Veggie$16.95Veggie $16.95 tomato, onion, bell pepper, olives, mushroom, basil, red sauce, mozzarella
Pepperoni$17.95Pepperoni $17.95 red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni
Meaty Pie$21.95Meaty Pie $21.95 pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon, mozzarella, red sauce, basil
Margherita$17.95Margherita $17.95 wood fire crust, red sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmesan, basil
Buffalo Chicken$19.00Buffalo Chicken $19 buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, banana peppers, scallion, and blue cheese
Classic Cheese$15.95Classic Cheese $15.95 Wood fire crust, red sauce, mozzarella, parmesan
Veggie$16.95
Pepperoni$17.95
Meaty Pie$21.95
Margherita$17.95
Buffalo Chicken$19.00
Classic Cheese$15.95
Hot Honey Pepperoni$18.95
Starters
Boom Boom Shrimp$15.95Boom Boom Shrimp $15.95 Crispy fried shrimp tossed in our creamy sweet-heat Boom Boom sauce and finished with scallions.
Smoked Fish Dip$13.95Smoked Fish Dip $13.95 Served with pico de gallo, pickled jalapeños, lemon, and saltine crackers.
Texas Twinkies$13.95Texas Twinkies $13.95 Jalapeños stuffed with a blend of cheeses, wrapped in bacon and grilled, then topped with sweet BBQ and smoked brisket.
Boom Boom Shrimp$15.95
Boatload Onion Rings$11.95
Big Captain’s Nachos$11.95
Anchor Away Pretzel$13.95
The Crew Sampler Tower$24.95
Smoked Fish Dip$13.95
Peel & Eat Shrimp$13.95/Half Pound
Old Bay Pickle Chips$9.95
Mozzarella Cheese Planks$11.95
Sweet Potato Wedges$10.95
Loaded Guilty Fries$11.95
Texas Twinkies$13.95
Quesadillas
Guilty Quesadilla$15.95Guilty Quesadilla $15.95 Seasoned ground beef, cheddar jack, grilled onions, grilled bell peppers, pico de gallo, and Guilty sauce.
Cheese Quesadilla$10.95Cheese Quesadilla $10.95 Cheddar jack cheese grilled in a flour tortilla.
Boom Boom Shrimp Quesadilla$18.95
Blackened Chicken Quesadilla$14.95
Guilty Quesadilla$15.95
Buffalo Crispy Chicken Quesadilla$15.95
Cheese Quesadilla$10.95
Hot Dogs
Chili Cheese Dog$10.95Chili Cheese Dog $10.95 All-beef hot dog topped with house chili, queso, shredded cheddar, and diced onions.
Beach Dog$8.95Beach Dog $8.95 All-beef hot dog with mustard, ketchup, relish, and diced onions.
Guilty Style Chicago Dog$11.95
Chili Cheese Dog$10.95
Beach Dog$8.95
Smash Burger
Guilty Burger$16.95Guilty Burger $16.95 Two beef patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Guilty sauce on a toasted bun.
Cheeseburger$15.95Cheeseburger $15.95 Two beef patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion on a toasted bun.
Guilty Burger$16.95
Bacon Cheddar Burger$17.95
Grilled Patty Melt$16.95
Cheeseburger$15.95
Philly Steaks
Guilty Philly$16.95Guilty Philly $16.95 Shaved steak with grilled onions, bell peppers, queso, and Guilty sauce on a toasted hoagie roll.
Classic Philly$15.95Classic Philly $15.95 Shaved steak with grilled onions, bell peppers, and melted American cheese on a toasted hoagie roll.
Guilty Philly$16.95
Classic Philly$15.95
Sandwiches + Wraps
Chicken Sandwich$15.95Chicken Sandwich $15.95 Grilled, blackened, or fried chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, onion, and mayo on a toasted bun.
Cuban Sandwich$15.95Cuban Sandwich $15.95 Ham, roasted pork, salami, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard pressed on Cuban bread.
Irb BLT$12.95IRB BLT $12.95 A big beautiful bacon, lettuce, and tomato sandwich with mayo on toasted bread.
Chicken Sandwich$15.95
Real Grouper Sandwich$20.95
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich$15.95
Chicken “Seaser” Wrap$15.95
Cuban Sandwich$15.95
Buffalo Chicken Wrap$16.95
Irb BLT$12.95
Wings + Shrimp
Crispy Shrimp$14.95Crispy Shrimp $14.95 10 shrimp served with ranch or blue cheese, celery
ExtrasExtras Carrots + Celery $4 | 4oz Cup of Blue Cheese Dressing or homemade ranch $3.00 | 2oz Cup of Blue Cheese Dressing or homemade ranch $1.50 | 2oz Cup of Any Wing Sauces $2 | 4 oz any wing sauce $4.00
Caesar Salad$10.95Caesar Salad $10.95 Chopped romaine tossed with Caesar dressing, parmesan, and croutons. Grilled, Blackened, or Crispy Chicken + 5.95 Grilled, Blackened, or Crispy Shrimp + 6.95
Wedge Salad$12.95Wedge Salad $12.95 Crisp iceberg wedge topped with pico de gallo, beer-battered onion rings, blue cheese crumbles, and blue cheese dressing.
Caesar Salad$10.95Grilled, Blackened, or Crispy Chicken
Wedge Salad$12.95
Cactus & Beef Chili$10.95
Sides
Fries$4.95Fries $4.95
Side Caesar Salad$5.95Side Caesar Salad $5.95
Sweet Potato Fries$5.95Sweet Potato Fries $5.95
Fries$4.95
Side Caesar Salad$5.95
Beer Battered Onion Rings$6.95
Sweet Potato Fries$5.95
Desserts
Peanut Butter Pie$6.00Peanut Butter Pie $6.00
Big A** Chocolate Cake$16.00
Classic Key Lime Pie$6.00
Peanut Butter Pie$6.00
Lunch Specials
Guilty Burger$11.95Guilty Burger $11.95 Single patty. Served with fries
Half Cuban$10.95Half Cuban $10.95 with Fries
10 Crispy Shrimp$11.9510 Crispy Shrimp $11.95 with fries and cocktail sauce
Guilty Burger$11.95
Half Cuban$10.95
with Fries$11.9510 Crispy Shrimp
Chicken “Seaser” Wrap$12.95
Late Night Menu
Smoked Fish Dip$6.00Smoked Fish Dip $6.00
Smoked Fish Dip$6.00
Boatload Onion Rings$6.00
Loaded Guilty Fries$6.00
Fried Dill Pickle Chips$6.00
Blackened Chicken Quesadilla$7.00
Guilty Burger and Fries$7.00
1/2 Pound Boneless Wings$7.00
Any Single Hot Dog and Fries$7.00
Guilty Pleasures
Wells$3.00Wells $3
Domestic Drafts$4.00Domestic Drafts $4
House Wines$4.00House Wines $4
Wells$3.00
Domestic Drafts$4.00
House Wines$4.00
Quickies
Fireball$4.00Fireball $4
Dirty Monkey$4.00Dirty Monkey $4
Fireball$4.00
Tullamore Dew Green Tea Shots$5.00
Dirty Monkey$4.00
Guilty Cocktails
Lunazul Margarita$6.00Lunazul Margarita $6
Lunazul Margarita$6.00
Family Brands Old Fashioned$9.00
Walk the Plank
Bacardi$5.00Bacardi $5
Lunazul$5.00Lunazul $5
Tito’s$6.00Tito’s $6
Jack Daniels$6.00Jack Daniels $6
Ford’s Gin$6.00Ford’s Gin $6
Buffalo Trace$7.00Buffalo Trace $7
Bacardi$5.00
Lunazul$5.00
Tito’s$6.00
Jack Daniels$6.00
Ford’s Gin$6.00
Buffalo Trace$7.00
Crowd Pleasers
Pitchers$12.00Pitchers $12
Pitchers$12.00
Beer Buckets Aluminum$18.00
Shared plates will incur a$5 Surcharge**
All-Star Slices
MVP Cheese$10 | Rookie Pepperoni $12
Extras
Carrots + Celery$4.00
Entrees
Snow Crab$35.00/ One Pound / $65.00/ Two Pounds
Grilled or Crispy Chicken
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich$12.95
1/2lb Boneless Wings$10.95
Blackened Chicken Quesadilla$11.95
Caesar with Chicken$10.95
Real Grouper Sandwich$17.95
Signature Cocktails
Blueberry Bramble$11.00Blueberry Bramble $11.00 Ford's Gin, fresh lemon juice, Reàl blueberry, club soda
Guilty Mary$11.00Guilty Mary $11.00 wheatley vodka, filthy bloody mary mix, lemon, lime, olive, & a cocktail shrimp with an old bay rim or Make it a bloody maria!
Guilty Punch$11.00Guilty Punch $11.00 Wicked dolphin coconut rum, raspberry liqueur, banana liqueur, Fresh orange juice, pineapple juice, and a myers's dark rum float
Housemade Crushes$11.00Housemade Crushes $11.00 Orange: Smirnoff Orange, Fresh squeezed orange juice Grapefruit: Deep Eddy Ruby red grapefruit, Fresh squeezed grapefruit
Mezcaloma$12.00Mezcaloma $12.00 Dos hombres mezcal, gran gala, filthy paloma, lime, and club soda
Apple Pie Sour$12.00Apple Pie Sour $12.00 Michter's Rye, fireball, Reàl apple, fresh lemon juice
Jake’s Original Margarita$8.00
Blueberry Bramble$11.00
Guilty Mary$11.00
Tito’s Blackberry Lemonade$10.00
Guilty Punch$11.00
Housemade Crushes$11.00
Mezcaloma$12.00
Apple Pie Sour$12.00
Seaside Classics
Rum Runner$11.00Rum Runner $11.00 wicked dolphin crystal rum, wicked dolphin gold rum, 151 rum, peach schnapps, banana liqueur, blackberry brandy, and fruit juices
Bahama Mama$12.00Bahama Mama $12.00 Myers's Dark Rum, Wicked dolphin coconut rum, orange juice, pineapple juice, and grenadine
Pain Killer$11.00Pain Killer $11.00 ron zacapa 23, pineapple juice, orange juice, coco Reàl, fresh lime juice, and a 151 Floater
Mai Tai$12.00Mai Tai $12.00 Diplom àtico mantuano rum, clement select, gran gala, orgeat syrup, bitters, and fresh lime juice
Yellow Submarine$12.00Yellow Submarine $12.00 Milagro silver, Reàl guava, red bull yellow, and fresh lime juice.
House Fashioned$10.00House Fashioned $10.00 Ft. Old Forester 86 Simple Syrup, Angostura Bitters, & an Orange
Family Fashioned$11.00Family Fashioned $11.00 Ft. Buffalo Trace Brown Sugar Simple Syrup, Black Walnut Bitters, & a Filthy Cherry
Colonial Ties$12.00Colonial Ties $12.00 Ft. Myers's Dark Rum & Old Forester Rye Brown Sugar Simple Syrup, Orange Bitters, Absinthe, & an Orange
Smoked Chocolate$14.00Smoked Chocolate $14.00 Ft. Woodford Reserve Brown Sugar Simple Syrup, Orange Bitters, & Chocolate Bitters
House Fashioned$10.00
Family Fashioned$11.00
Margaritas
Golden Italian$10.00Golden Italian $10.00 Milagro Reposado, Amaretto, and Jake's Coastal Cantina Homemade Margarita Mix
Grand Margarita$15.00Grand Margarita $15.00 Don julio blanco tequila, grand marnier, and jake's coastal cantina homemade margarita mix Substitute Herradura Reposado for NO UPCHARGE!
Spicy Jalapeno$12.00Spicy Jalapeno $12.00 21 Seeds Spicy jalapeno cucumber tequila, gran gala, and jake's coastal cantina homemade margarita mix with a tajin rim
Jake’s Original Margarita$8.00
Golden Italian$10.00
Grand Margarita$15.00
Spicy Jalapeno$12.00
Mojitos / Mules
All American Mule$9.00All American Mule $9.00 Made with Fresh lime, OWEN's Ginger beer, and wheatley craft distilled vodka
Mojito$9.00Mojito $9.00 Bacardi Superior Rum, Mint, Simple Syrup, Lime, & Club Soda