Toasted Turtle Tavern

51425 IN-19, Elkhart, IN

Menu (As of 10/30)

Dockside Starters

• Reuben Egg Rolls $14.00Stuffed with smoked corned beef, sauerkraut and swiss cheese served
• Alligator Tail $16.00
• Red Crab Dip $17.00
• chips $15.00Clam Chowder
• Crab Rangoons $16.00
• sweet chili sauce $22.00Tennessee Whiskey Filet Tips
• Mavyn’s Meatball $14.00
• marinara $14.00Speared Chicken
• Bison Meatloaf LAKEHOUSE FAVORITES $24.00
• Argentina Shrimp & Grits GF $24.00Pan seared Argentina red shrimp, parmesan and white cheddar grits topped

Butter Basted Cod

• North Atlantic Beer Battered Cod $22.00

Sides

• Crab Stuffed Walleye $34.00

Broccoli Salad

• Filet Mignon GF $39.00

House Veggies

• Chicken & Waffles $18.00

Fresh Fruit

• Side Salad $4.00
• Mills’ ChopGF $18.00
• Sweet Potato Fries $2.00

Toasted

• Tavern Irish Stew Cup $5 / Bowl $8
• Italian Wedding Cup $5 / Bowl $8
• Dockside Reuben $18.00Smoked corned beef brisket, sauerkraut, swiss on marble rye with Russian dressing

Italian Sausage Sammie

• House blend Italian Sausage topped with Sunday sauce, sauteed $15.00peppers & onions, mozzarella, provolone on a toasted hoagie bun
• T-Bar Burger $18.00Brisket, ribeye and chuck steak patty, Swiss cheese, smoked corned beef,
• Pub Burger $16.00
• Meatball Sammy $18.00House blend Italian sausage, ground brisket and ribeye with marinara and
• Tavern BLT $14.00
• garlic herb mayo $14.00Lakehouse BrisketMelt

Filet Salad GF

• Leafy Legends $24.00
• Grilled Chicken Tavern Salad GF $16.00
• Caesar Wedge GF $14.00

Desserts

• Lakehouse Crab & Avocado GF $18.00
• Turtle Cheesecake $9.00

Flatbreads

• with salted caramel, $16.00Traditional Pepperoni Flatbread
• toasted pecans $17.00Hawaiian Flatbread
• Fair Donuts $7.00
• covered in cinnamon $19.00Argentina Shrimp Flatbread
• Chicken Caprese Flatbread $18.00Grilled chicken, rosemary infused olive oil, fresh garlic, cherry tomatoes, and

Toasted Turtle Tavern: hours and how to order