BlackSheep Pizza & Cocktails - Columbus

345 4th St, Columbus, IN

Menu (As of 10/30)

Dessert

• Appetizers $12.00
• Garlic Bread $12 / $14fire-roasted bread with fresh marinara & pesto
• White Bean Hummus $14 / $15fire roasted bread with carrot sticks, cucumbers & celery
• Meatballs $15 / $16trio of 4-ounce hand-made meatballs with marinara, ricotta & basil
• Smoked Caprese $16 / $18freckled tomato, fresh mozzarella, slow-cooked onions, pesto, baslamic glaze & herbed focaccia
• Spiedini $18 / $28filet mignon steak, pesto, arugula & truffle
• Spring Lolli-Chops $28.004 lamb chops with pesto, fresh peas & focaccia
• Salad & Soup $13.00
• Chilled Green Caesar $13 / $15romaine, parmesan crisp, slow-cooked onions, focaccia croutons & green caesar
• Chop $15 / $13romaine, arugula, pepperoni, pancetta, brussel sprouts, mozzarella, artichokes, peppadew, gorgonzola & pesto vinaigrette
• Greek $13 / $9romaine, feta, olive, roasted heirloom tomato, peppadew, red onion, focaccia croutons & red vinaigrette
• Cream of Asparagus $9.00puree of roasted asparagus, aromatics & cream
• Piadinas $19.00
• Steak $19 / $15sliced filet mignon, onions, peppers, pesto aioli, mozzarella & arugula
• Meatball $15 / $13hand-made meatballs, marinara, mozzarella & arugula
• Spring Vegetable $13.00arugula, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, red onions, asparagus, white bean hummus & balsamic
• Pizza $18.00
• Pecora Nera $18 / $15pancetta, pepperoni, slow-cooked onions & mozzarella
• Rita $15 / $18fresh mozzarella & basil
• Erbi $18 / $16slow-cooked onions, red pepper, mushroom, artichoke, mozzarella, arugula & pesto
• Tarantasio $16 / $19sweet sausage, provolone, gorgonzola & calabrian chilis
• Lazio $19 / $17prosciutto, ricotta, honey & calabrian chilis
• The Whitesheep $17 / $16mozzarella, provolone, parmesan & pecorino
• Etna $16 / $18mozzarella, garlic oil, sesame seed, ricotta, orange honey & pistachio
• Chicken $18.00chicken breast, pancetta, slow-cooked onion & parmesan sauce
• Potato $18 / $21sliced potato, parmesan sauce, truffle & rosemary
• Luigi $21 / $4pesto, meatballs, peppadew peppers & ricotta cheese
• Entree $28.00
• Salmon $28 / $3210 oz. atlantic salmon filet, fingerling potatoes, asparagus, peas & blistered tomatoes
• Pork $32 / $4516 oz. Smoked Duroc Pork Chop, fingerling potatoes, asparagus, peas & blistered tomatoes
• Truffled Ribeye $45 / $2212 oz. Fisher Farms Ribeye, fingerling potatoes, asparagus, peas & blistered tomatoes
• Roasted Asparagus Primavera $22.00penne, peas, asparagus, cherry tomatoes, lemon juice, basil, tarragon, chili flakes & pecorino
• Sides $6.00
• Small Arugula Salad $6 / $9
• Spicy Roasted Brussels $9 / $7
• Roasted Parm Potato $7.00
• Kids $7.00
• Cheese or Pepperoni Pizza $7 / $9
• Penne with Marinara & Meatball $9 / $5
• Buttered Penne $5.00
• Strawberries $5.00
• Dessert $14.00
• Hazelnut Dessert Pizza $14 / $12
• Tiramisu $12 / $6
• Amaro Montenegro $6 / $5
• French Press Coffee $5 / $15
• Recioto della Valpolicella $15.00

Menu Notes

• +Additional bread $2.00

Softer Drinks

• Blacksheep Signature Cocktails $11.00
• Aperol Ditz $11 / $12Amplifier Vodka, Aperol, Orangecello, Lemon Juice, Orange Bitters
• Nera Moda $12 / $13High Rye Bonded Bourbon, Amaro Montenegro, Orange Bitters
• Baa-ram-ewe $13.00Lavender-Infused Bourbon, Yellow Chartreuse, Orgeat, Lemon
• BlackSheep Martini $13 / $10Gin or Vodka, Cocchi Americano, Roero Arneis, Orange Bitters
• The Classic Old Fashioned $10.00Bonded Bourbon, Demerara, Angostura Bitters, Orange Bitters
• Curated Classics $13.00
• Paper Plane $13.00Bonded Bourbon, Aperol, Amaro Montenegro, Lemon
• Baa-Loma $13 / $15Tequila, Grapefruit, Honey, Campari, Lime
• Espresso Martini $15 / $13Vodka, Cold Brew Blend, Amaro Montenegro, Coffee Liqueur, Cherry Bark Bitters
• Clover CLub $13.00Letherbee Gin, Vermouth, Raspberry Hibiscus Syrup, Lemon, Egg White
• Old Fashioned Riffs $13.00
• Oaxacan Old Fashioned $13 / $12Blanco Tequila, Mezcal, Demerara, Orange Bitters
• Rubber Band Gun $12 / $14High Rye Scotch, Averna, Coffee Liqueur, Orange Bitters
• Post Modern Man $14 / $13Coconut Washed Aged Rum, Rye Whiskey Blend, Lemon Sherbet, Angostura, Absinthe Rinse
• The Cuban $13.00Bourbon, Aged Rum, Demerara, Tobacco Bitters, Jamaican Bitters
• House Wine $10.00

Monte Antico

• Cabernet Sauvignon & Sangiovese Blend $10 / $12

Due Uve

• Sauvignon Blanc & Pinot Grigio $12 / $8

Lazmauri Rose

• Saperavi & Dzelshavi (Georgia) $8 / $12

Primo Secco

• Brut White, Shabo (Ukraine) $12.00
• Cold Bubbles $10.00
• Moscato D'Asti $10.00Frizzante (barely sparkling) + Sweet + Floral

Prosecco Brut

• Effervescent + Dry + Cheerful $11.00
• Brachetto $12.00Pale Rose + Semi-Sweet + So Terribly Pretty
• Rose Prosecco $12.00Light Blush + Bone Dry + Salt Finished Berry
• White Grapes $12.00
• Friulano $12.00Breezy + Dry + Peachy Candy
• Roero Arneis $13.00Supple + Dry + Farm Stand Apple
• Sauvignon Blanc $13.00Zing + Bone Dry + Rambunctious

Pinot Grigio

• Delicate + Dry + Coy $13.00
• Chardonnay $15.00Luxurious + Bone Dry + Autumn Romance
• Red Grapes $16.00
• Pinot Noir $16.00Cherry Sky + Dry + Grandma’s Purse
• Refosco $15.00Happy Purple + Bone Dry + Ripe Brambles
• Montepulciano D'Abruzzo $10.00Soft Cranberry + Tart Dry + Plum Skin
• Chianti $13.00Brick Red + Bone Dry + Dried Cherries
• Primitivo $14.00Velvet + Just Dry + Oven Roasted Fruit
• Rossa Riserva $18.00Ripe Plum + Bone Dry + Smoked Chocolate
• Cabernet Sauvignon $15.00Neon Cherry + Dry + Cedar Spice
• Super Tuscan Cabernet $72 btl / $84 btlBlack Cherry + Bone Dry + Opulence
• Barbaresco $84 btl / $111 btlGhostly Red + Bone Dry + Haunting
• Brunello de Montalcino $111 btlInky Red + Dry + Rewarding Depths
• Draft Beer $6.00
• Blacksheep Pizza Lager $6 / $7
• Dragonfly IPA $7 / $6
• Wheat Ale $6 / $7
• Champagne Velvet $7.00
• Campside Ale $7 / $8
• Sour Seasonal $8 / $7
• Porter $7 / $6
• Peroni $6 / $7
• Ultra $7.00
• Rotating Tap $7.00
• Digestivo 50/50S $4.00
• Dad Joke $4 / $7Mellow Corn Whiskey / Amaro Montenegro

Ferrari

• Fernet / Campari $7 / $6

M&M

• Amaro Montenegro / Mezcal $6.00
• Ryenar $6.00High Double Rye Bourbon / Cynar
• Beer and a Shot $10.00
• Schumaker $10 / $11Light Lager with Bourbon
• Spoilermaker $11 / $12Wheat Ale with Lemoncello
• Undertaker $12 / $13Porter with Cynar & Orange
• Golden Bulleit $13.00Bulleit 2oz. with Blacksheep Pizza Lager
• Softer Drinks $3.00
• Signature Burgamotto Iced Tea $3.00
• Coca-Cola Products $3 / $5
• Topo Chico Sparkling Water $5.00

BlackSheep Pizza & Cocktails - Columbus: hours and how to order