Food Near Me in Shelter Island, NY: To-Go, Delivery & Dine-In

12 restaurants and food spots in Shelter Island, NY: 0 with To-Go, 0 with Delivery and 2 with Dine-In. Pick a place to see its hours, menu and how to order.

Places to eat in Shelter Island

• The Terrace at The PridwinRestaurant · 81 Shore Rd · Shelter Island, NYDine-In
• Vine Street CaféBar · 41 S Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NYDine-In
• IGA DeliDeli · 75 N Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NY
• Kyle'sBakery · 27 N Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NY
• Maria's KitchenTakeout Restaurant · 55 N Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NY
• Marie Eiffel MarketOrganic restaurant · 184 N Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NY
• Opties and DinghiesChinese restaurant · 87 N Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NY
• SALT Waterfront Bar & GrillBar & grill · 63 S Menantic Rd · Shelter Island, NY
• Shelter Island Craft BreweryBrewery · 55 N Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NY
• Shelter Island SlicePizza restaurant · 3 N Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NY
• The Eccentric BagelBagel shop · 25 W Neck Rd #1 · Shelter Island, NY
• The IslanderFamily restaurant · 63 N Ferry Rd · Shelter Island, NY

Food near Shelter Island

• Shelter Island Heights, NY
• East Marion, NY
• Greenport, NY
• Southold, NY
• Sag Harbor, NY
• Orient, NY
• Peconic, NY
• Cutchogue, NY
• New Suffolk, NY
• Bridgehampton, NY
• Sagaponack, NY
• Wainscott, NY
• East Hampton, NY
• Water Mill, NY
• Mattituck, NY
• Southampton, NY