Rothenberger Cafe, Amos Hall, 620 S Lumpkin St, Athens, GA
Menu (As of 10/30)
NEW AT NEWK's
Pick 3$16.29Pick any 3 Half Menu Options *Upcharge for Premium Items.
Pick 2$14.19Pick any two Half Sandwich, Half Salad, Cup Soup, Premium Side. *Upcharge for Premium Items.
Lasagna SoupSavory beef in a spicy tomato broth with tender mafalda pasta and Italian herbs. Garnished with Parmesan and fresh basil.
Pumpkin Spice Cake Slice$8.19Our Pumpkin Spice Cake is packed with warm pumpkin spice flavor and cozy fall goodness-perfectly paired with your favorite meal or enjoyed all on its own.
Value Pairings
Wrap Pairing$17.89Choose any wrap to pair with a Cup of Soup, Bowl of Fruit, Bowl of Pasta Salad, Bowl of Potato Salad, Half Mac & Cheese or a Half Salad. *Upcharge for Premium Sandwiches and Salads
Whole Sandwich Pairing$17.89Choose any whole sandwich to pair with a Cup of Soup, Bowl of Fruit, Bowl of Pasta Salad, Bowl of Potato Salad, Half Mac & Cheese or a Half Classic Salad. *Upcharge for Premium Sandwiches.
Full Salad Pairing$17.89Choose any Full Salad to pair with a Cup of Soup, Bowl of Fruit, Bowl of Pasta Salad, Bowl of Potato Salad, Half Mac & Cheese or a Half Classic Salad. *Upcharge for Premium Salads.
Pizza Pairing$17.89Choose any Entrée Pizza to pair with a Cup of Soup, Bowl of Fruit, Bowl of Pasta Salad, Bowl of Potato Salad, Half Mac & Cheese or a Half Classic Salad. *Upcharge for Premium Pizzas. Calories are displayed with pizza by the slice. 6 slices per pizza.
Mac & Cheese Pairing$17.89Choose any Entrée Mac & Cheese to pair with a Cup of Soup, Bowl of Fruit, Bowl of Pasta Salad, Bowl of Potato Salad, Half Mac & Cheese or a Half Classic Salad.
Bowl of Soup Pairing$17.89Choose any Bowl of Soup to pair with a Cup of Soup, Bowl of Fruit, Bowl of Pasta Salad, Bowl of Potato Salad, Half Mac & Cheese or a Half Classic Salad.
Sandwiches
The Trio$12.49Choose Between 3 of the Following, Newk's Chicken Salad, Pimiento Cheese, Fruit, Pasta Salad or Potato Salad. Served with crackers.
Cajun Shrimp Po'boy$16.89Cajun Shrimp, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Pickles, Red Onions, and Olive Oil. Served with a Side of Comeback Sauce.
Newk's Philly$17.29Roast Beef, Caramelized Onions, Red and Yellow Bell Peppers, Cheddar, Our Pimiento Cheese, Mayo.
Newk's "Q" Sandwich$14.19Chicken, bacon, Swiss and our signature white BBQ sauce. (N)
French Dip$15.99Roast beef, caramelized onions, Swiss, Creole mustard, mayo on Parisian bread. Served with a side of Au Jus.
Newk's Chicken Salad Sandwich$13.19Scratch-made chicken salad made with grapes, pecans and red onions, with lettuce, tomatoes, provolone, mayo on Parisian bread. (N)
The Italian Sandwich$13.79Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, hot cherry pepper relish, mayo, Creole mustard and Italian sauce.
Chicken Bacon Club$14.19Chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, Swiss, olive oil, mayo and honey mustard.
Turkey Avocado$14.39Turkey, Swiss, avocado, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Newk's Club$13.79Ham, turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, Swiss, cheddar, mayo and honey mustard.
Portabella Veggie Sandwich$12.89Baby Portabella mushrooms, red and yellow bell peppers, Swiss and basil pesto. (V)
Pesto Chicken Sandwich$13.79Chicken, red and yellow bell peppers, Swiss and basil pesto.
Pimiento Cheese$12.49Scratch-made with aged yellow and Vermont white cheddar and tomatoes. (N)(V)
Ham & Swiss$12.29Ham, Swiss, lettuce, tomatoes, Creole mustard and mayo.
Turkey & Swiss$12.29Turkey, Swiss, lettuce, tomatoes, Creole mustard and mayo.
Roast Beef$14.99Roast beef, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, Creole mustard and mayo.
Adult Grilled Cheese$10.99Cheddar on Parisian bread
Salads
Cajun Shrimp Comeback Salad$18.79Cajun Shrimp, Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Eggs, Carrots and Green Onions. Tossed with Mississippi Comeback Dressing.
Pesto Pasta Chicken Caesar$15.39All-natural chicken, romaine blend, pesto bowtie pasta, parmesan, red bell peppers and croutons. Tossed in caesar dressing.
Newk's Favorite$16.29Chicken, mixed greens, grapes, pecans, artichoke hearts, dried cranberries, Bleu Cheese and croutons served with Sherry Vinaigrette dressing. (N)
Green Goddess Salad$15.99Chicken, romaine blend, bacon, tomatoes, cucumbers, feta, avocado and green onions served with green goddess dressing.
Salmon Caesar$18.79Salmon, Romaine blend, Parmesan and croutons served with Caesar dressing.
Ultimate$16.89Chicken, bacon, ham, turkey, mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, cheddar and croutons served with honey mustard dressing.
Cobb$15.99Chicken, bacon, mixed greens, diced eggs, Bleu Cheese, tomatoes, green onions, pecans, and croutons served with Bleu Cheese dressing.
Caesar$9.99Romaine blend, Parmesan and croutons served with Caesar dressing.
Greek$12.89Romaine blend, artichoke hearts, Kalamata olives, cucumbers, pepperoncinis, red onions, tomatoes and feta served with Greek dressing.
Garden$9.99Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, shredded carrots, cheddar and croutons served with your choice of dressing. Adds
Half Caesar$8.19Romaine blend, Parmesan and croutons served with Caesar dressing.
Half Greek$9.79Romaine blend, artichoke hearts, Kalamata olives, cucumbers, pepperoncinis, red onions, tomatoes and feta served with Greek dressing.
Half Garden$8.19Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, shredded carrots, cheddar and croutons served with your choice of dressing. Adds
Pizzas
Spicy Shrimp$15.99Seasoned shrimp, red and yellow bell peppers, mozzarella, Parmesan, red pepper flakes and chili oil, topped with cilantro. Calories are displayed per slice. 6 slices per pizza.
Pepperoni$13.49Pepperoni, mozzarella and pizza sauce, topped with basil. 6 slices per pizza.
Sausage & Pepperoni$14.79Pepperoni, Italian pork sausage, mozzarella and pizza sauce, topped with basil. Calories are displayed per slice. 6 slices per pizza.
Supreme$15.39Pepperoni, Italian pork sausage, mozzarella, red and yellow bell peppers, red onions, pepperoncinis, and pizza sauce, with basil. Calories are displayed per slice. 6 slices per pizza.
Newk's "Q" Pizza$14.39Chicken, our signature white BBQ sauce, bacon, mozzarella and chili oil, topped with jalapeños and a white BBQ sauce drizzle. (N) Calories are displayed per slice. 6 slices per pizza.
BBQ Chicken$14.19All-natural chicken, red onions, mozzarella, BBQ sauce, topped with fresh cilantro. Calories are displayed per slice. 6 slices per pizza.
Margherita$12.29Grape tomatoes, mozzarella and pizza sauce, topped with basil. Calories are displayed per slice. 6 slices per pizza.
Portabella Veggie Pizza$13.79Baby Portabella mushrooms, red and yellow bell peppers, red onions, mozzarella and basil pesto, topped with basil. Calories are displayed per slice. 6 slices per pizza.
Mediterranean$14.39Chicken, Kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, pepperoncinis, red onions, mozzarella, feta and garlic olive oil. Calories are displayed per slice. 6 slices per pizza.
Wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap$12.89Chicken, Parmesan, romaine blend, and caesar dressing, wrapped in a spinach tortilla.
Newk's "Q" Wrap$12.89Chicken, bacon, Swiss, romaine blend and our signature white BBQ sauce wrapped in a flour tortilla.
Newk's Club Wrap$12.89Ham, turkey, bacon, Swiss, cheddar, romaine blend, tomatoes and honey mustard, wrapped in a flour tortilla.
Newk's Chicken Salad Wrap$12.49Scratch-made Chicken Salad, romaine blend and tomatoes, wrapped in a spinach tortilla.
Soups
Lobster & Crab BisqueA hearty bisque with cold water lobster meat in a flavorful seafood broth finished with cream and a touch of sherry. Garnished with green onions.
Tomato BasilA creamy, slow-simmered soup made with fresh tomatoes and hints of carrot, celery, onion and garlic.
Loaded PotatoA creamy chowder of potatoes, chives, bacon, sour cream, and melted cheese.
Chicken TortillaA rich chicken broth loaded with chicken and vegetables and seasoned with a touch of Ancho chilies, corn masa and cilantro.
Mac & Cheese
Five Cheese Mac & Cheese$10.39Five Cheese Mac & Cheese / Asiago, Vermont white cheddar, Parmesan and Ammerländer Swiss cheeses folded into elbow pasta then topped with yellow cheddar. (N)
Six Cheese Pimiento Mac with Bacon$11.69Five Cheese Mac with the extra creamy kick of pimiento cheese. Topped with crumbled bacon. (N)
Half Six Cheese Pimiento Mac & Cheese with Bacon$7.99Five Cheese Mac with the extra creamy kick of pimiento cheese. Topped with crumbled bacon. (N)
Half Five Cheese Mac & Cheese$6.99Five Cheese Mac & Cheese / Asiago, Vermont white cheddar, Parmesan and Ammerländer Swiss cheeses folded into elbow pasta then topped with yellow cheddar. (N)(V)
Kids Meals
Kid's Toasted Ham & Cheese$6.89Ham and aged cheddar cheese served warm on French Parisian bread with choice of fruit, applesauce or bag of chips. For kids 12 and under. Includes kid’s fountain beverage, or apple juice.
Kid's Grilled Cheese$6.89Aged cheddar cheese melted onto French Parisian bread with choice of fruit, applesauce or bag of chips. For kids 12 and under. Includes kid’s fountain beverage, or apple juice.
Kid's Toasted Turkey & Cheese$6.89Oven-roasted turkey and aged cheddar cheese served warm on French Parisian bread with choice of fruit, applesauce or bag of chips. For kids 12 and under. For kids 12 and under. Includes kid’s fountain beverage, or apple juice.
Kid's Five Cheese Mac & Cheese$6.89Blend of cheeses folded into elbow pasta topped with cheddar and baked. Served with choice of fruit, applesauce or bag of chips. For kids 12 and under. Includes kid’s fountain beverage, or apple juice.
Kid's Cheese Pizza$6.89Mozzarella and pizza sauce on half of a regular pizza crust. For kids 12 and under. Includes kid’s fountain beverage, or apple juice.
Kid's Pepperoni Pizza$6.89Pepperoni, mozzarella and pizza sauce on half of a regular pizza crust. For kids 12 and under. Includes kid’s fountain beverage, or apple juice.
Beverages
Coke$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Diet Coke$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Coke Zero$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Dr. Pepper$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Cherry Coke$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Diet Dr. Pepper$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Sprite$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Powerade$3.7932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Root Beer$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Sweet Tea$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Unsweet Tea$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Lemonade$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Half & Half Tea$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Splenda Tea$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Orange Fanta$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Hi-C Pink Lemonade$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Hi-C Fruit Punch$4.1932oz Collectible Newk's Cup
Bottled Water$2.79
Kids Drink$2.49
Mott's Apple Juice$2.49
Acqua Panna 500ML$3.19Acqua Panna® Natural Spring Water’s unique characteristics is its own mineral composition, maintained by its source which is sheltered by nature to help ensure its continuing quality. Acqua Panna® Natural Spring Water is bottled at the source coming naturally from its special place in nature.
San Pellegrino 500ml$3.29
Gallon BeveragesUpgrade to "The Works" for our classic tea (sweet, unsweet or Splenda) or lemonade offerings and receive cups, ice, lids, straws and sweeteners. Available for an additional charge.
Desserts
New York Cheesecake Slice$6.89A rich, creamy cheesecake with a buttery graham cracker crust topped with a Strawberry.
Caramel Cake Slice$6.89Made from Newk's very own bakery.
Chocolate Cake Slice$6.89Made from Newk's very own bakery.
Strawberry Cake Slice$6.89
Chocolate Chunk Cookie$2.79
Brownie$4.29
Big Crispy$4.29Crispy treat made with real marshmallows and Grade A butter. Made from Newk's very own bakery.
Peanut Butter Crispy$4.39Big Crispy treat made with peanut butter and topped with chocolate. Made from Newk's very own bakery.
Red Velvet Cake Slice$6.89
Grab & Go
Grab & Go Newk's Chicken Salad Bulk ContainerChicken salad - made from scratch with tender all-white meat, sliced grapes, pecans, diced red onion and mayo. Choice of 8oz, 16oz, and 32oz options.
Grab & Go Pimiento Cheese Bulk ContainerCreamy pimiento cheese – made from scratch with aged yellow and Vermont white cheddar cheeses. Choice of 8oz, 16oz, and 32oz options.
Grab & Go ProteinsServe as an Entrée or add to pasta, salads, stir fry & sandwiches.
Grab & Go Bulk SidesNewk's House-made Pasta Salad or Fresh Fruit - Choice of 8oz, 16oz, and 32oz options.
Grab & Go SoupsAll made from scratch from Newk’s original recipes. Choice of 16oz and 32oz soups.
Whole Cakes
Whole Pumpkin Spice Cake$62.49Our Pumpkin Spice Cake is packed with warm pumpkin spice flavor and cozy fall goodness-perfectly paired with your favorite meal or enjoyed all on its own.
New York Cheesecake - Whole$56.29A rich, creamy cheesecake with a buttery graham cracker crust topped with a Strawberry.
Chocolate Cake$56.29Made from scratch in Newk's very own bakery.
Caramel Cake$56.29Made from scratch in Newk's very own bakery.
Strawberry Cake$56.29Made from scratch in Newk's very own bakery.
Red Velvet Cake$56.29Made from scratch in Newk's very own bakery.
Sides & Dressings
Chips by the Bag
FruitCut seasonal fruit. (V)
Potato SaladTender potatoes tossed in mayonnaise, mustard, vinegar celery, onions, red bell peppers, sweet relish and hard-boiled eggs.
Do Not Provide UtensilsIn an effort to be green, we have provided you with the options to omit utensils from your order. So if you do not need utensils, please add this item to your cart.