Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

205 Key Deer Blvd, Big Pine Key, FL

Menu (As of 10/30)

Regular / Decaf Coffee

• Sm - 1.70Lg $2.08

Iced Coffee

• Sm - 1.75Lg $2.05

Capuccino

• Sm - 3.50Lg $3.75

Cafe Con Leche

• Sm - 3.60Lg $3.85

Latte

• Sm - 3.60Lg $3.85
• Espresso $2.40

Americano

• Sm - 2.45Lg $2.55

Hot Teas (Black, Green)

• Sm - 1.45Lg $1.70

Chai Latte

• Sm - 3.55Lg $3.90

Unsweetened Iced Tea

• Sm - 1.45Lg $1.75

Frozen Coffee Coolada

• Sm - 4.65Lg $4.95

Frozen Non-Coffee Coolada

• Sm - 5.00Lg $5.35

Soy Milk

• YooHoo $1.35
• Bottled Water $1.50
• Can Soda $1.25
• Juices, Snapple, Vitamin Water $2.00

All American Breakfast

• 1 Egg 4.75 | 2 Eggs - 6.55 | 3 Eggs - 7.50

Eggs, Hashbrowns & Toast

• Atkins $8.25
• 3 Egg Omelets $7.95
• Belgian Waffle $4.75

French Toast

• Side Items $1.95Toast with Butter
• Hashbrown $1.85
• Oatmeal or Grits $3.35
• Bacon, Ham or Sausage $2.75
• Egg $2.00

Pastries and Desserts

• Muffins $3.00
• Butter Croissant $3.00
• Chocolate Croissant $3.00
• Cinnamon Bun $3.00
• Freshly Baked Cookie $1.50

Smoothies

• Sm - 4.65Lg $4.95

Chocolate or Vanilla

• Sm - 5.35Lg $5.65
• Turbo Milkshake LG - 5.25

Bagels Made Fresh Daily

• Single $1.25
• Half-Dozen $7.50
• One Dozen $15.00
• Butter $1.95
• Butter & Jelly or Honey $2.35
• Plain Cream Cheese $2.85
• Flavored Cream Cheese $3.45
• PB & J $2.45
• Nova Lox Spread $4.60

Bagel or Breakfast Sandwich

• One Egg $2.65
• Egg and Cheese $3.45
• Egg and Meat $4.75
• Egg, Cheese and Meat $5.50

Bacon, Ham, or Sausage

• Egg, Cheese and Meat $5.50

Sandwiches

• Grilled Cheese $4.25American, Swiss, Provolone, or Cheddar.
• Lox $9.50
• BLT $5.25
• Grilled Reuben $9.65
• Bella Dawna Panini $7.35
• Cuban $9.95
• NY Club $8.75
• Italian 6 $9.95
• Roast Beef Bomber $10.50
• Manatee Munchie $4.25
• Hamburger $8.00
• Cheeseburger $8.75
• Pulled Pork $6.50

Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo

• Grilled Reuben $9.65
• Bella Dawna Panini $7.35
• Cuban $9.95
• NY Club $8.75
• Italian 6 $9.95
• Roast Beef Bomber $10.50
• Manatee Munchie $4.25
• Hamburger $8.00
• Cheeseburger $8.75
• Pulled Pork $6.50
• Made to Order Sandwiches $6.96From top to bottom just the way you want

Salads

• Chef Salad $8.75
• Cobb Salad $7.95
• Garden Salad $4.75
• Small Salad $2.70

Coffee

• Regular / Decaf Coffee SM - 1.70 LG - 2.08
• Iced Coffee SM - 1.75 LG - 2.05
• Capuccino SM - 3.50 LG - 3.75
• Cafe Con Leche SM - 3.60 LG - 3.85
• Latte SM - 3.60 LG - 3.85
• Espresso $2.40
• Americano SM - 2.45 LG - 2.55
• Hot Teas (Black, Green) SM - 1.45 LG - 1.70
• Chai Latte SM - 3.55 LG - 3.90
• Unsweetened Iced Tea SM - 1.45 LG - 1.75
• Frozen Coffee Coolada SM - 4.65 LG - 4.95
• Frozen Non-Coffee Coolada SM - 5.00 LG - 5.35

Other Beverages

• YooHoo $1.35
• Bottled Water $1.50
• Can Soda $1.25
• Juices, Snapple, Vitamin Water $2.00

Hot Breakfast

• Atkins $8.25
• 3 Egg Omelets $7.95
• Belgian Waffle $4.75

Side Items

• Toast with Butter $1.95
• Hashbrown $1.85
• Oatmeal or Grits $3.35
• Bacon, Ham or Sausage $2.75
• Egg $2.00

Milkshakes

• Smoothies SM - 4.65 LG - 4.95
• Chocolate or Vanilla SM - 5.35 LG - 5.65
• Turbo Milkshake LG - 5.25

Bagel With...

• Butter $1.95
• Butter & Jelly or Honey $2.35
• Plain Cream Cheese $2.85
• Flavored Cream Cheese $3.45
• PB & J $2.45
• Nova Lox Spread $4.60

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe: hours and how to order