NextEats › New Jersey › Food in Manahawkin › Steak House › The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House › Menu The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House
1201 E Bay Ave, Manahawkin, NJ
Menu (As of 10/29)
From The Kitchen Raw Bar $16.00 Ceviche $16.00 citrus marinated fresh seafood, avo, pico de gallo, sriracha, house tortilla chips Bonsai Oyster (4) $16 / $10 (6) $18 (12) house oyster topped with sushi grade tuna, spicy mayo, eel sauce, panko, scallion and tobiko. Clams on the 1/2 Shell $10 (6) $18 (12) / $16 (6) fresh shucked barnegat bay clams, cocktail & lemon. Shrimp Cocktail $16 (6) / $18 jumbo shrimp, lemon, cocktail sauce Yellowfin Tuna Poke Bowl $18 / $24 hanalei style raw sushi grade tuna, sesame soy marinate, wonton chips, seaweed salad Crab Cocktail $24 / $16 jumbo lump crab, cocktail sauce, lemon Old Bay Crab Dip $16 / $20 lump crab, old bay, cream cheese, horseradish, table crackers Lobster Cocktail $20.00 chilled 1/2 lobster with chive vinaigrette (in shell) Seafood Towers $50.00 Main Sail (serves 2-4) $50 / $110 6 clams, 6 oysters, 4 jumbo shrimp, 1/2 chilled lobster Royal Sail (serves 6-8) $110.00 12 clams, 12 oysters, 6 jumbo shrimp, 2 half chilled lobsters, jumbo lump crab cocktail Soup and Salad $15.00 Steakhouse Wedge $15.00 iceberg wedge, caramelized onion, crispy proscuitto, heirloom tomatoes, bleu cheese, balsamic, candied pecans The OC Chopped $15.00 fresh farm greens & iceberg lettuce tossed with avocado, egg, blue cheese, beets, tomato, bacon & bermuda onion Caesar $15.00 romaine hearts, roasted mixed peppers, house made garlic croutons, grated grana padano Farro Salad $15 / $10 toasted farro, heirloom tomato, arugula, squash, goat cheese, pickled carrot, sunflower seeds, roasted tomato vinaigrette Manhattan Clam Chowder $10 / $11 classic red with tender ocean clams, potato & chorizo French Onion Soup $11.00 caramalized onions, gruyere & swiss cheeses, crusty bread Starters $18.00 Oyster Rockefeller (6) $18 / $16 spinach, bacon, parmesan Fire Roasted Oysters (6) $16.00 roasted on wood-fire grill, shallot herb butter Fried Oysters $16 / $14 remlouade & fresh lemon Jersey Devils (4) $14 / $18 fried oysters & sriracha on deviled eggs Classic Mussels $18 / $20 garlic, shallot, white wine & lemon, and butter (lots of it) Mexicali Mussels $20.00 chorizo, lime, cilantro, chipotle butter, cream Crab Cake $20 / $18 Mud City’s “world famous” cake served with remoulade Bonsai Tuna Rice Cakes $18 / $16 fresh sushi grade tuna, crispy rice cakes, spicy mayo, eel sauce Fried Calamari $16 / $17 fried jalapeños, fried sliced lemons, chimichurri mayo OC Wings (10) $17 / $30 honey brushed & dry rubbed with blue cheese dressing Lobster Poutine Fries $30 / $19 house fries, smothered in garlic gravy with lobster, tomato & fresh mozzarella curd Blackened Filet Mignon Tips $19 / $15 gorgonzola & applewood smoked bacon cream cheese Pork Carnita Quesadilla $15 / $16 crispy pork, cheese, pico de gallo, chipotle cream Blistered Shishito Peppers $16.00 roasted garlic aioli & shaved parmesan Sides $8.00 All of our sides enhance any meal! parmesan, parsley $8 / $12 Crispy Brussels Sprouts $12.00 hot honey glaze, golden raisins Bourbon Glazed Carrots $12 / $11 bourbon glaze, apricot mastarda, crumbled goat cheese, almonds fresh herbs $11 / $9 Cheesy Fritters $9 / $11 cheddar & panko, horseradish cream Mac N Cheese $11 / $12 creamy Vermont white cheddar & shells Spanish Fries $12 / $10 house seasoned wedge cut, jalapeños, fried onion, & manchego sauce Creamed Spinach $10.00 parmesan bechamel lemon & olive oil $10.00 Stuffed Sweet $10 / $7 herb pesto drizzle, corn, roasted peppers, manchego, sweet chile sauce Baked Potato $7.00 always fresh baked hand mashed yukon $7 / $6 OC Slaw $6.00 light & tangy Bar Bites $12.00 Grilled Pretzel $12 / $7 buttered then grilled, whole grain mustard, manchego cheese sauce Deviled Eggs (4) $7 / $6 cause they’re good! Fish Tacos (1) $6 / $10 fried, pico de gallo, oc slaw, avocado, chipotle aioli Fried Blue Olives (6) $10 / $16 blue cheese stuffed green olives, balsamic glaze OC Chips $16.00 house fried potato chips topped with braised short ribs, blooming onion petals, scallion & chipotle cheese sauce Wood Fired Steaks The Cuts $38 6 oz Filet Mignon $38 6 oz NY strip $43 12 oz Rib Eye $54 14 oz / $28 10 oz Flat Iron Steak $28 10 oz Pork Chop $28 12 oz / $42 16 oz Slow Roasted & Wood-Fire Grilled Prime Rib $42 16 oz One sauce on us, each additional sauce $4.00 Horseradish Cream The Surf $19.00 4 oz lobster tails $19 / $20 crab cake $20 / $16 fried oysters $16.00 garlic smother shrimp $16 / $29 grilled snow crab (1/2lb) $29.00 Signature Steaks $59.00 "Old Causeway Oscar" $59 / $68 grilled 8oz filet mignon served over asparagus & topped with jumbo snow crab meat & béarnaise sauce “The Black Eye” $68 / $52 14 oz. rubbed down Ribeye steak grilled with blackening season and smothered in our jumbo lump crab & gorgonzola cream sauce with house roasted mixed peppers-“It will knock you out” “Rosemary’s Strip” $52 / $34 rosemary & garlic marinated 12 oz NY strip, cradled atop sourdough crostini and bathed in our roasted mushroom cabernet sauce “Karate Chop” $34.00 bone in 12 oz. coriander crusted pork chop, pineapple soy glaze, steak house mashed (after 4pm-sub fries) Entrees $40.00 Lobster Fettuccine $40.00 fresh lobster meat, wood-fire grilled 1/2 lobster tail, asparagus tips, lemon & parmesan cream, crusty garlic bread Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes (2) $40 / $32 Mud City’s “world famous” crab cakes, remoulade, OC slaw Truffle Chicken Milanese $32 / $30 crispy 10 oz. airline breast, fresh arugula, red onion, cherry tomatoes, white truffle vinaigrette Open Face Meatloaf $30 / $36 creamed spinach, bacon, OC steak sauce on texas toast, mashed potatoes Shrimp & Grits $36 / $38 (add fettuccine pasta $7) sautéed jumbo shrimp, diced tomatoes & andouille cream sauce over white cheddar jalapeño grits, griddle toast, & fried green tomatoes Seafood Pot $38 (add fettuccine pasta $7) / $36 select cuts of fish, clams, mussels, 1/2 lobster tail, calamari, & jumbo shrimp stewed in a smoky tomato broth with crusty garlic bread Sesame Yellowfin Tuna $36 / $40 sesame seared, sliced avocado, pineapple soy glaze & lo mein noodles Old Causeway Lobster Tails $40 / $32 2 South African lobster tails egg battered & finished with diced tomato caper sauce, served with roasted asparagus Grilled Greek Salmon $32 / $79 wood fired grilled atlantic salmon, warm vegetable orzo, house made tzatziki Jumbo Snow Crab Clusters $79.00 1 1/4 lb of jumbo snow crab (wood-fire grilled), drawn butter, oc slaw & shoe string fries Sandwiches $30.00 All of our delicious sandwiches are served with a dill pickle & shoestring fries, house salad or oc slaw Classic Lobster Roll $30.00 split top bun, fresh warm lobster, avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato, & tarragon aioli on the side Lobster Reuben $30.00 warm lobster, sliced ciabatta, OC slaw, swiss cheese, remoulade Lobster Grilled Cheese $30 / $20 warm lobster, cheddar & american cheese, bacon, Texas toast Fish Tacos (3) $20 / $17 same great fish tacos, fried cod, pico de gallo, oc slaw, avocado & chipotle aioli, on corn tortillas Andouille Sausage Grinder $17 / $24 grilled andouille, pressed baguette, chimichurri, roast peppers, provolone Grilled Crab Cake Wrap $24 / $20 our “world famous” crab cake with cheddar, bacon, remoulade, lettuce, tomato, wrapped in a large tortilla & grilled Tri-Tip Steak Sandwich $20 / $17 hand carved tri-tip loaded on a sourdough onion roll with arugula, caramelized onions, horseradish sauce and gruyere cheese Corned Beef Reuben $17 / $18 corned beef piled high on sliced ciabatta with OC slaw, swiss cheese, & remoulade Fried Oyster BLT $18 / $16 hand breaded fried oysters on texas toast with bacon, lettuce, tomato & old bay aioli Pulled Pork $16 / $15 house smoked pork butt, provolone, roasted anaheim peppers, brown sugar-cider mop sauce, on a kaiser “The Big Cheese” $15.00 grilled texas toast stuffed with cheddar, bacon, & a fried green tomato! Grilled Vegetable Slammer $15.00 roasted mixed peppers, squash & mushrooms, horseradish sauce & gruyere cheese, ciabatta bread Burgers $16.00 Our 1/2 lb. burger s are 100% black angus beef flame grilled & served with a dill pickle & shoestring fries, house salad or oc slaw The Original $16.00 lettuce, tomato, & onion on a soft bun OC Burger $18 / $19 our black angus burger topped with fried oysters, roasted mushrooms, horseradish cream, & OC steak sauce Steak House Burger $19 / $17 avocado, cheddar, bacon, fried egg, chipolte ketchup on grilled Texas toast Scooter Burger $17.00 our black angus burger topped with bleu cheese cream, bacon & cherry peppers Kids Menu $16.00 5 oz. Flat Iron Steak $16 / $12 wood-fire grilled, served with ketchup Grilled Cheese $12 / $10 texas toast, cheddar & american cheese Macaroni & Cheese $10 / $11 vermont cheddar and shells Hamburger or Cheeseburger $11 / $10 100% angus beef on a toasted artisan roll Chicken Fingers (3) $10 / $12 crispy chicken fingers served with ketchup Fish & Chips $12 / $9 crispy cod served with ketchup or tartar sauce Kids Pasta $9.00 butter & parmesan cheese Desserts $12.00 Strawberry & Limoncello Parfait $12.00 limoncello pastry cream, fresh strawberry coulis, vanilla bean cake, whipped cream Warm Apple & Cherry Cobbler $12.00 warm apples & bing cherries, toasted oat crumble, vanilla bean ice cream Chocolate, Bourbon, Banana Bread Pudding $12.00 wild turkey infused, dark chocolate chips, bruleéd banana, vanilla ice cream Vanilla Bean Creme Brûlée $12.00 creamy custard with a crisp caramel layer Classic Carrot Cake $12.00 raisins, maple cream cheese icing, candied pecans Chocolate Sourdough Layer Cake $12 / $11 dark chocolate buttercream icing, milk chocolate chips, chocolate sauce Eric's Cheesecake $11 / $7 fresh strawberry sauce, whipped cream Ice Cream (by Rich's Ice Cream) $7.00 vanilla/chocolate/cinnamon swirl/vegan strawberry Spiked Coffee $11.00 Buck-a-shuck House Oysters on the Half Shell $1.00 served with cocktail, mignonette, & fresh lemon Wings (7) $10.00 dry rubbed, honey brushed, w/ side of house made bleu cheese dressing Grilled Pretzel $10.00 wood-fire grilled NY-style, w/ whole grain mustard & manchego cheese sauce Oc Chips $10.00 crispy potato chips topped with braised short rib, fried onions, fresh scallions & chipotle cheese sauce Jersey Devils (4) $10.00 our house deviled eggs, topped with a crispy oyster & sriracha Beverages $4.00 Beer $4 / $5 coors light & yuengling draft, narragansett lager 16 oz. can Oc IPA Draft $5 / $6 the house original draft Wine $6.00 house cabernet, merlot, chardonnay, pinot grigio, & white zinfandel Cocktails $6 / 4 house vodka, gin, tequila, rum, whiskey, bourbon or scotch (with simple mixers) Brunch Sharables $12.00 Cinnamon Roll $12 / $14 house made, cream cheese icing, candied pecans Jersey Devils $14 / $17 (4) deviled eggs topped with fried oysters & sriracha Bacon, Egg & Cheese Poutine $17.00 shoe fries, applewood smoked bacon, vermont cheddar, mozzarella curd, tomato cream, 2 sunny side eggs, baked brie House Favorites $32.00 Steak & Eggs $32 / $25 wood-fire grilled flat iron, chimichurri, 2 eggs, ciabatta toast, breakfast potatoes Country Fried Filet Mignon & Eggs $25 / $26 crispy filet mignon, 2 eggs, hollandaise, breakfast potatoes Mud City Benedict $26 / $24 “World famous" Mud City mini crab cakes, bacon, avocado, poached eggs, hollandaise, Texas toast Lobster French Toast $24 / $20 egg-battered lobster tail, brioche french toast, poached egg, vermont maple syrup, whipped butter Brunch Shrimp & Grits $20 / $19 our delicious jumbo shrimp & grits with diced tomato & andouille cream, Texas toast, fried green tomato, & fried egg Good Morning Burger $19 / $18 avocado, cheddar, bacon, fried egg, chipotle ketchup, texas toast, breakfast potatoes Meatloaf Patty Melt $18 / $17 house made meatloaf, cheddar cheese, fried egg, arugula, & garlic aioli, toasted ciabatta, breakfast potatoes Spanish Scramble $17.00 fried potatoes, red onion, jalapeños, chorizo, scrambled egg, manchego cheese sauce, pressed baguette in a cast iron skillet King’s Breakfast Sandwich $17 / $16 pork roll, fried egg, cheese, grilled pineapple, chipotle ketchup, king’s hawaiian bread, breakfast potatoes Carnitas Breakfast Wrap $16 / $17 pulled pork, anaheim peppers, potatoes, scrambled egg, cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, chipotle mayo & iceberg in a large flour tortilla, breakfast potatoes Chipotle Sweet Potato Bowl $17 / $16 roasted sweet potato, farro, guacamole, pickled onion, fried egg, chipotle aioli, everything bagel seasoning, grilled ciabatta Andouille Sausage Tacos $16 / $18 grilled andouille, scrambled egg, potatoes & peppers, garlic aioli, corn tortillas, breakfast potatoes The Standard $18 / $12 2 cage free eggs, choice of texas toast, ciabatta, or multigrain, choice of pork roll, bacon, or sausage patties, breakfast potatoes Original $12.00 2 slices of thick cut brioche, whipped butter, vermont maple syrup & powdered sugar Sides $6.00 Pork Roll-Bacon-Sausage Links $6 / $5 Wood Grilled Toast $5 / $6 ciabatta, multigrain, texas toast, with house berry jam & butter Fresh Fruit (seasonal selection) $6 / $12 Spanish Fries $12.00 diced potato, peppers, onions Kids Menu $7.00 Plain French Toast (1) $7 / $11 (add cheese for $1) slice of thick cut brioche, served with vermont maple syrup & whipped butter Scrambled Eggs & Choice of Meat $11 (add cheese for $1) / $19 pork roll, bacon, country ham, or sausage patties Steak & Eggs $19.00 5 oz. wood-fire grilled hanger steak & 1 egg Bloody Marys $13.00 The Captain $13 / $14 sky vodka, old bay rim, cocktail shrimp. Jersey Devil $14 / $12 skyy vodka, old bay rim, cocktail shrimp Maria $12 / $13 epsilon tequila, tajin rim, grilled jalapeño Derby $13.00 wild turkey bourbon, bleu cheese stuffed olives, everything bagel spice rim Brunch Cocktails $16.00 OC Espresso Martini $16 / $13 3 olives vanilla vodka, kahlua, & freshly brewed espresso, sugar rim Mocha Ice $13 / $14 stoli vanilla vodka, dark creme de coca, freshly brewed espresso, cream The Morning After $14 / $16 wild turkey, vanilla simple syrup, espresso, chocolate bitters Haulin' Oats $16 / $13 casamigos reposado, ancho reyes liqueur, brown sugar simple syrup, oat milk, freshly brewed espresso Basil Peach Smash $13 / $14 Bentham gin, elderflower liqueur, fresh lemon, honey, splash of prosecco Blueberry Crumble Refresher $14 / $12 pinnacle whipped vodka, blueberry syrup, apple juice, fresh lemon, splash of club soda Brunch Punch $12 / $11 sky citrus vodka, triple sec, orange, pineapple, & pomegranate juices Michelada $11.00 modelo, tomato juice, tabasco & tajin rim Mimosas $9 first, $1 each refill Hers $9 first, $1 each refill / $8 champagne & fresh oj His $8 / $10 a pint with fresh oj & a 16 oz. tall boy Narragansett lager Big Wave $10.00 pint of Kona Big Wave & pineapple juice Coffee Yellow Dog Coffee Roasting $4.00 *Sumatra & Kenya - Dark Roast* Espresso $4 / $5 Double Espresso $5 / $6 Cappuccino $6.00 Old Causeway Catering Menu Raw Bar $25 dozen Briny Piney Oysters $25 dozen / $16 dozen fresh, local oyseters served with cocktail, mignonette & lemon Barnegat Bay Clams $16 dozen / $35 quart fresh local clam, served with cocktail, horseradish, & lemon Ceviche $35 quart / $28 a pound citrus marinated seafood, avo, pico de gallo, house tortilla chips Shrimp Cocktail $28 a pound jumbo shrimp. lemon, cocktail sauce Seafood Towers $50 (serves 2-4) The Main Sail $50 (serves 2-4) / $99 (serves 6-8) 6 clams, 6 oysters, jumbo shrimp. 12 oz. lobster The Royal Sail $99 (serves 6-8) 12 clams. 12 oysters, jumbo shrimp. 2 - lobster halves, fresh ceviche with house tortilla chips Salads $30 half tray Steakhouse Wedge $30 half tray / $45 half tray iceberg wedge, caramelized onion, crispy prosciutto, heirloom tomatoes, bleu cheese, balsamic, candied pecans Farro Salad $45 half tray / $30 half tray toasted farro, heirloom tomato, arugula, squash, goat cheese. pickled carrot. sumflower seeds, roasted tomato vinaigrette Caesar $30 half tray / $35 half tray romaine, sunrise peppers, parmesan, house made garlic The OC Chopped $35 half tray fresh farm greens & iceberg lettuce tossed with avocado, egg, bleu cheese, beets, tomato's bacon & Bermuda onion. Bar Bites $55 half tray OC Chips $55 half tray / $70 twelve tacos house fried potato chips topped with braised short rib, blooming onion petals, scallion & chapotie cheese sauce Fish Taco $70 twelve tacos / $20 dozen fried fish, pico de gallo, cole slaw, avocado, chipotle aioli Deviled Eggs $20 dozen / $15 (18 pieces) cause they're good! Fried Bleu Olives $15 (18 pieces) bleu cheese stuffed areen olives with balsamic gaze Starters $35 dozen Oysters Rockefeller $35 dozen / $30 dozen oysters baked with spinach, bacon, parmesan Fire Roasted Oysters $30 dozen / $40 dozen oysters roasted on grill, shallot, herb butter Jersey Devils $40 dozen / 45 fried oysters over devils eggs Classic Mussels $45.00 (half tray) garlic , shallot, white wine & lemon and butter Mexicali Mussels 55 / $95 (half tray) chorizo, lime, cilantro, chipotle butter & cream Mini Crab Cakes $95.00 Mud City's "world famous" cake served with remoulade Cheese & Crackers $45 half tray / $48 half tray vermont cheddar, manchego, sliced pepperoni, prosciutto, spicy mustard, seasonal fruit spread, house made crostini Fried Calamari $48 half tray / $45 (30) fried jalapeños, fried sliced lemons, chimichurri mayo Wings $45 (30) / $60 half tray honey brushed wings, dry rubbed with bleu cheese dressing Lobster Poutine Fries $60 half tray / $40 half tray house fries smothered in garlic, gravy with lobster, tomato and fresh mozzarella curd Pork Carnita Quesadilla $40 half tray crispy pork, cheese, pico de gallo, chipotle cream SIDES (half tray) $18.00 parmesan, parsley $18 / $55 Bourbon Glazed Carrots $55 / $50 bourbon glaze, apricot, mustard, goat cheese, almonds Crispy Brussels Sprouts $50 / $45 remoulade, cherry pepper relish, parmesan herb butter, sea salt $45 / $55 Delicata Squash $55 / $40 brown butter, goat cheese, almonds Cheesy Fritters $40 / $45 cheddar & potato, horseradish sauce Mac N'Cheese $45.00 creamy Vermont white cheddar & shells Spanish Fries $45 / $50 seasoned wedge cut, jalepenos, fried onions & manchego sauce Roasted Asparagus $50.00 Stuffed Sweet Potato $50 (6) herb pesto drizzle, corn, roasted peppers, manchego, sweet chile sauce Creamed Spinach $50 / $30 parmesan bechamel Steak House Mashed $30 / $20 OC Slaw $20.00 light & tangy SLIDERS (12 per order) $110.00 Warm Buttered Lobster Roll $110 / $55 fresh warm lobster, avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato, & tarragon aioli on the side Andouille Sausage Grinder $55 / $75 grilled andouille, arugula, pesto, roasted peppers, provolone Crab Cake Sandwich $75 / $55 our "world famous' Mud City crab cake with cheddar, bacon, remoulade, lettuce and tomato Tri-Tip Steak Sandwich $55 / $50 hand carved tri-tip, arugula, caramelized onions, horseradish sauce and gruyere cheese Corned Beef Reuben $50 / $60 corned beef piled high with OC slaw, swiss cheese & remoulade Fried Oyster BLT $60 / $45 hand-breaded fried oysters with bacon, lettuce, tomato, and old bay aioli Pulled Pork $45 / $40 house-smoked pork butt, provolone, roasted anaheim peppers, brown sugar-cider mop sauce Grilled Vegetable Slammer $40 / $55 sunrise peppers, asparagus & mushrooms, horseradish sauce & gruyere cheese OC Burger $55 / $45 100% black angus beef topped with fried oysters, roasted mushrooms, horseradish spread & OC steak sauce Scooter Burger $45 / $35 100% black angus beef topped with bleu cheese cream, bacon & cherry peppers (sauced served on side) Hamburger $35 / $40 100% black Angus beef topped with lettuce, tomato, and red onion Cheeseburger $40.00 100% black Angus beef topped with cheese of your choice (american, cheddar, swiss, provolone, pepper jack) ENTREES (half tray) $125.00 Clam & Mussel Scampi Pasta $125 / $115 18 barnegat bay clams, 18 pei mussels, chopped ocean clams, calabrian chili scampi cream, mafaldine pasta, 1/2 tray of toasted garlic baguette Open Faced Meatloaf $115 / $145 eight 5 oz. pieces, creamed spinach, bacon, OC steak sauce (texas toast served on side) Shrimp & Grits $145 / $150 28 sautéed jumbo shrimp, diced tomatoes & applewood bacon sauce over white cheddar jalepenos grits, griddle toast & fried green tomaotoes Seafood Pot $150 / $175 select cuts of fish, clams, mussels, 4 pc 1/2 lobster tail, calamari & jumbo shrimp stewed in a smoky tomato broth with garlic bread Sesame Yellowfin Tuna $175 / $240 ten 4 oz. sesame seared steaks, sliced avocado, pineapple soy glaze & rice noodles OC Lobster Tails $240 / $160 twelve South African lobster tails, egg battered and finished with diced caper sauce, served with roasted asparagus Salmon Farro $160.00 ten 4 oz. pieces of grilled atlantic salmon, shrimp & mixed pepper cream, warm vegetable farro Desserts $60.00 Classic Carrot Cake (12-15 slices) $60 / $55 raisins, maple cream cheese icing (candied pecans served on side) Eric's Cheesecake (10 slices) $55 / $80 graham cracker crust, fresh raspberry sauce (served on side) Triple Chocolate Cake (12-15 slices) $80 / $45 rich chocolate cake, whipped chocolate ganache icing, milk chocolate chips Seasonal Fresh Fruit Cobbler (10-12) $45.00 fresh fruit, toasted cinnamon oat crumble, powdered sugar The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House: hours and how to order