House$6 / $12Iceberg, provel cheese, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, housemade croutons, parmesan, sweet zesty Italian
Cottleville Cobb Salad$17.00Bacon, blue cheese, carrots, grilled chicken, sliced egg, diced tomatoes with ranch dressing
Take home a quart of our Homemade Mayfair or House Dressing for$12.00
Handcrafted Favorites
Paulie$17.50Roasted beef, provel, garlic mayo on ciabatta with side of au jus
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich$17.50Lightly breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella served on cheese garlic bread
Cottleville Sliders$17.50Three mini beef patties with melted American cheese, and our signature sauce on toasted brioche buns
Mahi Mahi Fish Tacos$21.00Blackened mahi mahi in warm tortillas, aioli slaw topped with avocado lime sauce
Paulie (Italian Beef)$16.50Roast beef, provel, garlic aioli on ciabatta, served with au jus and choice of fries, tots, or side salad
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich$16.50Lightly breaded chicken, tomato basil sauce, fresh mozzarella on garlic cheese bread, served with fries, tots, or side salad
Grilled Chicken Cheesesteak$16.50Grilled chicken, sautéed peppers & onions, melted cheese on toasted ciabatta, served with fries or tots
Fire-Grilled Chicken Quesadilla$16.50Grilled chicken, sautéed peppers & onions, melted cheese on toasted flour tortilla, served with fries or tots
Pasta
Lasagna$21.00Thin layered pasta, meat sauce, blend of cheeses
Cannelloni (3)$20.50Beef cannelloni baked with meat sauce, blend of cheeses, pink sauce
Seafood Cannelloni (3)$23.50Stuffed with lobster, scallops, shrimp and topped off with garlic shrimp, cream sauce and blend of cheeses
Manicotti (3)$18.50Cheese manicotti baked with tomato basil, blend of cheeses, cream sauce
Beef Tortellini$20.50Bacon, asparagus tips with garlic cream sauce
Meat Cannelloni (2)$16.50Beef cannelloni baked with meat sauce and pink sauce, topped with melted cheese
Seafood Cannelloni (2)$17.50Stuffed with lobster, scallops, and shrimp, topped with garlic cream sauce and melted cheese
Eggplant Parmesan$23.50Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, blend of cheeses, served with tomato basil pasta, roasted asparagus
Chicken Parmesan$23.50Lightly breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella served with tomato basil spaghetti, roasted asparagus
Chicken Modiga$25.00Lightly breaded chicken, with a white wine lemon butter sauce and a blend of cheeses, crispy bacon and fresh mushrooms. Served with olive oil butter garlic pasta, roasted asparagus.
House Specialty Chicken Spiedini$23.00Chicken spiedini over olive oil butter garlic spaghetti with grilled asparagus, topped with lemon butter sauce
Baked Salmon$23.00Eight ounce filet with brown sugar dry rub served with broccoli