10.95Peppers, onions & cheese served w/french fries
• Grilled Burger Lunch Box $10.95Cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, ketchup & mayo
• Sloppy Joe Lunch Box $10.95Triple decker on rye w/cole slaw, swiss & russian dressing
• The Reuben Lunch Box $10.95Grilled corned beef or pastrami w/sauerkraut, swiss, russian dressing on rye

Side Orders

• Hashbrowns $5.50
• Home Fries $5.99
• Tater tots $5.99
• French Fries $5.50
• Meat $6.95
• Eggs $5.00

Berry Glow

• Strawberry + Acai + Lemonade $5.99
• Pink Dragon $5.99Strawberry + Dragonfruit + Coconut Water
• Blood Orange Mango $5.99Blood Orange + Mango + Lemonade

Blue Raspberry Blast

• Blue Raspberry + Lemonade $5.99

Peach Paradise

• White Peach + Green Tea $5.99

Smoothies

• Berry Blast Smoothie $7.49Strawberry, blueberry, raspberries, banana, milk, honey
• Green Machine Smoothie $7.49Spinach, mango, pineapple, orange juice
• Peach Sunrise Smoothie $7.49Peach, orange, banana, honey, almond milk
• Mixed Berry Acai Boost Smoothie $7.49Acai, blueberry, strawberry, milk
• Supreme Shake Smoothie $7.49Strawberry, banana, milk
• Mango Glide Smoothie $7.49Mango, banana, oat milk

Tea & Classics

• Iced Tea $4.49
• Matcha $4.99
• Chai Latte $4.99
• Green Tea $4.49
• Lemonade $4.49
• Half & Half $4.99Lemonade, iced tea

Cold Brew & Iced Coffee

• Harvest Black & White Cookie $3.99
• Cold Brew $5.99
• Nitro Cold Brew Coffee $5.99
• Iced Coffee $4.99

Beverages

• Soda | 12 Fl Oz Can $2.25Choose a flavor. Served as 12 FL OZ can.
• Poland Spring Water $2.2516.9 Fl Oz

Protein Shakes

• Keto Supreme Shake $9.99Plant-Based Vanilla Protein, Strawberries, Almond Milk

Milkshakes

• Cookie Butter Crunch Milkshake $10.99Chocolate ice cream, biscoff cookie butter, milk, whipped cream, crushed biscoff, caramel drizzle

Bagel Supreme | Wallington: hours and how to order