Casey Key Fish House & Tiki
801 Blackburn Point Rd, Osprey, FL
Menu (As of 10/30)
Full
- New England Clam Chowder $8.99
- Soup of the Day $8.99
Sides
- Garlic Bread $3.99
- Side Fries $3.99
Salads
- Caesar Salad $10.99
- House Spring Mix $9.99
- Chicken $16.99
- Mahi $18.99
- Grouper or Shrimp $19.99
Beverages
- SoftDrink w/ Refill $3.50
Waterfront Seafood Grill
- Coffee w/ Refill $3.50
- Ice Tea w/Refill $3.50
“Old Florida at its Best”
Moderately Priced
- Key Lime Pie $8.99
- Dessert of the Day $8.99
- Marker $32.00
- Seasonal Hours 09.30.25
Baskets
- Mussels Marinara $14.99
- Grouper, Pan seared $34.99
Extras
- Mussels $15.99
- Prince Edward Island Mussels sautéed in white wine and $2.00 each.sauerkraut, sauces or dip
- Sesame Crusted Pan Seared Tuna $34.99
- Grouper Sandwich $20.99
- U-Peel—–U Eat Shrimp $13.99
- Baked Stuffed Shrimp w/ Crab Meat $33.99
- Mahi Sandwich $19.99
- Fresh Grilled Salmon $29.99
- U-Peel, Garlic Shrimp — Served warm $14.99
- Cod Fish & Chips $17.99
- Battered Shrimp $17.99
- Fresh Grilled Mahi-Mahi $30.99
- Buffalo shrimp $14.99
- Crab Cakes $19.99
- Char-Grilled Burger, 1/2 lb $15.99
- Seafood Pasta $33.99
- Buffalo Wings .. Some Like Them Hot! $14.99
- Black Bean Burger $13.99
- Chicken Breast Char-Grilled Sandwich $14.99
- Shrimp Scampi $27.99
- Chicken Fingers $13.99
- Calamari $14.99
- Beef Dog, 1/4 lb $11.99
- Battered Dog, 1/4lb Deep fried beer batter $12.99
- Mussels with Pasta $26.99
- Onion Rings $12.99
- Diver Scallops with Citrus Sauce $36.99
- Conch Fritters $14.99
- Almond Snapper, Pan Seared $32.99
- A blend of our special seasonings, fried to a golden brown. Fish and Chips ( 1 piece) $8.99
- Hot dog and fries $8.99
- Crab Cakes $15.99
- Grilled cheese with fries $8.99
- New York Strip—Angus Beef 14 oz $33.99
- Chicken Fingers with fries $8.99
- Pasta with butter or Marinara sauce $8.99
- Smoked Mahi Fish Dip $14.99
- Sautéed Chicken Breast $27.99
- Coconut Shrimp $14.99
Casey Key Fish House & Tiki: hours and how to order