The Classic Egg Sandwich - GFA$12.50Scrambled or fried eggs with cheddar cheese and choice of bacon, sausage patty or sliced ham on toasted brioche.
The Classic Egg Sandwich - GFA$12.50Scrambled or fried eggs with cheddar cheese and choice of bacon, sausage patty or sliced ham on toasted brioche.
Sunset Starters
Chef's Ceviche - GFAChef's ceviche prepared fresh daily. Typically, with lime juice, tomato, cucumber, red onion, cilantro, garlic, jalapeño, olive oil and avocado served with a choice of tortilla chips or crackers.
Soups
Soup of the Moment$10.50
Soup of the Moment$10.50
Clam Chowder$10.50Creamy New England style, served with crackers.
Pop's Favorite Styles
Lobster Encrusted$10.00Lobster with Sherry cream and panko breadcrumbs
Seafood / Raw Bar
Mussels - GFA$18.501 pound steamed with garlic butter.
Pop's "in Paradise" Burgers
Classic Burger$17.501/2 lb. burger with lettuce, tomato and your choice of cheese. Served on a toasted brioche bun.
Classic Burger$17.501/2 lb. burger with lettuce, tomato and your choice of cheese. Served on a toasted brioche bun.
Harbour Island Bahama Mama$18.501/2 lb. burger topped with a pineapple slice, mozzarella cheese and teriyaki. Served on a toasted brioche bun with lettuce and tomato.
Black Jack Burger$18.501/2 lb. burger lightly blackened with pepper jack cheese, fresh sliced jalapeño, lettuce and tomato on a toasted brioche bun.
Black Bean Quinoa Burger$15.50House-made black bean and quinoa patty topped with avocado, lettuce, tomato and Pop's sunset aioli. Served on a brioche bun.
Kid's Menu
Cheeseburger$10.00None
Cheeseburger$10.00
Chicken Tenders$10.00
Grilled Shrimp$10.00
Fried Cod$10.00
Chicken Quesadilla$10.00
Cheese Quesadilla$10.00
Mac n' Cheese$10.00
Traditional Sides
ColeslawNone
Beverages
Iced Tea, Sweet Tea, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt. Dew, Starry, Dr Pepper, Root Beer, Ginger Ale & Lemonade$4.25
Unlimited Refills$4.25Iced Tea, Sweet Tea, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt. Dew, Starry, Dr Pepper, Root Beer, Ginger Ale & Lemonade
Starbucks Coffee, Decaf Coffee or Hot Tea$4.00
Espresso$4.00
Cappuccino or Latte$5.50
The Joe - GFA
on toasted sourdough$11.50
Casey Key Sandwich$15.50Scrambled eggs with chive and pepperjack cheese, blackened shrimp and baja sauce on toasted brioche.
Mother & Child Reunion - GFA$14.50Scrambled eggs with cheddar cheese and a fried chicken tender dipped in hot honey. Served on a fresh buttermilk biscuit.
The Ultimate BLT - GFA$13.50Over-hard egg with bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on white toast
Breakfast Burrito - GFA$13.50Flour tortilla with scrambled eggs, onions, peppers, tomato, bacon, sausage, baja sauce, jack cheese. side of pico de gallo
Tiki Benedicts
Pop's Sunrise Benedict - GFA$13.502 poached eggs with cold smoked bacon topped with Hollandaise on an English muffin.
Cali-Avocado Bene - GF$14.502 poached eggs with spinach and avocado topped with Hollandaise on grilled beefsteak tomato. No bread here!
Hot Honey Chicken Benedict$16.50honey topped with Hollandaise on a buttermilk biscuit
International House of Pop's
All-American Waffle$10.50Traditional waffle served with butter and warm syrup.
Classic French Toast - GFA$12.503 slices served with butter and syrup
From The Bakery
Toast, etc$2.00Choose from sourdough, white, wheat, multigrain, buttermilk biscuit, English muffin or gluten-free white bread.
Warm Cinnamon Roll$5.00Straight from the oven and topped with cream cheese icing
Pop's Family Style Cinnamon Rolls$16.004 large cinnamon rolls, served family-style, straight from the oven. Perfect for sharing!
Kid's Breakfast
Silver Dollar Pancakes$5.003 fluffy silver dollar pancakes
1/2 waffle$5.00
Kid French Toast$5.004 strips, dusted with powder sugar
Kid Breakfast$5.002 eggs, choice of sausage or bacon and choice of toast
Coffee & Juice
Regular or decaf$3.50
Latte$5.50
Cappuccino$5.50
Espresso$3.50
Florida Orange Juice$4.50
Pop's Favorites
Rise & Shine - GFA$12.502 eggs cooked to order, choice of cold smoked bacon or sausage, choice of side and choice of toast.
You're The Avocado To My Toast - GFA$13.50Multigrain toast topped with smashed avocado, red onion, beets, marinated grape tomato and burrata cheese.
Chicken Veggie Skillet - GFA$16.50Grilled chicken, onions, mushrooms, peppers, tomato, broccoli, hash browns, jack cheese, 2 over medium eggs, Baja Sauce, Siracha and fried jalapenos
Loaded Hashbrown Balls$9.00(6) Shredded potato loaded with jack cheese, scallions, bacon and a side of cheese sauce
Brisket Hash - GF$17.50Smoked brisket with scrambled eggs, jack cheese, onions, peppers, mushrooms, BBQ sauce, BBQ seasoning, green onions
Pop's Own Huevos Rancheros$16.00Nacho ordinary Huevos Rancheros! House-made flour tortilla chips with 2 eggs cooked to order, black beans, tomato, onion, peppers, breakfast sausage, cheese, sour cream, scallions and pico de gallo
Cold Smoked Bacon$4.993 slices of cold smoked bacon
Marinated Tomatoes$3.50
Breakfast Drinks
Mimosa$6.00BRUT sparkling with choice of orange, pineapple or cranberry juice
Mimosa's for the Table$24.00750 ml BRUT sparkling with your choice of juice
Aperol Spritz$10.00Aperol, prosecco and club soda
Blood Orange Aperol Spritz$14.00Kick up your Aperol Spritz a notch with Shark Tooth Blood Orange Vodka. (local favorite!)
Bloody Mary$10.00Vodka with Zing-Zang Bloody Mary Mix, lemon, garnished with citrus, olive, celery and a taijn rim
Papa's Shaken Colada$11.00Papa's Pilar Blonde Rum, pineapple juice & Coco Lopez topped with Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum
Pop's Favorite
Market Price
Smoked Mahi Spread$13.50A healthy serving of smoked Mahi spread. Served with saltine crackers, carrots and cucumber slices.
Blackened Salmon Bites - GFA$16.50Fresh blackened salmon served with dill scallion aioli.
Wings "Mild to Wild"$16.508 wings served with celery and bleu cheese or ranch dressing. 6 Styles - mild, medium, hot, teriyaki, bbq or honey sriracha.
Coconut Shrimp$16.505 Large shrimp rolled in a coconut breading and golden fried. Served with Coco Dijon sauce.
Buffalo Shrimp$16.505 large shrimp lightly battered and fried, tossed in your choice of sauce. Served mild to wild with celery and bleu cheese dressing.
Salt & Pepper Calamari$16.50Rings and tentacles lightly dusted in seasoned flour, drizzled with dill scallion aioli and served with marinara sauce.
Fried Pickles$12.50Dill pickle spears lightly battered and golden fried. Served with ranch dressing.
Casey Key Nachos$16.50Tortilla chips topped with white queso bravo, corn pico de gallo, shredded lettuce and lime sour cream.
Shrimp Rangoon$18.505 crispy jumbo shrimp served over herbed cream cheese, sweet chili sauce and teriyaki glaze.
Rockefeller Style$4.00
Mediterranean Style$4.00
Mango BBQ Shrimp - GF$23.50Large grilled shrimp skewers with red onion and green pepper, glazed with mango BBQ sauce. Served with coconut rice and vegetable of the day.
Grilled Rack of Ribs - GFA$25.50Tender Baby Back Ribs grilled and smothered with sweet and tangy BBQ sauce. Served with fries and cole slaw.
Teriyaki Salmon$28.50Blackened Salmon finished with teriyaki glaze and scallions. Served with coconut rice and vegetable of the day.
6 oz Filet* - GF$38.50Parmesan Crusted or seasoned and grilled on the open flame, served with roasted red potatoes and vegetable of the day.
Mediterranean Chicken$24.00Chicken breast lightly dusted with flour, topped with artichoke, sun-dried tomatoes, capers parsley and lemon butter. Served with roasted red potatoes and vegetable of the day.
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp & Grits$32.00Bacon wrapped jumbo shrimp served with loaded grits topped with cheese, bacon and scallions.
Original Urbanek's Steamship Pot$30.508 steamed Royal Red easy-peel shrimp, 1/2 lb of mussels, Andouille sausage, corn on the cob, red bliss potatoes, onion, carrot & celery steamed with Old Bay seasoning. Served with drawn butter and spicy cocktail sauce.
1/2 lb Mussels$7.00
1 lobster tail$17.00
Famous Grouper Reuben$26.00Fried Red Grouper filet with sauerkraut, swiss cheese and thousand island dressing on toasted marble rye.
Salmon BLT$25.50Fresh salmon cooked on the open flame grill with bacon, lettuce, tomato and dill scallion aioli. Served on toasted marble rye.
Spicy Tuna Wrap - GFA$19.50Seared tuna, sushi rice, power blend, wasabi aioli and sweet chili sauce rolled in a warm spinach wrap. Served with a side of sesame dressing.
Chicken Caesar Wrap$17.50Grilled chicken breast tossed with classic Caesar salad and crushed croutons, wrapped in a flour tortilla.
Maine Lobster Roll$32.00Lobster with tarragon aioli, mixed greens and tomato on a brioche roll.
Marker 10 Tacos - GFA$21.00Fresh Mahi grilled or blackened on two corn tortillas with sunset slaw and queso fresco.
Shrimp Tacos - GFA$18.50Grilled or blackened shrimp on two corn tortillas with sunset slaw and queso fresco.
Pop's Favorite
Sunset Quesadilla - GFA
1/2 LB Royal Reds [NEW]$16.001/2 lb Royal Red shrimp steamed with Old Bay, served easy peel style with drawn garlic butter, cocktail sauce and fresh lemons.
Full LB Royal Reds$31.00Full LB Royal Red shrimp steamed with Old Bay, served easy peel style with drawn garlic butter, cocktail sauce and fresh lemons.
Casey Key Salad$15.50Mixed greens, red quinoa, blueberries, power blend, dried cranberries, candied pecans, goat cheese and white citrus vinaigrette.
Asian Sesame Salad$15.50Baby spinach, power blend, red onion, cucumber, crispy wontons, edamame, and sesame vinaigrette.
Classic Caesar Salad - GFA$13.50Romaine lettuce tossed with house-made Caesar dressing. Topped with croutons and parmesan cheese.
Chicken$8.00
Shrimp$10.00
Blackend Tuna$13.00
Salmon$13.00
5 Oz. Steak$15.00
Pop's Favorite
Flatbread Pizza
Margherita Flatbread - GF$17.50A combination of vine ripened tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, and balsamic drizzle.
Pepperoni Flatbread - GF$16.50Pepperoni slices with a blend of provolone and mozzarella cheeses.
Cheeseburger Flatbread - GF$19.50Seasoned ground beef, blended cheese, pickles, tomato, and thousand island dressing, finished with shredded lettuce.
Seafood Flatbread - GF$19.50Crab and shrimp with tomato, basil, scallions, mozzarella and balsamic drizzle.
Pop's Favorite
Mussels - GFA
1 Pound$18.50
Pop's Platters
Beer Battered Fish Platter$25.50Beer battered Cod, fried golden brown. Served with coleslaw, fries, tartar sauce and lemon wedge.
Panko Fried Shrimp Platter$24.506 large shrimp panko battered and fried to golden brown. Served with coleslaw, fries, cocktail sauce and lemon wedge.
Coconut Shrimp Platter$24.508 large shrimp rolled in a coconut breading and fried to golden brown. Served with coleslaw, fries, Coco Dijon sauce and a lemon wedge.
Pop's "in Paradise" Handhelds
Sunset Chicken Sandwich$17.506oz chicken breast on a toasted brioche bun with cheddar, lettuce, tomato and sunset aioli. Prepared buttermilk fried, grilled or blackened.