Our Legendary interpretation of a classic salad$4.00Fresh Romaine Hearts tossed with Creamy Caesar Dressing topped with seasoned crunchy Croutons and shaved Parmesan Cheese. Add Grilled Chicken, or Deep Fried Breaded Chicken Strips for an additional
Traditional Wings
8 pcs for$15.00
Boneless Wings
1/2 LB. for$15.00
Chicken Tenders
5 pieces for$15.00
Build Your Own Legend
Hamburger$8.75
Velveeta Cheeseburger$9.00
Double Hamburger$12.50
Double Velveeta Cheeseburger$14.50
Triple Cheeseburger$17.00
Hamburger$10.50
Velveeta Cheeseburger$12.00
Double Hamburger$15.50
Double Velveeta Cheeseburger$17.00
Triple Cheeseburger$19.75
The following toppings$1.50/each
Lettuce and Tomato • Hardwood Smoked Bacon$3.00
Gourmet Buns$2.00
Return to Top
Bison Burger$17.75
Black Bean Burger$15.00Morningstar Farms Black Bean Chipotle Vegetarian Burger, a savory blend of black beans, brown rice, corn, diced tomatoes, green and red peppers. Served on a Brioche Bun.
Turkey Burger$15.00House Ground Turkey – Our custom blend of spices, red onion, Jalapeños mixed with 4 oz. of our House Ground Hand Pattied Turkey served on a Brioche Bun.
Patty Melt$15.00Our Ultimate Hamburger topped with melted Swiss Cheese and Grilled Onions served on a grilled Marble Rye Bread. Make it a Double Patty Melt
Ultimate Gourmet Burgers
BBQ Burger$16.00
Bleu Burger$16.00
Buffalo Street Burger$16.00
Wilson Street Burger$16.00
No Substitutions
Breaded Popcorn Shrimp$14.00
Captain’s Platter$23.00
Breaded Shrimp$16.00
Clam Strip Dinner$14.00
Lake Perch Dinner$18.00
Just Dogs
Hot Dog$7.25
Cheese Dog$8.00
Chili Dog$8.00
Chili Cheese Dog$8.50
“New” Buffalo Dog$8.75
Two Dog Special$12.00
Change of Pace
Jimbo’s Italian Beef$14.25
Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato on toasted White Bread topped with Mayonnaise. Served with a dill pickle spear. The way Mom us$3.50
Red’s Reuben$16.75
Trio Club$16.00
New Buffalo Hot Breaded Chicken Sandwich$16.00
Maui’s Madness$16.00
Hildy’s Hot Ham and Cheese Sandwich$11.50
Sloppy Mak$12.50
Short Subjects
The “LITTLE MAK”$7.00
The “LITTLE CHEESE MAK”$8.00
The “Kiddy Dog”$7.00
The “LITTLE CHICKEN”$8.00
“The Original” Kraft Macaroni & Cheese$7.00
The “Little Mini Corn Dogs”$7.00
Grilled Cheese$8.00
Short Drinks
2% Milk$3.50
Chocolate Milk$3.50
Orange Juice$3.50
Cranberry Juice$3.50
Pineapple Juice$3.50
Apple Juice$3.50
Bottled Water$3.00
Soft Drinks – By the Glass (Free Refills – Dine-In Only)$3.50
Soft Drinks – By the Pitcher (Free Refills – Dine-In Only)$8.00
Soft Drinks – Kids Cup (Free Refills – Dine-In Only)$3.25
Shakes & Stuff
Red’s Cheesecake Shakes$8.00
Specialty Shakes$8.00
Red’s Oreo Blast
Shakes$7.50
Malts$7.50
Smoothies$6.50
Red’s Dreamsicle$6.50
Red’s Root Beer Float$6.50
Legendary Liquids
Red’s Bloody Mary$8.00“The Bloody Mary that made New Buffalo famous!” You haven’t had a Bloody Mary until you’ve had one of ours! A combination of Smirnoff Vodka and Zing Zang’s Bloody Mary Mix, green olives and a dill pickle spear with hot sauce and Worcestershire sauce served on the side.
Piña Colada$8.00A delicious blend of Island Oasis Piña Colada, Pineapple Juice and Bacardi Rum. Also available in Strawberry, Raspberry, Banana, and “New” Mango. Topped with Real Whipped Cream and a Cherry. Escape to the Islands!
Nutty Monkey$8.00Island Oasis Banana and DiSaronno Amaretto blended frozen – you’ll go bananas for this cocktail! Topped with Real Whipped Cream and a Cherry.
Mudslide$8.00Kahlúa, Baileys Irish Cream, Vodka blended with Vanilla Shake Mix. Topped with Real Whipped Cream and a Cherry.
Margarita$8.00Jose Cuervo Gold is the highlight of this tart and tangy cocktail. Also available in Strawberry, Banana, Raspberry, and “New” Mango or any combination.
Grand Margarita$10.00A unique combination of Grand Marnier and Jose Cuervo Gold. Where’s the Fiesta?!
Delicious Daiquiris$8.00Highlighting Bacardi Rum and refreshing flavors: Strawberry, Banana, Raspberry, and “New” Mango or any combination blended frozen. Topped with Real Whipped Cream and a Cherry.
Bahama Mama$8.00Crafted cocktail, Myer’s Dark Rum, Malibu Rum, Crème de Banana, and Pineapple Juice.
The Hurricane
Windex$8.00Set your taste buds awash with flavors that will definitely brighten your horizons. Blue Curacao, Vodka, Sprite, and a touch of lime served on the rocks.
Redamak’s Punch$8.00Malibu Rum and Pineapple Juice with a splash of Grenadine – a pineapple pleaser!
The Mermaid’s Tale$8.00Capt. Morgan’s Spiced Rum and Malibu Rum mixed with Blue Curacao and Pineapple Juice with a slice of fresh lime.
Pain Killer$8.00Uniquely blended Island Oasis Piña Colada mix, Myer’s Dark Rum, Orange Juice and Pineapple juice served with a cherry.
Beer Bottles$6.00Angry Orchard hard Cider
Budweiser$6.00
Bud Light$6.00
Coors Light$6.00
Corona$6.00
Corona Light$6.00
“NEW” Corona (NA)$6.00
Michelob Ultra$6.00
Miller High Life$6.00
Labatt Blue$6.00
Leinenkugel’s Summer Shandy$6.00
“NEW” High Noon$6.00
“NEW” Sun Cruiser$6.00
“NEW” Lucky One$6.00
Athletic (NA)$6.00
Draft Beer
Alaskan Amber Ale$5.00
Blue Moon$5.00
Bell’s Hazy Hearted$5.00
Bell’s Oberon$5.00
Bell’s Two Hearted Ale$5.00
Haymarket Blood Orange Blonde$5.00
Miller Lite$5.00
Round Barn Kolsch$5.00
Stella Artois$5.00
Seedz Brewery$5.00
“New” Yuengling Lager$5.00
Wine
Glass (6oz.)$8.00 • Bottle – $25.00
Soft Drinks
2% Milk$3.50
Chocolate Milk$3.50
Orange Juice$3.50
Cranberry Juice$3.50
Pineapple Juice$3.50
Apple Juice$3.50
Bottled Water$3.00
Soft Drinks – By the Glass (Free Refills – Dine-In Only)$3.50
Soft Drinks – By the Pitcher (Free Refills – Dine-In Only)$8.00
Soft Drinks – Kids Cup (Free Refills – Dine-In Only)$3.25