Maryland Crab Dip$13.99Maryland-style crab dip served with chips and garlic toast
French Onion Soup$6.79A hearty broth thick with sautéed onions, topped with a lid of melted cheese
Walnut Chicken Salad Plate$15.99Our freshly made chicken salad with tender chicken, walnuts, apples, seasonings and mayonnaise. Served on a bed of lettuce with assorted fresh fruit and hard-boiled egg
Jeremiah’s Supreme Burger$15.99Juicy all-beef burger loaded with sautéed onions, peppers and mushrooms, melted Swiss cheese and bacon
Crab Cake Sandwich$18.99Maryland-style crab cake made with jumbo lump crabmeat. Served with tartar sauce on the side
Shepherd’s Pie$16.99The ultimate casserole stuffed full of beef, potatoes, corn and cheese
Chicken Fingers Basket$14.99Tender chicken fingers served with French fries and your choice of dipping sauce · Served with your choice of two
Sizzling Steak or Chicken Fajitas$19.99A half-pound of chicken or steak served sizzling with grilled onions and peppers. Served with cheese, tomatoes, lettuce and flour tortillas
Lasagna$17.99Our own recipe, better than your mother's! Served with a house salad
Chicken Nuggets
Chocolate CakeNone
Jeremiah’s Rum Runner$9.25Malibu, banana liqueur, amaretto, pineapple juice, meyers floater
Blush and Red Wine
White Zinfandel, Estrella, CA$7.95Fresh-picked strawberries, and hints of cranberry on the delightful finish
White Zinfandel, Estrella, CA$7.95Fresh-picked strawberries, and hints of cranberry on the delightful finish
Sangue Di Guida, Decordi, Italy$8.95An effervescent red wine that occurs naturally. Full bodied, accompanied by violets, raspberry and blueberry jam notes creating a smooth finish
Merlot, Estrella River, CA$7.95Opens with dark ripe blackberries and cherries with mild oak on the smooth finish
Pinot Noir, Scarlet of Paris, France$8.95Aromas and flavors of black cherry and raspberry fruit and a hint of vanilla, with a long smooth finish
Montepulciano, Terre Di Poggo, Italy$9.95Medium-bodied packed with wonderful flavors of dark cherry, blackberry with soft velvety tannins with a well rounded finish
Cabernet, Estrella River, CA$7.95Flavors and aromas of ripe plum, black cherry and cassis that compliment the finish
Cabernet, Never Look Back, SA$11.00A full-bodied and richly textured, with intense black fruit, well-integrated hints of oak on the finish. You’ll never look back!
Moore Creek, Rose$8.95California Flavors and aromas of cherry, watermelon, red berry fruit, pomegranate and raspberry with a refreshing finish
Signature Cocktails
Maryland Crab Dip$13.99Maryland-style crab dip served with chips and garlic toast
Bacon Cheddar Potato Skins$10.99Crispy potato skins topped with crumbled bacon and melted cheddar cheese. Served with sour cream
Tavern Nachos
Full Order$12.99
Half Order$8.99
Stuffed Mushrooms$11.99Fresh mushroom caps with a crabmeat stuffing, topped with mozzarella cheese then baked
Fried Mushrooms$10.99Hand breaded and deep fried
Loaded Fries Tater Tots$11.99Tots covered with queso, cheddar cheese, bacon, onion straws, and jalapeños
Southwest Egg Rolls$10.99Spicy chicken, black beans, corn, cheeses and peppers
Jumbo Pretzel$11.99Served with 3 dipping sauces
Fried Onion Ring Tower$11.99Served with creamy horseradish sauce
Cajun Shrimp Dip$13.99Spicy shrimp in a cream cheese blend, served with pita chips
Fried Pickle Chips$8.99
Fried Wontons$8.99With sauce on the side
Chips and Salsa$5.99
French Onion SoupBowl $6.79 / Cup $5.59A hearty broth thick with sautéed onions, topped with a lid of melted cheese
Soup of the DayBowl $6.79 / Cup $5.59Ask your server for today’s fresh-made selection
Walnut Chicken Salad Plate$15.99Our freshly made chicken salad with tender chicken, walnuts, apples, seasonings and mayonnaise. Served on a bed of lettuce with assorted fresh fruit and hard-boiled egg
Beef Taco Salad$15.99Seasoned ground beef on a bed of lettuce topped with cheddar cheese, tomatoes, and black olives. Served in a taco bowl with tortilla chips. Sour cream and salsa on the side
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad$15.99Grilled chicken and romaine lettuce, topped with parmesan cheese and croutons. Tossed in Caesar dressing
Salmon Caesar Salad$18.99Salmon and romaine lettuce, topped with Parmesan cheese and croutons. Tossed in Caesar dressing
Fried Chicken Salad$15.99Tomatoes, crumbled bacon, and cheddar cheese tossed with fresh lettuce mix, topped with fried chicken
Grilled Chicken Cobb Salad$15.99Char-grilled chicken breast, bacon, hard-boiled, cheddar cheese, black olives and tomato
Grilled or Blackened Mahi Salad$17.99Over mixed greens with cheddar and Monterrey Jack cheese
Homemade Shrimp Salad$15.99Served with fresh fruit on a bed of lettuce
Fresh Garden Salad$6.99Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, black olives, cheddar cheese and croutons
Jeremiah’s Supreme Burger$15.99Juicy all-beef burger loaded with sautéed onions, peppers and mushrooms, melted Swiss cheese and bacon
California Bacon Cheeseburger$15.99A hot and juicy burger with melted American cheese and crispy bacon
Blackened Bleu Cheese & Bacon Burger$15.99A seasoned blackened burger with crisp bacon and bleu cheese crumbles
Whiskey Glazed Burger$15.99Fresh burger topped with bacon and smoked cheddar with lettuce, tomato and onion
Hamburger$13.99Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle
Rooney Burger$15.99Fresh burger topped with sautéed mushrooms and melted Swiss cheese
Classic Cheeseburger$14.99Fresh ground beef burger topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and melted cheese. Simply delicious!
Bison Burger$18.99Topped with smoked Gouda cheese
Patty Melt$15.99Juicy burger with sautéed onions and double the cheese on grilled rye bread
Short Rib Brisket Burger$16.99Topped with smoked cheddar and bacon
Pepperjack and Bacon Burger$15.99With fried jalapeños, topped with Boom Boom sauce
Crab Cake Sandwich$18.99Maryland-style crab cake made with jumbo lump crabmeat. Served with tartar sauce on the side
Fried Grouper
tartar sauce$17.99
Reuben, Reuben$15.99Lean corned beef, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread
French Dip$15.99Tender roast beef, shaved and piled on a fresh-baked deli roll with provolone cheese. Served with au jus
Philly Steak$15.99Choice of sliced sirloin or grilled chicken. Served with grilled onions and mushrooms, topped with melted Swiss cheese. Served on a fresh-baked deli roll
Deluxe Ribeye Steak Sandwich$17.99Topped with sautéed mushrooms, peppers, onions and cheddar cheese
Cuban Sandwich$16.99House-smoked pork with ham, mayo, mustard, Swiss and American cheese with pickles on Cuban bread
Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos$14.99House-smoked pork with ham, mayo, mustard, Swiss and American cheese with pickles on Cuban bread
Tenderloin Steak Sandwich$18.99With Onions, mushrooms, peppers, and Swiss cheese. Served on a ciabatta roll with au jus for dipping
With pepperjack cheese$14.99
BLT$13.99On toasted white bread
Island Fish Sandwich$16.99Grilled mahi topped with island slaw and provolone cheese
The DaVinci$14.99Pressed Italian sandwich! Salami, ham, crisp bacon and provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato and our special Italian mayo
Topped with smoked Gouda cheese$14.99
Smoked Pork on Toasted Roll$14.99Served with barbecue sauce on the side
Italian Turkey BLT$15.99Shaved turkey on fresh Ciabatta roll with fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, bacon and Italian mayo
Grilled Fish Tacos (3)$14.99Three flour tortillas filled with grilled mahi, lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, and our sweet chile sauce. Served with French fries
Shepherd’s Pie$16.99The ultimate casserole stuffed full of beef, potatoes, corn and cheese
Alabama Country-Fried Steak$16.99Tender sirloin steak lightly breaded, fried and served with mashed potatoes, brown gravy, and vegetable of the day
Chopped Steak$17.99Tender chopped steak topped with sautéed mushrooms and gravy. Served with mashed potatoes and vegetable
Fried Pork Chops$18.99Served with mashed potatoes and vegetables
Chicken and Dumplings$15.99Slow-cooked chicken and vegetables in a creamy stew with piping hot dumplings topped with a fresh buttermilk biscuit. Served with one side
Baked Chicken Pot Pie$15.99Pot pie with fresh chicken and garden vegetables in a rich creamy sauce baked until golden brown
Pot Roast$17.99A generous serving of slow-roasted beef, vegetables and mashed potatoes
Seafood Pot Pie$18.99Shrimp, scallop, fish, and crab meat in a seafood stew. Topped with a puffed pastry
Applesauce
Sweet Potato or Loaded potato$1.00
Honey-Fried Chicken$16.99Four pieces of tender chicken dipped in our own sweet honey-batter and fried to a golden brown
Grilled Liver and Onions$16.99Tender baby beef liver cooked to perfection. Topped with plenty of sautéed onions
Chicken Key Largo$17.99Key-licious! Chicken breast smothered with sautéed mushrooms, onions, bacon, mozzarella and Colby cheese
Chicken Fingers Basket$14.99Tender chicken fingers served with French fries and your choice of dipping sauce
Buffalo Chicken Wing Basket$14.99Eight wings served with French fries, celery, carrot sticks and bleu cheese dressing
Seafood Combo Basket$17.99Golden-fried shrimp, fish fillets and crispy clam strips. served with French fries and your choice of dipping sauce
Shrimp and Rib Basket$18.99Baby back ribs and hand-breaded, fried shrimp. Served with French fries
Fish Basket$14.99A pub tradition. Batter-fried fish fillets served with French fries and tartar sauce
Shrimp Basket$15.99Hand-breaded shrimp served with French fries and cocktail sauce
Fried Grouper Basket$16.99Fried Grouper bites served with French fries and coleslaw
Shrimp and Scallop Basket$17.99Breaded and fried to order
Salmon$24.99Fresh pan-seared salmon cooked with our house seasoning
Grouper$28.99Fresh grilled or blackened grouper caught in the Gulf
Broiled Haddock$23.99Dive into this fish favorite! A generous-sized flaky haddock fillet broiled to perfection
Crab Cake Dinner$28.99Two homemade jumbo lump crab cakes served with rémoulade
Fried Haddock$23.99Made famous over 50 years ago at the Penfield Tavern. Served with French fries and coleslaw
Fried Shrimp$20.99Everyone’s favorite! Gulf shrimp, breaded and fried to a delicate golden brown, served with our homemade zesty cocktail sauce
Broiled Seafood Platter$29.99A big platter loaded with haddock, shrimp, sea scallops, and deviled crab
Fried Seafood Platter$28.99A big platter loaded with all your favorites, including shrimp, scallops, clams and a fish fillet
Buttermilk Fried Catfish$19.99Served with French fries and coleslaw
Sweet Potato
Loaded baked potato$1.00
Prime Rib of Beef10 oz. $26.99 / 16 oz. $35.99You’ll appreciate the rich flavor and moist, tender taste of slow-roasted aged USDA prime meat ribeye
10 oz. Jack Daniel’s Sirloin$22.99Juicy center-cut sirloin cooked to order and finished with a Jack Daniel’s glaze. Served sizzling, topped with sautéed fresh mushrooms
Jeremiah’s Special 8 oz. Sirloin$19.99This tender cut of beef packs great steak flavor. Cooked to order
Smothered Steak$21.998 oz sirloin with sautéed mushrooms, bacon, cheddar, Monterey Jack cheese. Topped with onion straws
Filet Mignon6 oz. $28.99 / 10 oz. $38.99Most tender of all cuts. Cooked to your specifications. Topped with garlic butter
14 oz. Ribeye$27.99Aged USDA center-cut ribeye
Baby Back Ribs
Full order$22.99
Half order$14.99
14 oz New York Strip$27.99Aged center-cut steak. Cooked to order
Sizzling Steak or Chicken Fajitas
Steak$19.99
Chicken$18.99
Combination$19.99
Beef Chimmi$17.99Made with our 60-year-old recipe - deep fried then topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, black olives. Served with refried beans and rice
Arroz Con Pollo$17.99Grilled chicken over yellow rice, topped with white queso cheese sauce with refried beans
Steak or Chicken Quesadilla
Steak$14.99
Chicken$13.99
Make it Loaded with mushrooms, sautéed onions, bacon and grilled green peppers for an additional$1.99
Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos$14.99Filled with shrimp, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and our new Bang Bang sauce. Served with French fries
Grilled Fish Tacos (3)$14.99Three flour tortillas filled with grilled mahi, lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, and our sweet chile sauce. Served with French fries
Lasagna$17.99Our own recipe, better than your mother's! Served with a house salad
4 Cheese Chicken Parmesan$18.99Breaded chicken breast fried and topped with marinara sauce and our blend of four cheeses: Romano, mozzarella, parmesan, and Monterrey jack. Served over pasta and served with one side choice
Chicken Marsala$18.99Fresh mushrooms in a Marsala wine sauce served with mashed potatoes and a salad
Pepperoni Cheese Pizza$13.9912” pizza loaded with sauce, cheese and pepperoni
Cheese Pizza$12.9912” pizza topped with cheese
Your choice$8.99
White Wine
Prosecco, Franzie & Cratzi, Italy 187 Split$9.95Opens with a lovely aromas of pressed wildflower, ripe apple notes with a lively finish
Moscato, Culitos, Chile$8.95Well-balanced combination of ripe peach, juicy apricot and hints of zesty citrus
Mango Moscato, Culitos, Chile$9.95Layers of ripe mango, with hints of peach and melon with a crisp finish
Riesling, Fritz, Germany$7.95Delightfully fragrant with floral and mineral notes, luscious and fruity with pleasant sweetness
Pinot Grigio, Bel Vento, Italy$8.95Bright and lively aromas and flavors of crisp green apple with zesty citrus notes on the finish
Pinot Grigio, Bordinise, Italy$7.95Opens with crisp citrus notes and green apple with a smooth finish
Sauvignon Blanc, Hooks Bay, NZ$10.95An elegant expression of the Marlborough region, vibrant tropical notes, bright melon, white peach and citrus notes, with a crisp finish
Chardonnay, Estrella River, CA$7.95Aromas and flavors of apple, pear and tropical fruits with a hint of citrus on the finish
Chardonnay, Seal Rock, CA$8.95Aromas and flavors of tropical fruits, caramel apple, honey dew melons with a hint of citrus
Jeremiah’s Rum Runner$9.25Malibu, banana liqueur, amaretto, pineapple juice, meyers floater
Espresso Martini$9.00Titos, Kahlua, Baileys, and espresso
Moscow Mule$11.25Titos, ginger beer, mint, lime juice