Shay's Pie Place

4876 Yellowstone Ave suite 1 &2, Chubbuck, ID

Menu (As of 11/4)

Featured Products

• Birthday Party $150.00
• Birthday Party $11.50Meal Menu (single serving order)
• Meal Menu (single serving order) $40.00Meal Menu (family dinner preorder)
• Peach Pie (baked) $22.00
• Banoffee Pie $22.00
• Cherry Pie $25.00

Cherry Pie

• Chocolate Cream Pie $22.00
• Keto Pies $28.00

Chocolate Cream Pie

• Coconut Cream Pie $22.00

Coconut Cream Pie

• Keylime Pie $22.00
• Butterscotch Cream Pie $22.00

Keylime Pie

• Buttermilk Pie $22.00

Buttermilk Pie

• Lemon Meringue Pie $22.00

Lemon Meringue Pie

• Apple Pie $22.00
• Possum Pie $22.00

Apple Pie

• Banana Cream Pie $22.00

Banana Cream Pie

• Pecan Pie $22.00

Pecan Pie

• Razzleberry Pie $22.00
• Lemon Meringue Pie $22.00

Razzleberry Pie

• Strawberry Rhubarb Pie $22.00

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

• Pumpkin Pie $22.00
• Pumpkin Pie $45.00Tres Leches cake (9x13 pan)
• Tres Leches cake (9x13 pan) $20.00Cinnamon Rolls and Fruit Rolls (pan of 6)
• Heart Shaped Cheesecake $40.00
• Pumpkin Chiffon Pie $22.00

Full Sized Pies

• Nutella No-Bake Cheesecake $22.00
• Gluten Free Full-sized Pie $28.00
• Gluten Free Full-sized Pie $22.00Full sized no bake Cheesecake
• Pumpkin Pie $22.00
• Razzleberry Pie $22.00

Pumpkin Chiffon Pie

• Sour Cream Lemon Pie $22.00

Strawberry Lemonade Pie

• Pecan Pie $22.00

Possum Pie

• Keylime Pie $22.00

Fresh Peach Pie

• Keto Pies $28.00

Keto Pies

• Coconut Cream Pie $22.00
• Raspberry French Silk $25.00
• Raspberry French Silk $28.00Gluten Free Full-sized Pie
• Peanut Butter French Silk $25.00

Fresh Strawberry Pie

• Banoffee Pie $22.00

Specialty Pies

• Black Forest French Silk $25.00

Black Forest French Silk

• Cherry Pie $25.00

Other Treats (not pie)

• Full Sized Cheesecake (baked) $40.00
• Pumpkin Roll (full roll) $22.00
• Cream Puffs (9 pieces) $20.00
• Cream Puffs (9 pieces) $45.00Tres Leches cake (9x13 pan)
• 9x13 Pan Of Cake $45.00
• 9x13 Pan Of Cake $10.00Treat Boxes (personal size)

Weekly Meals

• Meal Menu (family dinner preorder) $40.00
• Meal Menu (single serving order) $11.50

Catering / Events

• Catering Options

Catering Options

• Birthday Party $150.00
• Birthday Party $25.00Fruit Salad (8x8 pan)
• Personal sized no bake cheesecake $6.00
• Personal Sized Pie (Any Flavor) $6.00Add flavor choices in the Order Comment section at checkout.

Shay's Pie Place: hours and how to order