Ice Cream Paradise

1416 W South St, Lebanon, IN

Menu (As of 10/30)

Homemade Ice Cream

• 1 Dip $4.50
• 2 Dips $5.60
• 3 Dips $6.85
• Cone or Dish $6.001 Dip Waffle Cone
• 2 Dips Waffle Cone $7.20
• 3 Dips Waffle Cone $9.30
• Hand Dipped Banana Split $8.75
• Hand Dipped Soda/Float Small $5.75 Large $6.60

Hand Dipped Sundaes

• Hand Dipped Sundaes Small $5.00 Medium $5.35 Large $6.05
• Hand Dipped Shake Small $6.05 Large $7.40
• Malt Added $1.15

Cones or Dishes

• Dog/Baby 2.25 Small 2.75 Medium 3.15 Large 3.50
• Dog/Baby 2.80 Small 3.25 Medium 3.50 Large 4.00
• Soft Serve Waffle Cones $5.95

Soft Serve Sundeas

• Soft Serve Sundeas Small $4.45 Medium $4.60 Large $5.10

Soft Serve Sodas / Floats

• Soft Serve Sodas/Floats Small $4.95 Large $5.90

Soft Serve Shakes

• Soft Serve Shakes Small $5.25 Large $6.10

Soft Serve Malts

• Soft Serve Malts Small $6.20 Large $6.90
• Shake & Sundae FlavorsVanilla - Banana - Chocolate - Marshmallow - Strawberry - Hot Caramel - Peanut Butter - Cherry - Butterscotch - Raspberry - Pineapple - Hot Fudge - Butter Pecan - Creme De Menthe
• Fountain Small $2.65 Medium $2.90 Large $3.25
• Flavor Added $0.85
• Bottled Water $2.25
• 24oz. Cup of Ice $0.95

Sandwiches

• Hot Dog $2.90
• Coney $4.30
• Sloppy Joe $4.75
• Ham&Cheese $5.50
• BBQ $5.25
• BBQ Dog $4.55

Includes Medium Soft Drink

• Chili Nachos $8.50
• BBQ Nachos $9.90
• Supreme Nachos $11.50
• Supreme BBQ Nachos $12.55
• Chef Salad $8.75

Includes Chips & Medium Drink

• Coney $8.35
• BBQ Dog $8.35
• Sloppy Joe $8.35
• Ham & Cheese $8.90
• BBQ $8.90
• Kids Meal $7.50Hotdog, Chips, Cookie & Kids Drink

Side Items

• Chips $1.99
• Nachos & Cheese $5.25
• Chili Cheese Nachos $6.75
• BBQ Nachos $7.75
• Supreme Nachos $9.50
• BBQ Supreme Nachos $10.50
• Chef Salad $7.95
• 1 Cookie $1.35
• 3 Cookies $3.00
• 12 Cookies $8.25

Extras

• Cheese $1.35
• Sour Cream $1.20
• Large Drink in Combo $0.75
• Flavored Drink in Combo $0.85
• Nuts $1.25
• Pecans $1.60
• Sprinkles $0.50
• Extra Candy $1.25
• Extra Malt $1.15
• Flavor 0.85 Fruit 0.60 Cream 0.75

Slushes

• Slushes Small $2.95 Medium $3.25 Large $4.00Lime - Cherry - Blue Raspberry - Grape - Orange - Strawberry
• Slush Freeze $5.40

Take Home

• Coney Pint 13.50 Quart 27.00 Half Gallon 54
• BBQ Pint 13.00 Quart 26.00 Half Gallon 52.00
• Turtle Pie $26.50
• Soft Serve Pint 8.250 Quart 10.50 Half Gallon 17.00
• Hand Dipped Pint 9.75 Quart 12.95 Half Gallon 18.50
• 1Bar $2.50 12 Bars $21.00

Dairy Free Banjo Bar

• 1Bar $2.75 12 Bars $25.00
• 1Bar $2.75 12 Bars $24.50

Specialties

• Turtle Sundae Small 5.50 Medium 6.50 Large 7.85

Flurries

• Flurries Small 5.75 Large 7.50
• Paradise Nachos $7.85
• Hot Fudge Cake $7.85
• Strawberry Short Cake $7.85
• Fudgeberry Delight $7.85
• Banana Split $7.85
• Banana Royal $7.85
• Parfait $7.85
• Cherry Licious Cake $7.85
• Waffle Sundae $7.80

Paradise Pops

• Paradise Pops Small 3.80 Medium 4.25 Large 4.95Our take on the TikTok & Instagram viral dirty sodas!

Ice Cream Paradise: hours and how to order